<p>SoCal-Your daughter is very lucky to have parents who do their homework. I am constantly surprised at the number of parents who treat this process like it was a trip to Macy’s. Knowledge is power and many of us gain that knowledge on CC. Your daughter’s story is an inspiration.</p>
<p>luvmom, S definitely a B student until this year and that didn’t show by application time. Like RVM, if S didn’t apply ED to Elon, not sure he would have gotten in. I think it is about knowing the fit of the school with your child and then working that process. Socal’s process is a great example. there are many great schools out there and we have covered them in this thread. </p>
<p>mom2009, if your son is in to outdoor stuff, (boulder, uvm) when you go back to visit elon, make sure you go to the bottom level of the rec center during open hours of the adventure office. we stopped by and were told about all the outdoor adventure trips. they do hiking, rafting, kayaking, and rock climbing almost every weekend.</p>
<p>samtalya, I understand & agree 100% with your helpful words of wisdom. (see below)
momjr, Your support & kindness means the world to me…thank you. My D has returned transformed: more mature, self-assured, ready to take on (make) her future. Nothing short of miraculous!
rvm, As always, your shared experiences bring me (& others, no doubt) knowledge & hope. I am eternally grateful for all of your posts.
socaldad, Once again, thanks for the inspirational tale. I’ll share it with my D. I’ve always appreciated your humor, now I appreciate your openness, as well.
familyof3boys, I look forward to reading your success story.</p>
<p>From the getgo, D’s been an Elon fan (Thanks, in part, to so many of you on this thread). Elon is the only perfect fit she’s found (including the outdoor ops, samtalya!). However, D’s public NJ HS is large & competitive with many other (more qualified, straight A minority) students also interested in Elon. She knows her only chance is to apply ED & to market herself, while putting her nose to the grindstone to increase the GPA & SAT scores. I guess we’ll see just how much she wants it! I worry that she’s putting all her eggs in 1 basket-which intellectually she gets, but there’s still that emotional tug of “They will want me because I want them.” We’re keeping our options open, but also our fingers crossed.</p>
<p>listserve, happy to hear that there’s life (suitors) after not accepted ED. Good luck to your S! The world is his oyster.</p>
<p>Thanks all for the nice words. I was not fishing for compliments, merely trying to help others.
Lisztserve, as I am too lazy to try to find the ongoing list, Are we allowed to hear the final choice options? I always enjoy following the process. If you are not comfortable sharing, I do understand.</p>
<p>Putting in a plug to have the readers of this thread to respond to a thread I started on the Parents Forum.
<a href=“http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1312827-looking-mid-size-mid-atlantic-mid-selectivity-schools.html[/url]”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1312827-looking-mid-size-mid-atlantic-mid-selectivity-schools.html</a></p>
<p>Can anyone share information regarding a second visit to a college? </p>
<p>I guess as I read this thread (and others), it makes me wonder about the time and money investment in visiting schools. My husband I both work full-time. Therefore we can only visit schools on weekends or during the summer, (or take a day off, but this would be rare). Also, like all the other Juniors and Seniors (next Fall), my S has lots of schoolwork and commitments. Of course I recognize the huge commitment (time and $) of college, so I recognize the importance of these visits… I am just wondering how to make the most of these trips. </p>
<p>So what do you think is the purpose of a second visit? What would we see that we didn’t see the first time? I assume we would not attend the “formal” information session/tour again? Do you agree that summer trips are not very beneficial as we will basically just see the “physical” campus as opposed to get a “feel” for the college life there? What about sleepovers on campus?</p>
<p>Again - thank you for your insight.</p>
<p>Champs2004, obviously a lot depends on the first visit experience (drive-by or overnight, e.g.). I think typically second visits are used by admitted students to really narrow their choices, and by staying overnight with a student, allow them to experience a much greater range of campus life. As for summer visits, they are better than no visits.</p>
<p>Champs-I think the kid views the school/city/campus differently the second time around. The question, “Can I envision myself here?” takes on greater meaning. That’s not to say every school needs to be visited a second time, but maybe when the student has narrowed the decision to 2. I respectfully disagree with Sop14–I believe a summer visit, when the campus is does not resemble its normal look and feel, is not worth your time or money. It doesn’t really answer the kid’s question of whether s/he belongs there.</p>
<p>Vitrac, I do think there is useful information to be gleaned in the summer. UMichigan is plenty active in the summer, and though you might not get a sense of what the school is like on game days, it’s easy to compare to a SLAC, even in July. I did all my college visits in the summer, since that was the only time my father could take me; my kid had to do some of hers during the summer, and her impressions weren’t particularly swayed by the relative dearth of students (on the other hand, she was comparing specific programs, not Greek life). I’ll agree it’s not optimal, but not the end of the earth, and still better than no visit.</p>
<p>Champs: I agree with Vitrac regarding second visits. It would seem that the main reason to do a second visit if the student hasn’t been admitted to the schoolwould be if the student is applying ED. In the case of S1 we were in a similar situation as you were regarding time concerns and my S was applying to schools over a broad geographic area. We didn’t even do first visits at a few schools he applied to and several of the schools we did visit he ruled out. That isn’t ideal but he is going to one of those schools and is very happy there. Our Junior year search which was done mostly when school was not in session and gave us a good feel for what my S liked and didn’t like in a school and from there we generalized for the application choices. (Again not the best strategy for showing interest and gaining admission but it worked out.) As for second visits,(assuming there was a first one ) those all have come after the acceptances have been in. For us they have been to hone in on the areas that we wanted more information on. An overnight is always a great idea, we have also made appointments to meet with profs from the major areas being considered, just last weekend my S spent time visiting with students from Hillel. Taking a good look at the dorms especially tomake a dorm choice is another consideration for a second visit after admission. We have not retaken any of the formal tours but if there was an organized program that we did not have time to attend the first time we scheduled it the second time around. Taking time to sit in on a class or too can also be helpful.</p>
<p>On summer visits - we used this as a starting point before son’s junior year of hs. Did only day trips on a Saturday - so no work or activities were missed - and used it as an opportunity to see various types of campuses - urban vs. rural - small LAC vs. mid-sized university. Just to give all of us an intro to what the various options are and how they differ. We found this very useful. So - if we were having a later discussion about another school - I could describe it as being similar in size or location to one we had already seen - it helped put it into perspective.</p>
<p>It was also helpful to get a feel for the campus in terms of how spread out it was - what the surrounding area looked like, etc. We were able to do info sessions/tours - and the parking was easy!</p>
<p>I do want to chime in on this…I have girls; but I am advising an increasing number of boys…Venus v mars in terms of college searches…</p>
<p>Girls: need to see if they “fit” with the current student population; going in the summer would be a total waste of time in most, if not all, situations EXCEPT, as RVM states, for really early initial reads on types of schools…</p>
<p>Boys: summer visits are fine; they are infinitely (at least in my experience) less concerned with seeing who else attends; it is more their moms who deal with that…2nd visits can seal that either before an ED application or, alternatively, after admission…</p>
<p>If anyone has kids who fit their opposite gender objectives, feel free to adjust…but I don’t think you can generalize the summer visits for all kids…</p>
<p>Just my take…</p>
<p>And, fwiw, while we are on the subject of college lists and gender, the male/female social dynamic on some campuses is like day and night…</p>
<p>I am female and I have 2 Ds so I plead ignorance as far as understanding the male psyche. I started Penn State in the summer and loved every minute. But it bore absolutely no resemblance to Penn State the rest of the year. If I had visited during the summer and based my decision on that visit, it would have been a big mistake. In that way, it can hurt, bc a kid (a girl) can draw the wrong conclusion of what life would be like there.</p>
<p>I disagree about boys being okay with summer visits. Actually, summer visits to any small colleges, or campuses without summer programs going on did not fare well at all. I did them with all three, but they really couldn’t get a feel for the campus or the programs without the Professors or students. It’s not so much the looks of the students but if you can’t ask the students or the Professors about classes, internships, then it’s just buildings. </p>
<p>I know a lot of people don’t like open houses but for kids sort of on the shy side that aren’t going to seek out Professors but have an idea of their major, these were very handy for us. Everything is open and Professors were available. The exception to this for us was one particular state school where there were way too many students and each tour had too many people. Some colleges get around that by simply having more tour guides or breaking the groups up into different majors.</p>
<p>If time and money are an issue, I would hold off on summer visits until after acceptances and use the visit for final decisions. If applying ED and just to be sure that it is the right choice, then it makes sense to go for a 2nd decision before applying.</p>
<p>On the 2nd visit, ask to sit in on a class, stay over with a student if possible, have coffee with students, attend organization meetings or sports events if interested. Just walk the campus and stare at people. Sit in the student lounge.</p>
<p>Hi All,</p>
<p>Just wanted to let you know that D and I came back today from a visit to Beloit College and were very impressed. I think it is a wonderful option for serious/eclectic Jewish students looking for a small liberal arts college. Kids looking for a “party” school should stay away.</p>
<p>For those of you not familiar, Beloit is a “College that Changes Lives” and has about 1300 students. Even though the Hillel website says that there are only 120 Jews on campus, we met plenty of Jewish students during Junior Visiting Day and met other Jewish high school students. I don’t, however, think that Beloit has a “Jewish scene.”</p>
<p>Don’t let the obscure location scare you away. It is a one 1 hour bus ride from Chicago O’Hare.</p>
<p>Next week is University of Illinois (not my choice), Wooster (another CTCL), Oberlin (reach) and Case (lisztserve - thanks for comments)</p>
<p>Interesting time to skim various CC threads - lots of sad stories of high stat kids who were rejected or waitlisted by top tier schools - and many who have no options they are happy with - at least today.</p>
<p>Unless I am mistaken - everyone who has been reading and posting on this thread has had a reasonably successful admissions process. If there is someone who is not in a good place today - let us know - so that we can simply lend a shoulder or make some suggestions.</p>
<p>I think we have all learned from each other and we have really stressed the need to have several safety schools that would be an acceptable option. Applying to a “safety” school that you hate defeats the purpose.</p>
<p>I’ve said this before - but I enjoyed the college process with my “B” student much more than I did with my “A” student. Multiple reasons - but a primary one was simply less pressure. I found it more enjoyable exploring schools that were a bit off the radar than trying to compete with the masses for a spot at a top 25.</p>
<p>So - I’m glad we don’t seem to have any of the angst that is going on elsewhere on CC right now - but if there is someone reading this who is not a happy camper tonight - let us know.</p>
<p>Thinking, thinking…S’s top choice acceptances are Dickinson, Lafayette and Case Western. Three great choices! My impression is that all three offer small classes, good liberal arts, attention from professors and supportive environment. Case offers the positives of a diverse population and broad social experience, in a city, but has a reputation for hard work that some find oppressive. Lafayette feels like a comfortable, happy fit now, but maybe less intellectual culture and room to grow academically & socially? Dickinson, with serious academics and an interesting global orientation, is the smallest of the three, with a campus that “felt quiet” when S visited. Lafayette and Case have more of a “pre-professional” atmosphere than Dickinson, I believe.
Where will this work-in-progress find his passion, engage with other curious original thinkers, be challenged, have fun and hone his skills?</p>
<p>EvanstonDad, thanks for the note about Beloit. There’s a lot that sounds great about the school, but I do have in my notes that there’s pretty much nothing when it comes to organized Jewish activities, just a Jewish Students Organization with a moribund website. But with more Jewish students and prospies, maybe that’ll change. </p>
<p>D2’s school year starts August 14. I’m thinking that we may do a family short vacation in August to Colorado, and hey, look, the University of Denver! Since we’re here, let’s take a look!
;)</p>
<p>Yes Rockville, I am in complete agreement! I think our “B” kids did very, very well :)</p>