Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>Back in transcript hell. Three of S2’s colleges have his transcript and have a complete file. Two do not have it logged in yet - it might be there - it might not. (My head hurts).</p>

<p>Susquehanna is adamant that they do not have it - and given how small they are - and that it was mailed (supposedly) 3 weeks ago - this is not good. Elon is still matching things up - suggested I give it a week (clearly they don’t know me) and then check their online status checker again.</p>

<p>I find it so odd that the 3 largest schools have it logged in and the smaller 2 don’t. </p>

<p>I emailed appropriate people at S2’s hs and asked them to resend to those 2 schools. I figure it will take at least several requests before they do anything - so might as well start now. I have no idea how people manage to stay on top of 15-20 applications!</p>

<p>rvm- you have had more than your share of frustrations! So far, our process has been smooth. I think that most of the larger schools handle the process electronically, so it is easier to match information. All of the schools my D2 has applied to are large publics, and all have received her info and reported “complete” per online status checker. Now we just have to watch the mail, hoping for a large envelope soon!</p>

<p>Rockvillemom - Congrats on the Towson admit! We had similar problems with Elon last year and I also found it funny that a smaller college wouldn’t be as organized but all turned out well in the end. They do have a huge amount of students that apply EA and I bet it gets overwhelming. It’s funny that you are looking at schools that one or another of my kids applied to, or looked at. Two applied to and were accepted to Elon, one to Towson, and we visited Susquehanna. All are great choices!</p>

<p>RVM, we had these kinds of problems with Quinnipiac. Since Q was rolling at that time (don’t know what kind of application process it is now), we were pretty upset. They claimed that son’s transcript was missing. I know that the hs sent it since Q had the rest of the info from the hs and our guidance dept. is very careful to triple check prior to mailing anything. Son’s GC faxed son’s transcript and then the file was listed as “complete”.</p>

<p>I’m going to grit my teeth and be patient for a week as far as Elon is concerned. If they don’t have it by the end of next week - I will have to hound the hs to send it out again. They already think I’m a pain in the neck - nothing to lose there!</p>

<p>^^You have to do what you have to do! </p>

<p>I remember using a chart when my kids applied. Some schools had a checklists online, or mailed them in those days, others we just called (some multiple times) until the app. was listed as complete.</p>

<p>What I find amusing is the parents who feel the student should be doing this! (I have been reprimanded a few times!) Maybe some kids would be ready to keep track of all this stuff - but I feel this is the responsibility of the “project manager”, who needs an adult beverage at this point.</p>

<p>RVM, LOL! I have been there! My kids also needed “help” in completing a fafsa. In fact, my DH and I needed some help from an accountant to complete it. We were completely frazzled the first 2 times that we tried to fill it out! Oh, but it is “simple”. We disagree.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Great point. They are all different, as you point out. He hated Penn. Loved Hopkins (campus within a city). Wants to look at CMU (we will look at Pitt while we are there). Options are good. DS is definitely very interested in the opportunities (that’s why UMD’s opps are more important to him than the size of the school. Thanks for stating this so eloquently.</p>

<p>RVM and Northeast - Completely agree! There is no way my S would be capable of managing this process on his own! I give him a task, he completes it, we review it together, and on to his next task. There is no way he could manage all of the varied requirements by himself. Maybe it’s a “boy” thing, but I can’t imagine that any of his friends would be capable of doing this solo either.</p>

<p>If my kids had applied to 2, 3, or 4 schools, they might have managed it under my direction. On their own, it probably would not have crossed their minds to even follow up. They would have thought if they applied, paid an app. fee, told their GCs that they were ready to have paperwork sent, and they sent in SATs/ACTs, they were done. </p>

<p>I encouraged lots of applications because our family needed to compare FA and/or merit aid, as cost was important to us. Managing all of this was time consuming and required organization.</p>

<p>FYI on Elon; I had to call them on behalf of a student yesterday; a kid answered the phone in admissions, told me it was his first day and then told me that there were absolutely no admissions officers in this whole week; on the road…</p>

<p>so, if anyone is getting frustrated about the downloads, you may want to keep this in mind…</p>

<p>doesn’t make it better, but certainly explains it…</p>

<p>RVM: if you really need to talk to someone, I would have your son email the rep; I got an answer yesterday in literally 3 minutes by email…</p>

<p>Huzzah, RVM! You should go back and reread your first post on this thread about where your S2 was looking. Ah, memories…</p>

<p>chocchip: PSAT was yesterday. D2 said she felt pretty good about the math section, which was a knock-us-down-with-a-feather kind of surprise for everyone. Her vocab was lacking on the reading part. Best thing was that she didn’t have any kind of panic attack about the entire process. </p>

<p>sujormik: Not sure about CoC. I’d certainly like to see Charleston, so maybe that should be the objective, and the visit just organically bubbles up out of that. :)</p>

<p>Sukkah is up and we have nice weather in which to enjoy it. Apologies to those of you who aren’t getting the type of weather that the holiday deserves. </p>

<p>The question of managing the apps and to-do lists and double-checking seems to vary from kid to kid. D1 checked on her own with little input from the adults. D2 will need more handholding.</p>

<p>Hi ST:</p>

<p>Yeah, my S2 will take PSAT’s this Saturday. I am amazed at how many of you take them on Wednesdays…that is never offered here. Always on a Sat. My S2 did much better on the state standardized tests in Bio last year (Advanced) then he did on the SAT II (a 570 for his very first exposure to SAT’s, no prep of any sort). He also tends to panic when test taking, but he will prep next fall for the March 2013 SAT test.</p>

<p>It’s raw and raining here in New England today and tomorrow. NOT Sukkah weather!</p>

<p>Linymom:</p>

<p>CMU is a really nice, green campus near the city of Pittsburgh. Fabulous Hillel building too. Only problem is: it’s not in the warmer weather! :slight_smile: UMCP sounds like a great choice for him too, glad he like it! FWIW, my S1 hated Penn too. Btw: Will he apply to Cornell or Dartmouth or just too wintery?</p>

<p>RVM:</p>

<p>I don’t even drink and I remember needing an adult beverage fairly often! And my S1 applied ED…oy, I’ll be in the trenches next time with RD applications!</p>

<p>The person I spoke to at Elon was actually very helpful. He explained that their online tracking system is not updated daily - but weekly - so to check it again next week. He also told me that transcripts take longer to match with files and show up in the tracking system than test scores - which are submitted electronically. He also stressed that as long as the application is in by the deadline date - not to stress if the transcript is slightly late. So - overall - a very satisfactory explanation - but I’ll just worry for the next week as to whether they have the transcript or not. But that’s just how it goes.</p>

<p>Major warning to all those who will be filling out FAFSA in January for the first time. This was way harder than the college apps. I think I called their toll free number 4-5x. I finally asked why this had to be so hard for someone who already graduated from college.</p>

<p>CCC: Dartmouth way too cold/north for DS. I think he should consider Cornell because it is fairly known for engineering (debatable over on the engineering thread! LOL) and, well, it is Cornell. Again, will sit tight on this till SAT scores are known. Actually pretty surprised that he is enthusiastic about CMU, considering location. Just shows to me that he does have some maturity – not going to pick a college based on temp, although all things being equal…</p>

<p>S met with the GC today and she said that she would get her form in soon. I was impressed that she read his essays and app and said she was glad she did since she learned a lot about my S. good start.</p>

<p>now we just keep checking naviance to see when it actually goes out. I am going to guess that it will be there by nov 1 and then we will have the wait to see that it gets updated on college system.</p>

<p>whew.</p>

<p>LINYMOM - if you “liked” the FAFSA - you should try the CSS Profile. At least twice as complicated! This year should be my last time with the CSS Profile - for which I am eternally grateful!</p>

<p>LOL I had to do CSS for DD (one school). Ridiculous. I will have to do it again for DS. However, DD will be in her third year of college by then so all our assets will be gone anyway. (JK)</p>

<p>What is CSS profile?</p>