Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>MarkBass, great comeback! </p>

<p>Samtalya, that is funny about Hess Kramer. My dh worked there in college too and my grandmother begged me to go there when I was going to camp. I refused, as I was from the Bay Area and did not want to go down to LA for camp!</p>

<p>So instead, went to UCLA for school.</p>

<p>I have a lovely nephew at Berkeley where he is a sophmore. If anyone needs someone to talk with that is going to the school, I might be able to get him to chat with you. He is in a Jewish frat and is on the moot court team. I have not heard of him having trouble getting classes, but he may be one of the lucky ones!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Again, I apologize for quoting an old post, but I’m caught up to only one year ago and this time it is about an actual direct-thread-topic.</p>

<p>Rodney, if you’re still here, what did you mean? Can you please give some specifics?</p>

<p>Several of the CTCL schools have rowing teams and they are on our very early preliminary list. What issues are there for a Jewish student?</p>

<p>Thanks.</p>

<p>=====</p>

<p>And, no, my “relationship” with that young woman did not last long at all. She very soon began to hang out with a very hunky guy of Mediterranean heritage.</p>

<p>@MarkBass: that comeback was perfect!</p>

<p>phillyartmom, i was at hess kramer summer of 83, was your there? i have a bag of pics of counselors still if he was there i have pics of him! Eisner in the Berkshires (anyone?) summer 86.</p>

<p>markbass, at least she didn’t ask if have horns? my sis and I use to get that growing up in nh.</p>

<p>samtalya: Did I know that you worked at Eisner? DD will be working there again this summer (after 3 years as a camper)! DS went there too (4 summers) - skipping “machon” this year.</p>

<p>Re: Stevens Institute - I don’t know much about it either except that a friend of my DD from Hebrew High School is there. This friend was very active in the temple. I know she was also accepted to Delaware, but she got a better package from Stevens (merit? need? I don’t know the family)</p>

<p>MarkBass - Awesome story. Love it.</p>

<p>DS still getting college mail, like most HS juniors. He hardly even looks at ANY of them. At all. I had to laugh when we got the UD brochure yesterday. Sitting in the pile with the rest of them. What a waste of paper. Have any of your kids started even researched a school just because of this mass mailing that is sent out after PSATs?</p>

<p>DS’ good news this week: Math SATII is in the range he needs (wants, not sure which schools he actually needs it for). AP Physics (grade went up second quarter) is going even better this quarter. Best news: Today is our last day in NY - we are off to FL tomorrow! Although we will be on vacation, he will have to do practice ACTs along with a SS paper. At least we can sleep past 6 am! I’ll still be on-line - would miss too much here if I “left” for a week!</p>

<p>MarkBass - you are a very funny addition to our thread! Going back to that quote about Jews being wealthy - I think mdmomfromli nailed it - colleges recognize and value the emphasis that Jewish parents place on a college education. Not to imply that other demographics do not value it - but I have heard anecdotal evidence that Jewish college students graduate at a higher rate than non-Jewish students.</p>

<p>markb - good story! I choose to believe (naively?) that you made a difference in her life, performed a Mitzvah by helping her grow, opening her mind. Hey, she dated you, so she had potential! </p>

<p>We all have ignorance/prejudice in us to some degree. I personally struggle with a group that continues to baptize Holocaust victims post-mortem & how that transfers, in my mind, to a certain candidate.</p>

<p>Having grown up in an extremely diverse community, my D cannot comprehend that there are those in this great country who have never encountered a Jewish person, and those who might picture her as their Satan, or green, or funny/rich/smart/spoiled only. This has come into play as she chooses colleges.</p>

<p>No, liny, my D has not once cracked the seal on any of the college mailings. I have :slight_smile:
Love your dedication to the thread, vacation-wise!</p>

<p>Mark Bass, thumbs up on the comeback.</p>

<p>Now, about CTCL and Jewish students–rodney will speak up for herself, but I’ll take a crack at this.I’ve slowly been ■■■■■■■■ for information on what the Jewish population is like at the different CTCLs. I look at the Hillel website to see what percentage of Jewish students they give, then look at the Hillel website for the campus to see if it’s there, and if it’s been recently updated. I search this thread for people’s comments about the school. I do a google search using the campus name and terms like Jew and Hillel and Chabad. </p>

<p>What I get is a sense of which schools have somewhat established Jewish communities, which have ones on the upswing, and which have few Jewish students. None of these schools are listed on the Reform Judaism magazine’s list of schools with a large percentage of Jewish students. I wouldn’t say that these schools are hostile or unwelcoming to Jewish students. The issue is if a student wants some sort of active existing Jewish community at the school. </p>

<p>Some examples from my notes: about Beloit, I have that there’s pretty much nothing organized, no Chabad, a Jewish Student Organization-type club but nothing showing that there are services. Centre College affiliates with the University of Kentucky Hillel, but Hillel.org lists no Jewish students at Centre. Supposedly a JSO but they do about two Shabbats a semester. A poster on a website that rhymes with tune-a-go but you can remove the t, the n, the e and the hyphens to get the real name says he’s one of very few Jews at Denison. </p>

<p>Not an issue for some of our students, of course. An issue for others. That’s why we’re here! :)</p>

<p>Mark: given my menopausal state, I will have to go back into the thread to see in what context that post was made; but Slithey summed it up pretty well…no time right now, but will do that later</p>

<p>If I remember correctly, ( and that’s a stretch), it may have been in reference to a bunch of the LACS mentioned on this thread in the Midwest that I have investigated over the years…</p>

<p>I’m coming up for air then I have to hit Southwest’s website again and start booking. I may not come up with all the schools I want to see, but I have to somewhat group them geographically. We can always return. I have a flight into Pittsburgh and that’s as far as I’ve gotten so far LOL. I’ll keep plugging while my challah is rising.</p>

<p>Luvmomn8ur: Thanks for the info. Don’t feel inadequate I classify my ‘A’ students as ‘B’ for purposes of holistic app review because they aren’t as well rounded (no sports, little community service, one has strong ECs, the other doesn’t, they both love their computes and value their downtime) so I am realistic that Harvard won’t want them. That’s who they are and I didn’t push, I just tried to encourage their strengths and find the right fit. I’m rambling, sorry! It’s just that GPA and SAT/ACT is only part of who they are, as are all of our kids.</p>

<p>Pepperdine: my impression is that it is a true ‘Christian’ school as opposed to the Jesuits. I think students HAVE to take one religious (Christian) course. In fact, if anyone is considering Pepperdine, I encourage you to look at Loyola Marymount U in Los Angeles. ‘College on the bluff’ over the ocean. Very active Jewish life, and the religious course requirements (three) means any spiritual course, which are varied across all religions. If you have a car, easy access to all parts of Los Angeles.</p>

<p>Anyone else on this thread considering small Los Angeles schools for the Jewish B student - Chapman.</p>

<p>Jewish campus life: in general, I have found that the Jewish kids at the Hillels and JSUs are as varied as any student body. It depends on whether your kid will connect with them. Some groups may be very religious, others more social. For my kids, just because there is a Hillel/JSU doesn’t mean they will want to hang out there or affiliate. YMMV. </p>

<p>LINYMom: BTW DH grew up in Comack. Now he is a CA transplant, LOL. Please take notes on U of Miami merit/scholarship data!</p>

<p>MarkBass: love the date story. One CTCL, Whitman in Washington state, had a very welcoming Jewish group. GREAT school for the right kid. I can’t say enough good things about Whitman but like many CTCL, it has become a reach for classic B students. They do welcome diversity so if you are East coast and Jewish, give it a look over. </p>

<p>Bezerkley: My understanding that even though it is still considered the crown jewel of CA pubs, it is not very undergraduate friendly and I have heard stories of kids having programs pulled out from under them. If you are going to consider the UCs, look at UCSD which likes to get their kids out in four years. Stay away from UC Irvine which has had a lot of press lately with the Muslim Student Union. Admin hasn’t handled things well there. </p>

<p>I gotta hit the search engines, back to the other ‘tabs’! Thanks all!</p>

<p>One comment about the UCs: if you’re OOS and money constrained at all, they shouldn’t even be in consideration.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Thank you both very, very much.
At this time, our very early (big) list is very heavily east coast oriented with just a few schools edging into the midwest.</p>

<p>And my own memory is apparently faulty because it turns out the only CTCL school with a rowing team on our list is CLARK. (I thought there were two or three.)</p>

<p>The other CTCLs that we might look at are:</p>

<p>MARLBORO<br>
JUNIATA<br>
HAMPSHIRE<br>
ALLEGHENY </p>

<p>If any thoughts (that wouldn’t otherwise be in the last 400 pages :wink: ) I’d be happy to hear them.</p>

<p>I should also point out I guess at this time that neither I or my D are pious or observant in any way. My interest in learning the great information in this thread is because I think it will help lead to a better fit for my D. I don’t have any specific requirements as relates to aspects of Jewish life on campus.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Thanks … I guess. I hope that’s a good thing.</p>

<p>Clark I know a little about–took D1 to tour 2-3 years ago, because it was the only CTCL that, at the time, looked to have a “significant” Jewish population. They didn’t have a free-standing Hillel, but D1 spent some time talking to the incredibly nice rabbi director. They do a number of events, including some bagels-at-midnight (or was it brunch?) stuff that is attended by the whole campus, MOT and not. </p>

<p>As for the school itself, I’ve got mixed feelings. The biggest strike against Clark is the surrounding neighborhood, which is a little depressed. Students tend to stick to campus. Boston is about an hour’s drive away, and students don’t seem to spend a lot of time there. On the other hand, the school stands out in my memory as one of the few where the tourguide did not constantly use the word “like” :smiley: It was reasonably warm and nurturing, and is the ONLY school in the US to offer study abroad opportunities on EVERY continent. Yup, there was an option to spend time in Antarctica! They have an option to get a fifth year master’s free in some majors, though you have to do a bit of advance planning to take advantage of it. D1 was looking at it as a safety, and ultimately decided it wasn’t her cuppa. Plus MOT family friends, who had a kid there, weren’t as impressed and told us they didn’t think it would work for D1. </p>

<p>You can search the thread, you know, for any school name. :slight_smile: That’s what I’ve just been doing to check out University of Denver (looking for D2). I’ve been around for those gazillions of pages and heck if I can remember most of what we’ve discussed. :slight_smile: :)</p>

<p>RE: Clark, ^^^^ Thanks S/T! *</p>

<p>is the ONLY school in the US to offer study abroad opportunities on EVERY continent.</p>

<p>Well, that would suit my D.
As I think I’ve mentioned, she has lived overseas and is very good at languages (takes after her mother, not me. :wink: )</p>

<p>Yes, I’m aware of the fifth year Masters. Intriguing idea.</p>

<p>If my D decides to row in college (and if she makes it to a team) the college searching/applying process is going to be much more complicated for us. Or maybe a whole lot easier. We shall see.</p>

<p>=======================</p>

<ul>
<li>BTW, I am also a big Lewis Carroll fan. Own a few books about him. Have not read yet, though, the book that came out a year or two ago … I think it was a fictionalized biography of Alice Liddell.</li>
</ul>

<p>Hey Markbass:</p>

<p>I live up here in New England and have heard of numerous students attending Clark U over the years. Honestly, I personally don’t know that much about the school. However, that said, anyone that we’ve asked how their kids liked the school, all gave glowing reports. The range of majors we’ve heard about differs by kid…Sociology, Government, Languages, etc.</p>

<p>I’m talking maybe 10-12 over the course of a few years that we have heard about enjoying Clark and all were Jewish. Hillel seems to be active there. Some kids feel the need to leave campus and others are quite content to remain on campus and find lots to do.</p>

<p>Another poster on this thread on occasion is HollieSue. I believe it is her daughter that attends Juniata, if I remember correctly. She could be a good resource for you on questions re: that school.</p>

<p>Totally unrelated question but I can’t find the answer online: 12-y-o DS is going to a B’Nai Mitzvah tomorrow morning (twins). Never done this before. If he is really friends with only one twin (but definitely knows the other), what is the cash gift policy? 150% of what you would give to 1 kid? The multiple of 18 part certainly complicates matters here… We see the parents at parties but are not close. Thanks…hope you don’t mind my appealing to your collective knowledge on non-college related matters!</p>

<p>^^^^ Thanks very much!</p>

<p>On paper (well, electrons) it looks like a perfect fit.
CTCL schools are coming here soon for their own “fair” and we plan on attending.
Plus, D and her mother will be in New England this summer so I’m hoping they will have time to visit a couple of schools.
I know some people are not crazy about visits in the summer but we really don’t have much of a choice.
Once crew workouts start, we are not in control of our own lives.
They even workout on school holidays (this Presidents Day for example) and camps are mandatory during breaks.
Also, once boat assignments are made, one is not allowed to skip a practice.
This is a whole new world.</p>

<p>MomofNEA: when we had this situation a number of years ago, we gave the exact same gift X 2 that we would have given normally…</p>

<p>I know it’s been awhile but 54x2 or 36x2 seems reasonable for a peer gift…</p>

<p>I knew I’d get a fast and sensible answer here! 54x2 seems hefty to me for a peer gift, but 36x2 seems fair, especially since my S is supplementing with a token personal gift costing about $20. Thank you!</p>