<p>See if your son is willing to take the test again. No practice, just one more shot to see if his scores will go up.</p>
<p>D took a Princeton review class the summer before junior year. We knew going in that math would be her weakness and reading her strength. She took the SAT in Sept and scored in the 500’s in Math and 650 on reading. We then hired a math tutor and for the rest of her junior year she was tutored in math for the SAT and ACT. She did nothing for reading and writing. She studied a bit for science (ACT) on her own.</p>
<p>By the spring, her math went up to 610 (although her ACT never budged from 23.) She was done with math and her reading stood at 680 and writing at 660.</p>
<p>She had to decide whether to take one more stab at the SAT in June. Other than go to bed early, she did absolutely no preparation. We knew her math would likely go down, but figured it was worth a shot to see if reading and writing could go up.</p>
<p>In the end it was totally worth it! Her writing went up by 10 to 670. However her reading went up by 40 points to 720!! So in the end, she went from a 1290 to a 1330. A 1950 to a 2000!</p>
<p>So in my mind there is a a certain random element to these tests. My daughter really did not have the time or inclination to study for reading, but she was able to set aside the time on a Saturday morning to give it one last </p>
<p>This analogy may be meaningless to anyone but me, but here goes. I have had a lifelong weight problem and been a lifelong dieter in response. I have a goal weight based on charts and stuff that I am not likely to ever reach. At one point I talked to my doctor, who said, losing some (versus “all”) is still better than not losing anything. “We may also just have a natural point at which our body is where it belongs and to continue to beat yourself up for staying at it is just counterproductive.”</p>
<p>My point? MAYBE where he’s at right now is just where he’s meant to be. </p>
<p>Like I said, maybe a stupid comparison, but maybe rings true for someone.</p>
<p>Since this is the B students thread - which naturally has to include thoughts about reaching - I will say once again that if a kid (or a parent) has to push too much just to make the cut at a school, it’s definitely necessary to think about fit. My B+/A- D did ace her ACT fall of senior year and added reaches … then had a very stressful decision process because she got into a couple of them. She chose an honors college in a less selective school (as I’ve said, also because of her artistic admission), but honestly I still can’t say what is right for her. However, we did have a significant situation of “be careful what you wish for.”</p>
<p>I know merit money is an issue, too. As it happens, she got great merit money at the “lesser” school she is now going to. So many details to balance here. I guess my message is to let the details be what they are. And I would be sad if anyone was having a strained relationship with their child over some points on a test. Your relationship is worth more than any of that. I am more and more convinced all the time that kids are hard enough on themselves in this process and don’t need parents to add more disapproval.</p>
<p>Spectrum- the fact that your son has already increased 100 points to achieve over 700 in math is wonderful! But as someone noted, there is some random variation in the test scores- at 700 ish he may well have maxed out his math score and therefore random variation may result in a lower score if he takes the test again. I can see where that would be frustrating.</p>
<p>again if the CR is the part he needs to raise, it is really very difficult IMHO. Though I think the writing score can be very prone to variation depending on the reader and how much the student writes (longer is better). In my own D’s case, she took SAT twice: her CR went down -30, math +10, and writing +130 points!! We decided no more testing (even though it would have been nice to get that CR score above 600) since it seemed like a diminishing return. math was stable, and writing had been maxed. Unless she would have been willing to put effort in to studying vocab, the CR was not likely to reach 600.</p>
<p>Spectrum, give him a couple of days off to cool down and then have him try again. If he still is frustrated, see if he will take the test cold and stop all the practicing. I would hate for him to lose confidence and strain your relationship.</p>
<p>spectrum - wonderful points made here about not pushing him to the point that it damages your relationship, makes him feel that you are disappointed in him, etc. And sujormik - that actually is a decent analogy - that people do have a “setpoint” - whether with their weight or with test scores - that all the work in the world won’t get it to budge any further.</p>
<p>But - given that we are talking about October 1 - I’d still encourage him to take the SAT that he is signed up for - and just see what happens. If he improves - great and if he doesn’t - he is done. If he can stomach a little more practice - before then - great - and if he has reached the end of his rope - then he can just take it based on where his skills are now.</p>
<p>Rooting for you - hope he does take it and shows the improvement you are seeking.</p>
<p>spectrum - I know how hard it is not to push our kids. You probably think he can do better if he studies some more and gives it one last shot. I was in a similar situation with D. She took the ACT, did great. She said she wanted to take it again to raise her composite by 1 point. As the ACT test date approached I kept telling her if she wanted to raise it she needed to start studying. Finally she said she didn’t have anything left in her for standardized testing, her score is great, even though she originally wanted to try to improve it, she is happy with it and just wants to focus on her applications now. As much as I wanted to push her, I let it go.</p>
<p>So D has been working on her common app essay and I am not sure how I feel about it. OK, I realize it’s not about me…but…LOL! She is an excellent writer, so good that her friends have been asking her to look at their common app essays for her opinions/edits, etc. As she tells me each kids topic, I think, wow, deep topic or intellectual essay, or life changing event being written about… My D’s essay is about a personalilty trait and how at first it was perceived by others as a negative, but it eventually led her to what she wants to be. She is really telling a story with this essay. </p>
<p>On the other hand when I hear of these deep topics, I think, how deep can a 17 year old really be? I am conflicted on this. Last year her AP Lang teacher looked at her first draft of her essay and loved it. She is taking it to her AP Lit teacher soon for comments. It has been edited substantially since then. It was originally over 700 words, she now has it down to just over 500. </p>
<p>Is she going in the right direction with this? Should she find something more meaningul? It is VERY difficult for me to comment on anything she writes. She is very possesive/territorial about her writing, so I have held my tongue.</p>
<p>I say keep holding it. I do not believe it is the topic of the essay that matters but the way it is written, how much it conveys the student. It is answering the question: Would this be a student we want to have here? Maybe any Ivy wants kids to explain how they’ve already cured a disease, but I think in general most schools want someone thoughtful, caring, maybe a little funny or a little unusual in how they see things, and that can come through on any topic.</p>
<p>Your D’s essay sounds like my D2’s - she wrote simply about how she learned to understand her own imagination and how much she enjoys it. I suggested at one point being a little more clear that while she has this very unconventional side that she is confident about balancing it with the conventional world. </p>
<p>D1 is not so imaginative, and she told a pretty straight story about how she likes to approach problems and find solutions. She decided against some of the “cool” challenging experiences she’d had because she though they would look pretentious.</p>
<p>I know the feeling of “other kids’ essays are way cooler than my kid’s” but in the end they just have to be themselves and feel happy with it. That’s all I asked my girls when they said they thought their essays were done. And we figured, if they were rejected, then it was just bad luck or they simply didn’t belong at those schools.</p>
<p>Mdmom, I agree with Emmybet. If your daughter’s essay is well-written and really reflects who she is, the topic is fine. Let her keep ownership of it.</p>
<p>Spectrum: I would try giving your son a few days to cool off, then asking him to keep practicing and take the October test if the tutor thinks he can improve his scores. This is a tough situation. Good luck.</p>
<p>MDmom, your daughter’s essay sounds perfect. a very wise person told me that the essay should be a story so that admissions gains a sense of the writer. sounds like she is on the right track.</p>
<p>ok calm me down and advise. S goes to guidance counselor with his counselor eval form for E and told her he already requested transcript through naviance. He also gave her his completed app with notes of pages for her to look at so that she could get to know him better. the transcript request has been in for a few weeks. he asked about all the test scores on naviance which are incomplete. She tells him that they haven’t uploaded all the new test scores or rankings. (haven’t loaded test scores since last february, what does that tell you) she told S not to worry about score reporting since she doesn’t do that; it is done directly from the testing services. well on the E counselor form it asks for the GC to fill in the scores.</p>
<p>more importantly, she said she won’t fill out the form or deal with the transcript yet until she has what she called the official meeting with her seniors in the first couple of weeks in Oct. when she will call him down to discuss his college choices. HUH lady, he just gave you his completed ED app!! S explained that early decision is Nov 1 and he wants to make sure that his info is in before. GC was pretty care free about this. ugh. i want to scream at her. </p>
<p>so when do i get involved? now? first week in oct?</p>
<p>Sorry, samtalya–remind me of a few key factors.
How many years has she had the job?
how many other seniors is she responsible for?</p>
<p>If she’s a rookie i’d keep a closer eye on her vis-a-vis deadlines. Also, if the school has a fairly large group of ED-inclined kids, i’d keep a close eye on her. You’re from NJ (so am I) so I get the concern about wanting to be proactive about all this. I recommend sitting back for at least the next two weeks–although if there’s a way to get him in on his senior mtg earlier than later, definitely push for that. Sounds like the school’s protocol is to wait for that. Luckily ours is held in March/April of Junior year…although I confess I was underwhelmed by it, as (it sounds like) you will be–we’d already done all the visits, choosing ED, etc., and meeting with her was a formality/rubber stamp.</p>
<p>Re. test scores: I know you self-report scores on the academic part of the common app, and that you can request a copy of the scores be sent to the college from ETS–the fact that they aren’t in Naviance and/or she might not put them directly on the E form isn’t as huge a deal, since the college will still get them from that other (official) source. </p>
<p>It sounds like she feels that mid-September to Nov. 1 is a long time, and not to worry. As I said, if she’s a veteran, she might be right–if she’s a rookie, she might be naive–but either way, I still wouldn’t kick up a fuss just yet, especially if NO ONE’s ED gets sent in this quickly at your school. It would be great to know it’s all in by Oct. 1st, but doesn’t sound like that’s going to happen.</p>
<p>she is a veteran. large public high school. i am sure there will be other Eds. think it is a little silly for her to have to meet with S again to start the process since he went in today with everything she could possibly want.</p>
<p>the school is having a meeting for parents tomorrow on how to use naviance to request transcript, deadlines, visits etc. S asked if i need to go and she said no. guess we have it all covered!</p>
<p>ok patience for the next two weeks. maybe he will be one of the first called down due to the fact i married an “A!”</p>
<p>samtalya - I think that I would attend the meeting and use that opportunity to ask questions about the ED procedures. This may provide you with reassurance that it will be taken care of.</p>
<p>Something our high school did might be helpful:</p>
<p>Students attached a self-addressed, stamped post card to each application turned in to the GC. She mailed the post card at the same time she sent off each application packet. We would get the post card and know things had been taken care of.</p>
<p>Samtalya, I would have your son email the GC a bit before October 1, something along the lines of “could you please make sure I have given you everything needed to complete my ED application packet because it needs to be mailed in the next few days?” He can make it sound like he is doublechecking his own thoroughness so as not to get her dander up…and my guess is that if she is actually checking his ED application packet, she will just finish it up to get it off her desk.</p>
<p>If she doesn’t respond within a few days, then time is becoming severely of the essence and I would ratchet up my contact with her to the point of having your son camping out in her office by about October 12!</p>
<p>samtalya: Wow, I live on another planet, we have no senior meeting that I know of, we have no naviance and S just filled in a request to get his info sent and it was good as done. So taking it from an alien my first thought was to schmooze the counselor and probably your best opportunity would be at that meeting so I would attend and try and get some face time in a very pleasant way. I would also try and question other parents from prior years to find out if there is reason for concern. If you are seriously coming up against your ED deadline I would make a phone call or request a meeting within about three weeks of the deadline if nothing seemed to be happening. If its a large school, a seasoned counselor and things get done I think I would sit on it until then. But I love the postcard suggestion!</p>
<p>mdmom: I also think your daughter is on track if the essay is true to who she is. I think that sometimes the loftier topics are also more cliche and less personal. If the writing is good and it capture a piece of who she is, she has probably done well. I think that different reviewers are looking for different things but since there is no way of knowing what an individual reviewer will be impressed by the best our kids can do is show who they are.</p>
<p>On the SAT: A day really does make a difference. Socaldad I really appreciate what you said about accolades about achievements. S2 has surpassed my expectations and has also lived in the shadow of S1 since they have had many of the same teachers. I’m sure I don’t compliment him enough on his achievement. As for the difficulty with increasing CR scores I’m sure that is true but since the first score was nearly cold and the second was below the first I had hoped that coaching would provide tools for some improvement. Even an increase of 20 points would be significant (that would be just 10 above the first score.). I agree we don’t want to strain our relationship at home over this. However what jumped out at me was my S’s knee jerk reaction that he was done. He had been onboard until yesterday. I am sure he wouldn’t be retaking if my H and I hadn’t pursuaded him to but he seemed to buy in completely. For me that sudden reaction of throwing his hands up and giving up was more disturbing to me than actually coming to a well thought out decision to stop. That is what made me think that parenting was in order. College can be rough he can’t throw up his hands and quit when things are difficult. (Which in all fairness he has not done in HS). Anyway, his tutor called him this morning as he was getting ready for school. I didn’t hear the conversation but from what I can tell is that after a break today he is back on the program. Today he had a friend over after school and for a while, I think that helped. This could be a long three weeks.</p>
<p>Boys, love the postcard idea. Maybe I would amend it to. send a quick email when it is done. it seems that is the way the hs is now communicating.</p>
<p>i think what i will do if S doesn’t get his official appointment by oct 3, i will have him “camp out” as you say. when he does get that appt, i will have him find out what she thinks is her timing and bring up how she will notify when it is sent. if there isn’t a satisfactory answer, then i will pounce.</p>
<p>for now i will take deep breaths and let S handle it. (one rotor coming off my helicopter parenting :)</p>
<p>samtalya - if you have naviance - you don’t need a postcard. You just log into Naviance - look for the tab that says transcripts - it should show the college names - the date the request was made - and it will say pending and then sent. So - you have a record of when it was requested and when it was sent out. There is also a tab that says “colleges I am applying to” and this also lists the same type of info.</p>
<p>samtalya: I think it all depends on your HS. At our school, I’ve been told by a neighbor whose kids are older than mine, that you have to be on top of your GC. I saw the lack of urgency with some of DD’s friends (who didn’t have parents like me – good or bad, depends on how you look at it!). I would also go to the meeting and use it as an opportunity to talk to the GC - either understand the process better or push. I am surprised that they don’t want to get your DS “out of the way” since he is so on top of things. One less kid to worry about, you know? DD had an early action deadline that I was fearful that our GC was going to miss - I called (or emailed, I cant remember) to offer my FED EX account #! After being an involved parent (and doing TONS of volunteering) since my kids were in kindergarten, I wasn’t going to lay off during such a crucial time.</p>
<p>Just so you all don’t think I’m completely over the top here (LOL, isn’t that a requirement on CC?), DD is completely advocating for herself at college!</p>