Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>A couple comments above referred to Drexel as being “sink or swim” and I’m wondering what is meant by that. Isn’t all college “sink or swim” in a sense? What type of supports do other colleges have that schools like Drexel lack?</p>

<p>BU currently requires SAT + 2 subject tests, or the ACT with writing. I think that next year the will no longer require subject tests. I agree that it’s best to check each school’s website for requirements.</p>

<p>Support can mean many different things. It could mean that professors notice if a student isn’t coming to class/turning in assignments/did badly on a midterm or project. At some schools, the prof won’t notice at all. At others, the professor could send a brief note to the student, or contact the student personally, set up a conference. Or send a heads-up notice on to a dean. </p>

<p>Or, it could mean being available when students want to discuss difficulties. If a student is having a tough time in a course, or bombed a midterm, will the professor simply say that the student needs to work harder, or that the student is in the wrong major? Or will the professor spend more time with the student, figuring out if this is just a bump in the road? </p>

<p>And there’s the student culture. Are they willing to help out classmates who are having a tough time, or are they highly competitive to the point of cut-throatedness?</p>

<p>pamom, Not all students are good test takers. My youngest is one of them. He likes to participate in class, does very well on projects and homework but might freeze up on a big tests. In college, it’s common to have just a 2- 3 tests for the whole semester. We really paid attention when the tour guide at Champlain talked about how much emphasis there was there on hands-on learning and a de-emphasis on standardized tests. They said the same thing at Drexel’s iSchool but when asked about the rest of the college, the answer was that the classes were just too big for that and it really depended on the teacher. We looked over the curriculum and most of the classes freshman year at Drexel were not in the iSchool. That was disheartning, but not unexpected. That’s pretty much how it is at big schools.</p>

<p>Hi all! It’s been awhile since I’ve checked in. Nice to hear all the good news! I will be going to Charleston to check it out with my D right after pesach. Anyone else considering CofC? I love feedback…</p>

<p>Hi Names1: My DS has decided on C of C without a doubt. We visited last June and again at the JSU’s prospective students weekend in October. He absolutely fell in love with the school and the city (as did I). He has heard from/gotten in to 6 other schools, but C of C instantly became his top choice and he never looked back! He can NOT wait to get down there for orientation this summer!</p>

<p>On Monday, S participated in a University of Alabama webcast for admitted students about their housing procedure. Students log in with their name, so all participants were listed in a window. Another window had a chat going on during the presentation, with kids chiming in on where they’re from, if they’re looking for roommates, etc. I was amazed at how many kids posted they were Jewish and were looking for Jewish roommates.</p>

<p>^^^Chardo, Gotta love modern technology!</p>

<p>I have yet another question for the Vets of this thread…</p>

<p>According to the James Madison University CDS, their admissions decisions do not consider these factors: an interview, class rank, SAT/ACT writing score, demonstrated interest in school, personal qualities/character & religious affiliation/commitment.
Is this credible? I see many schools say they don’t consider some/all of these factors, esp the larger universities. Granted, character can be difficult to assess & outright consideration of religious affiliation could be construed as discrimination, but it leaves me wondering…What’s been your experience?</p>

<p>D is interested in JMU, so I’m not picking on JMU, quite the contrary, merely curious.</p>

<p>We’ve been talking to CWRU about academic support for ADHD. The Disability Office is run by learning specialists very familiar with ADHD - they see a lot of it there. Case offers extra time on exams in a reduced distraction setting, and assigns trained staff to work with students on time management, organization, compensatory skills, etc. one-on-one, as needed. To access this help, the student fills out a disclosure form with recommendation (from current MD or learning specialist) for type of support needed. </p>

<p>Several general features also seem very positive in terms of support. SI (supplementary instruction) leaders are assigned to notoriously difficult classes. Faculty & alumni talk about collaborative, not competitive atmosphere. And something I really like – students can retain merit scholarships as long as they complete 12 credits per semester (minimum full-time credits out of a possible 18) with a 2.0 average. This standard was eased a year or two ago, to encourage students to take challenging classes and try new things without fear of putting their scholarships at risk.</p>

<p>LuvMom that sounds right to me with JMU. What they are saying - is that they look at grades, rigor of transcript and the math and reading test scores - and that is pretty much what they consider. Larger universities tend to be more of a stats-based admission - and put less emphasis on a holistic approach. JMU does not give interviews - and even teacher recs are optional. Larger universities tend not consider demonstrated interest - that is more common among smaller schools. More and more high schools do not rank - so it also makes sense that they do not look at rank.</p>

<p>In some ways - I prefer admissions evaluations at larger universities such as JMU - as it is easier to predict the decision. I’m not saying 100% of the time - but generally speaking - if you look at Naviance - you will see that every student above a certain GPA or above a certain test score was admitted. While on the other hand, at smaller schools and at more elite universities - the admissions decisions can be very surprising and it is not uncommon to have two students with the same GPA and test scores get different results.</p>

<p>Sending out huge congrats to all the new admittances, acceptances and decisions to enroll!! This thread makes me so happy every day. Also big hugs for those who need it. Believe me, we understand that too. Especially happy for the new CofC decideds!! we were so so close, but alas, she will not be there with you in the fall. I am hoping you all let us know how it goes. I have a DS (2017) who loved CofC. I figure as a male, hockey player, he has a good shot!!!</p>

<p>Anyway, thanks ElKyes for the update and I will share ours:</p>

<p>Private admits:
Hofstra w merit
Goucher w merit
Washington College w merit</p>

<p>Public admits:
PSU (univ park)
UDel
CofC
JMU</p>

<p>Rejected/denied:
Fordham
W&M reg decision</p>

<p>It came down to CofC vs. JMU. Much wringing of hands and doubt, but eventually JMU wins. I will say I think the admitted student day at JMU had a lot to do with it.</p>

<p>What ultimately made the decision? WHo knows? (See the “stupid reasons” thread hahaha) but I think - 1. Southern mentality. she was afraid of being very different - northeast, slightly sarcastic jew? Although JMU is also south, many more northeast kids, 2. size/breadth - undecided majors so, she was interested in options; 3. possible education majors - not for sure but definately highly ranked in edu; 4. friend who is an adcom at a highly ranked grad school - said JMU would have better name recog. I think much of it also had to do with the vibe she caught from the other students.</p>

<p>Also - re JMU, I do think the admit stats/info are accurate, with one big caveat. JMU recalculates grades based on rigor and their own scale. They do not count many of the electives, focus on the 5 major subjects, and recalc grades (ap, honors, etc). Seems to make big difference in some places/schools. </p>

<p>Good luck to all - please let us know how it all turns out!!!</p>

<p>Congratulations on JMU - a school we really liked - very happy kids - very friendly vibe.</p>

<p>Momof12, Congrats on JMU. i really liked the campus when we visited it. If not for the difficulty of getting there from LA, D would have applied.<br>
Lovemom, while I believe that the rules and policies you stated are true, I will say that when we visited, My D arranged to sit down for 30 minutes with the California admission rep. They exchanged emails, and was encouraged to keep in touch. Had she applied, I do believe that the encounter would have helped. While they might not have formal interviews, anything you can do to have your child stand out and be remembered by the person deciding their fate, is helpful. </p>

<p>Just my humble opinion…</p>

<p>SAT scores are in and… drumroll… DS got over 1300 on M/CR! SO HAPPY. Only problem is that the writing score went down scarily (he didn’t get to finish his essay). Now to check with the schools he’s interested in to see if they look at that - so many of them don’t. Don’t know how a kid in AP English classes can do so poorly on that part of the test. Oh, wait, I know. He hates to write. UGH.</p>

<p>If they don’t look at the W score, then he is in pretty good shape! Still, one more test to go: April 14 ACT. Deep breath…</p>

<p>@LINYMOM- on the SAT writing score its very important to write a long essay and if possible to fill the entire two pages. Studies have shown that a higher score is gained by writing a longer essay. Also- our experience with the writing score was that it could vary greatly as my D first scored in the high 500s and the second time in the low 700s. The second time she aced the multipled choice and scored one point higher on the essay. :)</p>

<p>the overall score of 1300 math/reading should make him competitive for lots of schools but if he could score 1400+ there could be a lot more merit; also- math subscore can be important for engineering admits- how do the subscores break out?</p>

<p>pamom: Yes, he knew that. But as a result, he didn’t finish!!! Score went down 60 points on that section from last time! I’m thinking that GC can address his writing in her rec (and note whatever grade he gets in AP Lang this year). Unfortunately, he is not very excited about this AP Lang teacher so he’s definitely not asking him for a rec. DS actually won a huge writing award in middle school. I’m kind of shocked. If he does great on ACT, then we will send that instead of SAT. Otherwise, we may have to send both SATs. I have about five months to figure this out…</p>

<p>@LINYMOM…well in any event those are very solid scores for admission, and many schools don’t consider the writing score. I didn’t realize this was his second go round at the SAT so in that case your plan to have him take ACT seems like a good one. I think some people do find the ACT reading and writing sections are easier than the SAT ones.</p>

<p>As to the merit chances, at Pitt he wil not get merit under 1400 SAT. However, I’d predict he’d get merit at schools like UD and Drexel.</p>

<p>Linymom: Congrats on the improved SAT score! Good luck with the April ACT. If that score isn’t better, you should be fine if you send in the scores from both SATs. It seems like every school superscores.</p>

<p>Momofa12: Congrats on your D’s choice of JMU. I know many very happy students who attend JMU. It’s interesting to hear how JMU recalculates GPA. They always accept a lot of students from our HS. I think our course system might help. We have AP, GT and honors level courses. The honors courses are accelerated, but not as rigorous as GT. I wonder if JMU weighs them the same?</p>

<p>Luvmom: I agree with RVM that large schools look mostly at GPA, rigor and SAT scores. I believe that they pay more attention to EC’s and essays for honors programs. Large schools are actually a good option for kids with solid stats who haven’t “played the game” and are weak on ECs.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>His math scores (SAT, Math 2 SAT II) are in the 700’s.
His science/math scores on his first ACT are in the 30s.
His chem SAT II is in the 700’s.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Neither are on his list :(</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I know, but it’s still worrisome. I just emailed three schools that I know he’s interested in. Looking at our HS Naviance for SAT 1600, he’s in good shape, but…</p>

<p>Wish this could be easy.</p>

<p>momofa12 congrats on jmu. we have many happy friends who have kids there.</p>

<p>liny, wonderful that the scores went up. watch out ACT here he comes. I bet he will do great.</p>