Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>samtalya - one thought that may help you - the Nov.1 ED deadline is for the student’s application. If the transcript arrives a few days beyond that deadline - you are still going to be ok. Colleges do give high schools some leeway here. But hopefully they will have it out well before Nov. 1.</p>

<p>PRJ: We had a problem with the primary school (K-2) and 3rd grade in the elementary school as well. Don’t even get me started.</p>

<p>RE: Columbus Day - not all colleges cancel classes for Columbus Day, so your student needs to check. UD has classes that day, for example. (My sister got married on the Sunday night of Columbus Day weekend and she had out of town guests that worked places that didn’t close on Columbus Day, including my brother in Boston).</p>

<p>Samtalya: I would call the GC about the transcript and get a date/deadline. But that’s me. I’m sometimes too pushy especially when it comes to deadlines. However, the email did ask if your question was answered and it wasn’t! I am impressed about the process there. We don’t have that.</p>

<p>Call me a glutton for punishment but I stopped with DS at major college fair here on LI yesterday on the way home from our UMD/UD trip (but I did let him sleep as soon as we got in the car in Newark, DE, and he didn’t wake up until we hit Brooklyn!). But we had a very specific goal: meet the local admissions rep for the colleges he was interested in. He was fine with that and perky (more than me because he got to sleep!) So we met: Miami, RPI, Tulane, UMD (we didn’t make the gen admissions session on Fri). Also, Wash Univ was there (late addition), but the woman at the booth, who said she has two kids at Wash U, sounded just like a parent and not an admissions person so she wasn’t really helpful. Stopped by Binghamton booth, but it was packed (as expected); the guy was basically just handing out brochures. So DS registered interested at these schools (again) by filling out cards and he now has the emails for these adcoms and will email them all this week. Despite the mob scene, we were out of there in an hour.</p>

<p>University of Alabama was there (not mobbed) and I told DS about the great merit aid they give. He wasn’t impressed… Alabama? Why would I go to Alabama? LOL.</p>

<p>Several years ago the theme of our elementary school’s winter concert was ethnic diversity. The students were all supposed to wear a banner declaring themselves Irish American, Italian American, etc. My family originated from Eastern Europe and everyone left 100 years ago, before WWI. I feel absolutely no kinship to Poland, Russia, Hungary, etc, and certainly was not going to allow my D to stand up in front of the school declaring herself to be a hyphenated American anything when my grandparents were certainly not viewed as citizens of their country of origin. My family was kicked out of these countries! I suggested Brooklyn-American, NJ-American, Bronx-American, which is where my kids’ grandparents were born. I also suggested African American, since some of my grandfather’s family went to South Africa (loved the idea of a white kid declaring herself to be African American), or Galician-American, but of course there is no country called Galicia. She ended up wearing a banner that said American.</p>

<p>Samtalya: I understand your frustration. Our county has 12 HSs and they don’t release official transcripts and class rank until 10/1 each year. When the state flagship changed their priority deadline to 11/1, it made things very difficult for the guidance departments, but they still managed to send all the transcripts on time.</p>

<p>It sounds like this is out of the GC’s hand. I’m sure that the school system will have the transcripts ready in time for 11/1 deadlines. I suggest that you send the GC a nice email saying that you understand the situation, but that you would appreciate if your son’s ED transcript could be sent as soon as transcripts are available. If it’s not sent in time for some reason, you could ask the GC to contact the college with an explanation. As RVM said, I don’t think that the college would penalize the student in a situation like this.</p>

<p>thanks for your encouragement mom, rvm, and liny. i will wait it out another week before i contact gc again. i am sure there are many in the school district being equally pushy for info. if need be i will make sure she calls the school, in the meantime i will see what happens next week. </p>

<p>maybe our district is slow, because we have off all the jewish holidays. ;)</p>

<p>Hi, friends. I just wanted to come back and post among this nonjudgmental, fair group. I started a thread about engineering schools yesterday - hey, I have questions so it made sense to me to ask people who either know or have opinions (big difference!) - and feel like I am getting lambasted over there. - Why these schools? Why not those schools? Why the Long Island bias? Why are you stressing? OMG. I am getting some useful information, which was the purpose. But people are so angry! I should have expected it!</p>

<p>DS is feeling the junior year stress. He’s trying to fit in all his ECs on top of the increased school work caused by the APs. Plus drivers ed and SAT tutoring. I explained that some of the activities are just temporary, but he’s going to have to really plan and work ahead when possible to make it all work. One month of school and he seems so tired already. I wish YK was on a weekday to give him an extra day off! He is off on Monday, Columbus Day, but he is marching in the Columbus Day parade in NYC with his HS marching band (and has SAT tutor later that day) so it’s not exactly a free day. Better keep loading him with Vit C - no time to get sick this year!</p>

<p>I hear you - junior year is tough! My son is definitely having an easier time this year - pressure of SAT/ACT is over - he knows where he is applying, etc. Junior year is just one of things you have to push through! Very cool about marching in the parade!</p>

<p>I took my d to see Marist College. Fell in LOVE with every aspect. They claimed to be nondenominational but thats not what I picked up. Do any of you know if theres a jewish population there??? It’s incredible but maybe not bc of dating issues? ;(</p>

<p>LINYMOM, it may not be judgmental in the sense(s) you percieve it, but rather just the way critical, matter-of-factly opinionated engineers often think and then express themselves. </p>

<p>On the otherhand, it might be useful to listen to what they have to say as it may reflect the sorts of attitudes your DS will have to face in getting a job later with/from other engineers.</p>

<p>Yeah … that full-frontal CC experience can be really intense … hurray for the B student threads!</p>

<p>names: DS/DD’s GC went to Marist and she kept pushing it for my daughter, despite her insistance that there be a significant Jewish population. Did not pursue.</p>

<p>mhc: I think DS will fit in; he’s got a bit of a superiority complex in some ways. Has always been just a little over-confident when it comes to academics but is being brought back to reality in AP Physics and AP Calc. </p>

<p>Emmybet: Yes, I do love the B student thread!</p>

<p>LINYmom–I hear you about Junior year. One D is a senior and the other’s a freshman-I’m glad to have some downtime before going through it again.</p>

<p>names1, have you done a search on Marist in this thread? It’s been asked or talked about a number of times before. Here’s an article from a few years back I came accross
[Jewish</a> Students Group transitions to Hillel in upcoming weeks | The River Reporter](<a href=“http://theriverreporter.■■■■■■■■■■■■■/2009/02/02/jewish-students-group-transitions-to-hillel-in-upcoming-weeks/]Jewish”>Jewish Students Group transitions to Hillel in upcoming weeks | The River Reporter)</p>

<p>And you might also contact students on their Marist College Jewish Student Facebook group [Marist</a> College Jewish Students Group | Facebook](<a href=“Facebook Public Group | Facebook”>Facebook Public Group | Facebook) although…it doesn’t seem to be very up-to-date, which may or may not be indicative of activity or involvement.</p>

<p>LINYMOM- I read your thread on engineering schools and thought that you got some interesting feedback. Just sort out the helpful information from the parts that you find angry and also know that you don’t have to respond to those questions about why this school, why not that school, eventually people on those threads often start to argue among each other and forget why you even asked the question!..but maybe some schools were mentioned that you hadn’t considered, or had ruled out but want to reconsider? It’s always good to have someone question your assumptions, and since its on an anonymous forum, I think people feel freer to offer their opinions and don’t care about whether they might hurt your feelings. </p>

<p>And adding my two cents- Tulane and Miami are probably great schools but are they worth the cost vs. say U MD which you liked? I think as far as job opportunities go, the big state U’s are great because they have good career offices, large alumni networks, and tons of employers who recruit on campus.</p>

<p>Anecdotally, a friend of mine’s daughter graduated from U Miami with a Marketing degree and could not find employment.</p>

<p>pamom: Thanks for your comment. I’m not going to derail this thread onto the other subject, but there is a lesson in not feeling like you have to respond to everyone! They are having fun talking among themselves now. I should pop on every now and again, though, so they know the OP is still paying attention.</p>

<p>(And on UM and Tulane: I completely agree with you, but both give significant merit aid as compared to the other privates on the list. I am loving UMD though for the reasons you stated!)</p>

<p>On this thread, the talking among the group about the various issues is great. We are all coming from a very similar base and the conversation has been going on for soooo long!</p>

<p>Linymom,</p>

<p>Can you put up the link to the site you started. I want to read it for sport. Thanks</p>

<p>Only because socaldad asked.</p>

<p><a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/engineering-majors/1219297-engineering-schools-trade-offs-ranks.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/engineering-majors/1219297-engineering-schools-trade-offs-ranks.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Now back to our regularly scheduled programming.</p>

<p>I have one really stupid question, but I trust you all to snicker to yourselves and then to give me an answer! :slight_smile: Dd has an application that must be paper and there is no way to fill it out on the screen and then print it out. How in the world do you fill this out? Just with handwritten pen? What do I do about the fact that dd’s handwriting is terrible. I am lost without a typewriter–ha-ha! Anyone else have this going on? It seems so crazy that we can’t copy on line and fill it in and then print, but there does not seem to be a way to do this. On to read LINYMOM’s other thread! Thanks.</p>

<p>We also have this issue. DS got an application in the mail for the honors college at a school that he was just admitted to (rolling) and it has to be manually filled out and mailed. He has illegible handwriting. It is worse that any I have ever seen. I was thinking that he could print out his essay and attach it but the other questions I am not sure about.</p>

<p>I would do the writing but I just don’t think that is kosher and also, would be concerned if anyone looked at dd’s SAT writing…Not that I would be trying to pull something over on the school, just want it readable. It is so hard to believe that in this day and age we have to do something like this by hand. Dd also has a teacher doing her recs that does not use a computer, so those will be hand done, even for Common App schools–kind of defeats the purpose, don’t you think? Oy…</p>