Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>My D applied to Pitt for the reasons RVM mentioned. I “discovered” it on CC. It was her first acceptance, which was a nice lift. She liked a lot of things about the school, but Pittsburgh couldn’t compete with Boston (sorry, Levrim).</p>

<p>Pizzagirl, your son’s Hillel experience sounds great. My D2 has not made it to Hillel yet, but she’s making a lot of Jewish friends, and she says it’s nice to meet so many other Jewish kids. </p>

<p>RVM: It’s great that your son is almost finished his last essay. </p>

<p>So far, my daughter loves BU. She’s made lots of friends and likes her classes. She really loves being in the city, which was one of her top priorities. Two years ago, she picked this school out of the Fiske guide and asked to go visit. It felt right from our first visit, and still looks like her best fit.</p>

<p>Rutgers isn’t mentioned much on this page, but I thought I’d share since I know there must be a lot of NJ readers–Rutgers announced yesterday that they will accept approximately 4% fewer students for next fall compared to this fall for the New Brunswick campus. The reason is overcrowding on campus–fewer students moving off campus or transferring out, and more students accepting the offer of admission. According to the article I read, 200-250 students who would have been accepted to Rutgers will get rejection letters instead. Newark and Camden are not affected.</p>

<p>I would like to hear more about Rutgers too. It seems like most people who live in NJ don’t want to go there. Why doesn’t it get the love that, say, Penn State does in PA? What are peoples experiences and/or impressions of Rutgers? My husband keeps asking whether we should consider it for D, but I keep saying if no one in NJ wants to go there, there must be something wrong with it. Any info?</p>

<p>pamom, we are in NJ, but we do not have children at Rutgers. My children have plenty of friends that go there. I do not specifics through them, but I have asked a parent about Rutgers-NB and she has one child there now and one who recently gaduated. Plenty of students love the school and do want to go there. </p>

<p>Some of the negatives are being crowded on buses to get from one place to another and sometimes that can make it hectic to get to class, but that is not what I heard from parents with kids there. They are happy overall with the school. I have heard that some programs have been cut, but I don’t know specifics. This is just what I was told by a parent who has had 2 kids there over a span of the last 6 years.</p>

<p>We did not consider Rutgers because we feel a small school is better suited for our children. We did not want our children sitting in large lecture style classes as freshmen. Additionally, we knew that we were not going to get merit or financial aid grants to attend and we feel this school is so expensive (even instate pricing). Our younger child is attending a private school for a similar cost to Rutgers instate tuition.</p>

<p>Just to add, we did not want our children attending research focused universities.</p>

<p>Remember the Yogiism, “nobody goes there anymore–it’s too crowded?” That can be said for Rutgers. DD was accepted to Rutgers, but really only applied there because I made her. (Rutgers is in state for us.) A LOT of kids from our HS go there, and DD wanted to go someplace where she wouldn’t know so many kids. I tried to explain to her that when there are over 27,000 full time undergrads in New Brunswick, the 50 or so kids she would know wouldn’t even be noticeable, but she wouldn’t hear it. </p>

<p>It is a very large school–the New Brunswick center has 4 campuses, and you need to take a bus between them. It is very common to live on one NB campus and have classes on another. So that means making sure you leave enough travel time to get to class. The bus service is very good, but still. On the other hand, the 4 New Brunswick campuses are very different–College Ave is very urban, while Cook/Douglass is very green–so there is something for everyone.</p>

<p>Also, let’s face it, most NJ kids who go away to college want to get out of NJ. It’s not necessarily against Rutgers in particular, it’s a bias against NJ in general. Because Rutgers is centrally located, it is no more than an hour away for the majority of NJ kids who go there. Many kids want to be farther away from home than that. NJ sends more high school grads out of state than any other state in the country.</p>

<p>There have been budget cuts over the past few years–same as at many large flagship universities. Bad press from the Tyler Clementi suicide hasn’t helped.</p>

<p>There is a lot of school spirit surrounding the football and basketball teams. I have taken my S, who is in middle school, to a few games and he loves going. Rutgers used to be considered a safety school for NJ kids, but it has become much more competitive in recent years. Some of the programs, especially Pharmacy, are very hard to get into. </p>

<p>Two kids on my block attend there–one boy, one girl, both Jewish, the girl is Orthodox–attend and love it. They have a great Hillel.</p>

<p>If your D can handle a school as big as Rutgers, it’s worth taking a look at.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>We did not hear this word for word, but our kids did say that they did not want to go to a school with similar types of students that they went to hs with. They wanted a completely different type of student body. They just made an assumption that it was too much of “more of the same”.</p>

<p>It was ironic to read “no one in NJ wants to go there” the day after Rutgers announced it was accepting fewer freshman for next year because it has become overcrowded, with over 58,000 kids at its various schools.</p>

<p>Eastcoast and Northeast have stated the actual facts very well (the reputed quote from New Jersey resident Yogi Berra which also came to my mind).</p>

<p>I would add that Rutgers is hurt by 2 superficially contradictory facts: NJ is, on average, a very affluent state and Rutgers is more expensive in state than some competitors. Many affluent New Jerseyans are willing to afford both private schools (for example, Muhlenberg, with many more NJ kids than PA) and OOS flagships which are “not that much more” than Rutgers and, in kids’ minds, not too close to home like Rutgers or too far (Penn State, UMCP, Delaware).</p>

<p>With only 7% OOS students it appears that non-New Jersey-ites are not exactly flocking to Rutgers. </p>

<p>What is interesting to compare is that most PA students do seem to prefer their in-state publics to the out-of-state publics, even though a lot of their HS classmates will be at the in-state schools. I recently read an article in Pittsburgh magazine which listed the colleges in order of how many students sent their SAT scores there. I don’t have the issue handy, but Penn State was huge! The OOS public that PA students applied to most often was U Delaware; second place went to U MD College Park. I can’t remember when I’ve heard a PA parent saying their student was applying to Rutgers. Just curious why it seems to be unappealing.</p>

<p>Pamom, your OOS number is low. According to the web site, about 15% is OOS.</p>

<p>I recently read a similar article about where SAT scores were sent. 43% of NJ students sent their SAT scores to Rutgers. The top OOS schools were Penn State and UDel.</p>

<p>that’s interesting- princeton review says Rutgers has 7% OOS and college board says it has 8% OOS. Perhaps that is old info. A lot of state schools have recently increased OOS in order to get those higher tuition dollars.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I think that the above will explain a reason for this:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>As recently as 3 years ago (maybe even 2 years ago) there were several more really good OOS public options that ranged from less expensive to quite a bit less expensive than Rutgers for in-state tuition. I do feel that has changed for the B/B+ students with average to somewhat above average SATs (speaking only about public Us). For the A student with superior scores, merit aid could be awarded at some instate or out of state public Us that could change costs and would need to compare.</p>

<p>pamom, I am actually not sure as to whether you were discusssing an increase in the number of OOS students, or increase in OOS costs. </p>

<p>I am discussing the increase in costs of OOS public Us that I think are now making Rutgers more appealing to some instate students.</p>

<p>^^i think NE mom has hit the nail on the head. While Rutgers is on the high side for in- state students costwise, it has become more economical than attending many comparable OOS publics. </p>

<p>The exception to that rule seems to be in the SUNY system. Total COA for OOS is similar to in-state COA for Rutgers ( if not less)</p>

<p>Rutgers for OOS students will not draw the PA students who can pay less for Penn State or even UDel.</p>

<p>I agree that the SUNYs are nearly the same in cost today (perhaps more, perhaps less depending upon the school and merit aid). Here are the costs for SUNY New Paltz as a comparison: [SUNY</a> New Paltz - Student Accounts: Tuition and Fees](<a href=“http://www.newpaltz.edu/student_accounts/tuition.cfm]SUNY”>http://www.newpaltz.edu/student_accounts/tuition.cfm)</p>

<p>Quick estimate of Rutgers instate:</p>

<p><a href=“Student ABC | Rutgers University Finance and Administration | University Finance and Administration”>Student ABC | Rutgers University Finance and Administration | University Finance and Administration;

<p>^I see it took to me a survey. It said without books, more expensive meal plan and living there, it was about 24,400 with fees (instate). To be sure, try the survey if interested.</p>

<p>Using the OOS student percentage for Rutgers or any flagship to weigh its appeal to OOS students is unwise. For example, Rutgers’ OOS percentage is higher than Ohio State, UCLA and Texas–but that does not mean it is more attractive to OOS students than they are. In some cases, such as NC, OOS percentages are capped by law; to avoid similar caps, other schools may do the same informally. Conversely, some state schools will publicly (Vermont) or privately seek to boost their OOS % to attract more tuition income.</p>

<p>It could also be argued that a low OOS percentage reflects such great instate student loyalty that little room is left for OOS kids, but that, too, requires closer examination of such factors as comparative tuitions, OOS admissions selectivity, geographic proximity, etc. </p>

<p>In many cases, I suspect the relative attractiveness to kids comes down to sports reputation; party reputation; weather; campus attractiveness; and being more than an hour best less than 12 from home. For parents, I think it is comparative tuitions and driving range.</p>

<p>The SUNY/Rutgers comparisons hit the nail on the head for us. Given that lack of merit aid from all but one of the schools my D was accepted to, we put Rutgers and SUNY on equal footing, finance-wise.</p>

<p>RE SUNY schoools, Binghamton has only 8% OOS according to one source, despite its very modest OOS tuition, excellent academics and, I believe, lesser selectivity OOS than IS. Perhaps its lack of sports visibility or party rep reduce OOS applications, as I have not seen anything suggesting a cap on OOS kids.</p>

<p>Has anyone seen a reputable anonymous poll of students’ priorities in selecting colleges?</p>

<p>Binghamton is up to 16% OOS <a href=“http://www2.binghamton.edu/admissions/pdf/premier-public.pdf[/url]”>http://www2.binghamton.edu/admissions/pdf/premier-public.pdf&lt;/a&gt; plus another 9% international. this is an increase over what it had previously been. the figures are as of June 2010 – giving the trend, i wouldn’t be surprised if they are even higher now.</p>

<p>i think the increase has been due to 2 things – 1) OOS realizing what a bargain it is (it’s gotten a lot more press about being a great buy over the last couple of years with the downturn in the economy) and 2) i’ve heard that they were giving admission preference to OOS (i assume to increase the OOS dollars coming in though i don’t know of them ever expressly saying that).</p>

<p>ditto to the above responses to rutgers. S wanted to go south, so he didn’t even consider, but he has many friends there now and more that will apply for this year. Like yabe said, it is very costly for in state and at that point it is easier to look at other schools.</p>

<p>Thanks unbelievablem. In all aspects of admissions, there seem to be lots of different stats for the same schools. Here is the August 2011 list I was referring to, which might be helpful to others (if it is accurate): [College</a> Admissions: Which State Schools Give an Edge to Out-of-State Students - The Daily Beast](<a href=“College Admissions: Which State Schools Give an Edge to Out-of-State Students”>College Admissions: Which State Schools Give an Edge to Out-of-State Students)</p>