Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Haimish is one of my favorite words…it’s just so apt!</p>

<p>We joined a Reform Temple upon moving to the suburbs despite me growing up Conservative and my hubby being VERY Conservative-to-shomer shabbos (but that was for the grandparents, another story!) so I was very relieved when my parents first came to services with us and pronounced it haimish even if it was Reform!</p>

<p>Bashert is another word I just adore. Sorry for digressing.</p>

<p>I will echo yabe’s comments about the big picture. My goal over the past year was to get through with our good relationship intact - we got scarily close to some real fissures over the college admissions process (coupled with the artistic auditions my D went through), and I have to admit it was I who was adding the extra stress. No matter how much I could have said, “If only she would just XYZ,” the bottom line is that she had to be who she was, no matter what wonderful wishes I had for her. </p>

<p>All parents - and especially parents of B students - do need to remember during this time that life will go on and that there are many ways to be happy and successful. For the record, my D came up with her own essay topic about how she developed a relationship with her own imagination - it was a very personal, very sweet essay, very much in her own voice. It came out when she was ready to write it, and I felt that even if it had some flaws, it was a picture of who she was and said what she wanted to say. </p>

<p>So here we are on the other end: we moved her into school on Monday - a day late on Long Island, but really in the long run very successfully. We feel very lucky that all we experienced were some short-term blackouts and a pretty boring weekend in our hotel near campus. We have now driven home and are leaving her to have her new, wonderful adventure.</p>

<p>Best wishes to everyone!</p>

<p>EmmyBet, That is a beautiful story and agree with you and yabe about the big picture. I came too close with younger son about bugging him way too much. He was bright but just did not seem to want to compete in high school. I would get calls from teachers that were frustrated with him because they knew he could be doing better (this was mirroring my admitted frustration).Teachers still seemed to like him though and his teacher who had him for AP Stat and analysis would come to his sports games. This teacher walked out of his volleyball game with me (he was all state) and told me straight up that he was “lazy”-and she said it in a way that should have offended me but I got what she meant and felt she said it because she liked him. I told her though I thought at that point he seemed to think he had other fish to fry. I felt myself really defending him then and coming to grips with the occasional B’s and C’s in high schools (quite different from older A student brother). He’s gone on to do really well in college but just needed some time to really reach his stride.</p>

<p>A favor to ask of you: When my D goes through this process in 3 years, please keep me calm and remind me of all this wisdom. S was so easy to work with in this process and once he honed in on a few details it was smooth sailing. D fights me on everything, all day long. I know I will need to back way off and let her go through her own process, but I will need you guys to hold my hand doing it. Please don’t abandon this thread. </p>

<p>as for the big picture; i noticed this status on my S’s Facebook profile today and think it appropriate to our conversation:</p>

<p>“the girl you just called fat? She is overdosing on diet pills. The girl you just called ugly? She spends hours putting makeup on, hoping people will like her. The boy you just tripped? He is abused enough at home. See that man with the ugly scars? He fought for our country. That guy you just made fun of for crying? His mother is dying. Put this on your status for an hour, if you are against bullying.”</p>

<p>spectrum2 - haimish - with the accent on the first syllable and a long a sound like the word day. So hay mish.</p>

<p>Last ever Back-to-School night tonight. Woo-hoo!!!</p>

<p>Got it, thanks RVM!</p>

<p>Samtalya: I love that! After reading your post I googled “antibullying quote facebook”. I found a variation of the quote you saw on your son’s FB. The page was called “Random Acts of Kindness Today and Anti Bullying”</p>

<p>“A 15 year old girl holds hands with her 1 year old son. People call her a slut, no one knows she was raped at 13. People call another Guy fat. No one knows he has a serious disease causing him to be overweight . People call an old man ugly. No one knew he had a serious injury to his face while fighting for our country in the war. Re-post this if you are against bullying and stereotyping.”
August 4 at 3:19pm</p>

<p>I’m going to share both of these with my S when he comes home from school. I don’t know if he’s seen this. I’m envious Sam, I’m not privy to the content of S’s FB. I wonder if kids around the country posted this kind of thing on their FB pages if it would result in acts of bullying being decreased.</p>

<p>Samtalya: Good for your son for being so compasionate. Your D is at a tough age. Both of my girls got easier around age 16, and it’s been getting better ever since.</p>

<p>I’m very impressed with those of you whose kids have completed applications and essays. I agree with Yabe and Emmy about trying to enjoy this last year with them.</p>

<p>sujormik- I’m sure the essay is great.</p>

<p>We did consult a professional college counselor before my daughter wrote her essay. She helped her to brainstorm ideas and also how to structure the essay. Her advice was to start with a catchy opening (par 1), tell the story (par 2) and then give the personal connection i.e. what did this experience mean to you or how did you grow (par 3). At the end, when you read the essay, it should feel like only your S/D could have written it. </p>

<p>Having this structure really helped by D who struggles a bit with writing. Having these “chunks” breaks it down into manageable pieces.</p>

<p>When my D was done, she sent the essay to her school counselor, who gave here some minimal comments and positive feedback. That made us feel like the essay was done well.</p>

<p>I think the shorter 150 word one for the common app was a bit harder because the space was so limited.</p>

<p>Emmybet: So glad everything went well; you were actually the one on my mind during the week when that area of Long Island was slammed (and apparently much of the surrounding areas there still do not have power)…</p>

<p>samtalya: of course, congratulations…!!! and we will all deal with your daughter with you; remember I had one like that too…</p>

<p>rvm: I have found it hard to keep up with all the different forums and threads so pls forgive me for not answering your Elon move-in questions on that forum…another poster, Ratzer, posted a very comprehensive move-in report on the move-in tips thread that I had started awhile back if you wanna check it out…</p>

<p>suffice it to say that move-in was great; everything worked like a charm…if anyone has any specific questions, please feel free to ask…</p>

<p>my D LOVES her classes (first time ever) and is already feeling very comfortable (so shocking to us, her parents…lots of history there not appropriate for online consumption)
Actually waiting for the other shoe to drop…not pessimistic, just realistic…</p>

<p>yabeyabe: thanks for your PM…I’m having a bit of trouble with a new computer with replies but it was so thoughtful of you to think of us last week…earthquakes, hurricanes, road collapses, etc…</p>

<p>The Hillel Intern Engagement program has been amazing for her (in particular); one of the girls has reached out to her and they have really “clicked”; she has become a great go-to person for alot of information, not just about Hillel…</p>

<p>So far, so good…I’ll keep you posted…</p>

<p>YAY!!! So happy for rodney’s D!!! And for rodney!!! Wow, how far we’ve come in 2 years. So glad you all are safe and happy.</p>

<p>Rodney, where could I find that thread on move-in tips? I would love to start fixating on that now for next year! Thanks. </p>

<p>I love all the advice about keeping the essays in the voice of your child. We will try our best to do that. I am trying to keep out of the process as much as possible, but dd is just not one to work hard as she is not worried about getting in to schools that she likes. I think she is right, as she is not “reaching beyond the stars”, but I still would like her to light the fire and get things done earlier than later on the writing and apps, so that all she has left is to concentrate on her portfolio and statement to go with that. It is so hard to not be a control freak sometime. </p>

<p>School started yesterday and already she had band practice last night, and auditions for theater today–I expect it will not stop until she graduates. The good thing is that she has great classes, some hard, but all interesting and the right choices for her. She was able to figure out that she did not want another regular math class and instead is taking statistics and the stats teacher (whom dd had last year) told her that even she thought it was a really smart move. It also opened up dd’s schedule so she can do a personal finance class, which is something we really wanted her to take.</p>

<p>Sorry for writing so much, but sitting here all day with workers fixing problems from the storm: lost our attic fan and some water there, but being replaced today; fixing a crack in the foundation, which we found after we put in a french drain and sump pump a week before the storm (yippee); measuring for new carpet for the basement from the previous flood, etc. The good news is though that we have been renovating our kitchen and the counter tops are also going in today–so waiting for that service person too! Hope everyone has their electricity back! We tossed all our frozen food and cold stuff too. Although I was sad to waste all the stuff, I am kind of excited that my new french door fridge will get fresh food and I will be able to try to organize it. (Any suggestions as to how to organize those two freezer drawers would be great!) OK, that is it. Bye!</p>

<p>So happy to just scan through and read how Emmeybet’s D and rodney’s D are doing! All great news so far!</p>

<p>My son started his sophomore year and he is off with a running start, meaning that within less than 2 weeks one very exciting opportunity was already offered to him. All that I can say is that he was given the chance to do something that he would NEVER have gotten at a large school. We are very happy about it.</p>

<p>phillyartmom:</p>

<p>There is a school specific one on the Elon forum (which is the one I was referring to) and there is another one on the parents forum…I will look for and link in an edit…</p>

<p>Well, that was easy; it was highlighted at the top of the parents forum</p>

<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1185076-move-day-tips.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1185076-move-day-tips.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>As a side note to “haimish”, amongst German Jews, the term was “Gemütlichkeit”, a word you will often see in descriptions of late 19th Century Viennese life (well, as often at any rate as you happen to read about that era). </p>

<p>It’s still used in some circles where perhaps Yiddish words might sound too colloquial and Freud discussed the word in his paper, “The Uncanny,” where he traced the evolution of the German word Heimlich which was once almost synonymous with Gemütlichkeit.</p>

<p>For those of you whose students are still casting around for a distinctive essay topic, a college essay can be about almost anything. My older daughter answered Colgate’s essay prompt, “What one thing would you bring to campus?” with a long humorous piece on the importance and usefulness of lip balm and chapstick. My son wrote about his misadventures learning to drive a stick shift and segued into heurestic education and learning in general. My youngest wrote a semi- humorous an often self-deprecating piece about her extremely dimuntive height and what coping with it taught her about life and learning from it.</p>

<p>Those topics gave them an opportunity to present their own unique voices and points of view.</p>

<p>Rodney, Emmy and Northeast, how wonderful that the beginning of this school year has been so successful. I love all the great positive stories.</p>

<p>Phillyartmom, mazal tov on the new kitchen. eat in good health.</p>

<p>spectrum, my S is a martial artist and has been involved with anti bullying for quite a while. in fact it is the basis for a business proposal essay that he submitted with his app. he is quite serious in carrying out this business and hopefully will successfully implement while in college. </p>

<p>as for facebook, my kids were only allowed to sign on if i was their friend. some of you may think that is too intrusive, but i feel that it is my best way of monitoring where there head is at. also important to let them know when they post something stupid that might bite them later in the college app process or job interview. i fired one of my employees, because of something she posted on facebook and i want to make sure my kids understand the amount of exposure and the seriousness of what they post and who may see it. so maybe that is overbearing, but my kids accept these conditions and the guidance. (and they have been saved with posting some dumb stuff!)</p>

<p>RVM, thanks for the move in tips. there is also a great thread on what to pack that i copied and pasted in word.</p>

<p>Dropped my S1 off at school yesterday. He’s happy, I’m adjusting, and I’ve now decided that not only do I need appropriate schools for the jewish B student, but they can’t be too far from home as well. Don’t know how I’m going to do it w/ my youngest.</p>

<p>Glad to hear all the good news and sorry to hear of Irene’s continued frustrations. Just trying to enjoy the last weekend of the summer. This is a big year and I am so excited to see how the road turns. </p>

<p>The final list is (drum roll please) - Boston U, Rutgers, U of Maryland and Fordham. Any free apps he has received, will also be done. Decision day is so far away and maybe a smaller LAC might be more interesting.</p>

<p>Rodney: I’m glad to hear that your daughter is doing well. I hope that the other shoe doesn’t drop, but I understand how you feel.</p>

<p>Umich: Glad the drop-off went well.</p>

<p>Phillyartmom: Congrats on the new kitchen. </p>

<p>Cherryhill: I’m glad to see BU on your list. I’m really impressed with the school so far. My D moved in early to participate in a large freshman community service project. It’s a great way to meet people and acclimate to college.</p>

<p>Hi, this thread is exactly what I need. Just hoping to get updated info from it. My D will be applying this fall. Her average would be a b+ but early in hs she did have some c’s. Her SAT was 1560. She is jewish and we live in nyc and I hope that she can go to school within driving distance. Even if that means a 5 hour drive.</p>