<p>I’m just back from a Passover dessert get-together with some women from my temple. I was able to catch up with a mom whose DS went through all years of Hebrew school and confirmation with my DS. I knew we’d catch up on college visits, top choices, etc.</p>
<p>Her DS’ first choice… GEORGETOWN! I couldn’t believe it after the conversation here today. I was so confused. Really? So here’s what she told me: lots of Jewish kids, their tour guide was Jewish, services every Friday night, rabbi on campus, etc. Didn’t see a lot of religious symbols. She said his heart is set on it, but it’s a reach for everyone. (Although I told her that her DS may be more desirable bc of his religion!) While it’s not for a B student, I guess it is a consideration for Jewish students.</p>
<p>Another mom, with a DD who is a freshman at BU, talked about how they paid someone (a CPA) to fill out the financial aid forms (FAFSA/ CSS) for them. And he told them that he helped get them money. Then she mentions that her DD only got merit aid. It was insane, but I had to back off…I ended up saying, well, if you don’t want to do the forms and you want to pay, that’s another story. So she was recommending the CPA to the woman above to help with financial aid forms. I went on to tell them about resources online to find scholarships.</p>
<p>I suppose that there are always people willing to pay others for things they don’t want to bother with. Just not my choice for some aspects of the college process. I probably pay for things they would never pay for. I have to remember that.</p>
<p>I agree that every student (and parent) needs to weigh in on the culture of the institution and whether he/she feels welcomed and has access to the sorts of groups desired. I only mention the Jesuits as one consideration because the commitments to social justice and to healing the world really mirror Jewish precepts, which should not be a shock since they got it all from Judaism. At LMU in Los Angeles, I’ve maybe seen a cross once in a classroom. (There is one in the church on campus, obviously.) There are core classes students take related to religion, but the types available are varied. No one tries to convert anyone. One of the Muslim professors is the most popular with all the students because of his national work on interfaith dialogue with Jews and Christians. The professors come from all religions and none. LMU’s not as highly ranked as GT, of course, but it may be an option for a student who’s more in the “B” or “B+” category, although like all the universities, it’s getting harder to get in these days. When I attended a student presentation that included Jews, LGBT, Latino, etc., there was strong consensus there was a place for everyone there. One other point, the Jesuits can offer really nice FA packages (merit and need-based), and since there are around 22 in the country, there are lots to choose from.</p>
<p>Not sure that you have to have a CPA complete the FAFSA since the IRS tool now just pours your tax return into the form. That said, my son was accepted at Fordham, and they provided a free service where in about 25 minutes, the processor did it all for me. They began using the professional service and offering it free to parents because it increased their likelihood of accurate FAFSAs.</p>
<p>You definitely don’t need a CPA to fill out the FAFSA–particularly since you have to supply all the information, and the hardest part is just gathering it all (but you should’ve done that already for your taxes). The FAFSA takes all of 10 minutes. The CSS-Profile is a bit longer and requires more info, but even then a CPA is overkill for all but the most complicated of tax situations.</p>
<p>^^LInYMOM: BU only gives merit aid if you fill out the FA forms…actually, while I wouldn’t do it, if your kid wants BU and you want $$, not a terribly bad idea to have help tweaking those forms…only for them, IMO, unless you have done the net price calculator and you KNOW you will be eligible for FA…yes, BU is weird with this; the only award that does not require filing is the Trustee award (for tippy top kids)</p>
<p>When my older D was in this process, my H refused to spend hours and hours filling out the CSS profile for the outside possibility thatBU would decide my top stats D deserved $$; it was a good move; she ended up with merit almost everywhere else without us having to jump through hoops…</p>
<p>Hello - I posted this over on the UD forum but thought I’d post here for your benefit as well. </p>
<p>We attended as admitted student visit yesterday and were disappointed in the visit. As others who attended the UD admitted student day visit have said, the"information session" is not very informational. It consists of two students telling their personal stories about UD which may or may not be relevant to any particular student. The presentation seemed to stress the “campus feel” of UD as the overriding factor (according to their “food pyramid” type graph). Topics that we were more interested in, like quality of academics, class size, advising, etc. were not really mentioned. I mean, we all know that its fun to be a “blue hen” and all, but there is more to college than that. One of the students mentioned that the highlight of her study abroad in Africa was seeing all the cute baby animals…let’s just say, it was not impressive.</p>
<p>Our tour group leader was more informative, but our group of students/parents overall seemed fairly unimpressed/unenthusiastic. The tour took us mostly the same places we had already seen on our first visit for Discovery Day last summer. The difference this time was there were actually students around, and we got to eat lunch in a dining hall. The lunch was good and I give kudos to the UD Creamery Ice Cream! The student body appears to be largely white/middle class- a happy but homogeneous student body.</p>
<p>We took the opportunity to sit in on a lecture class prior to the 11am tour. Unfortunately, this lecture class did not reflect well upon UD as the prof was TERRIBLE and merely read off his powerpoints. Many students in the room were playing video games or on facebook. </p>
<p>The dorm we visited, Harrington, is traditional dorm style with double rooms and hall bathrooms. There is no A/C in the dorms. Floors are coed. There is a large construction site on the East Campus where new dorms are being built. As opposed to other schools we have visited, dorm security at UD is very lax (you just use your swipe card to get in, so you could swipe in any number of guests) and there is no visitor policy or sign-in. Perhaps this reflects the fact that UD is fairly safe…but it still left us feeling that security was lax.</p>
<p>On the plus side, I will say that UD is one of the most beautiful college campuses I have ever seen, and with many flowering trees in bloom the campus showed off well.</p>
<p>Pamom–Thank you for that very informative reflection. When we visited UDel with D1 three years ago, the presentation involved an adcom describing the admissions essay that was her very favorite of all the thousands she read over the years. Everyone was anxious to hear what she considered original, interesting, different from the ordinary piece of writing that applicants submit. I won’t go into it here, but what she revealed seemed pretty dumb. Her description fell flat and I left thinking that maybe UDel wasn’t for us. This adcom had no idea of the impact that had, not only for us, but other people present that day. </p>
<p>Obviously, it is unwise to judge a college based on the above incident. Similarly unwise to judge a college based on one lousy lecture by one lousy professor. But these things add up and it’s unfortunate when just about the time you have to write that hefty check you are left with a bad taste in your mouth.</p>
<p>well it is looking more and more like D2 will pick Drexel. What is funny is that at the beginning of this process I never would have picked Drexel for her and in fact it wasn’t even on her list. But when she asked to visit more schools close to home that weren’t small liberal arts colleges, Drexel was the one that popped into my head. And when we visited, it really spoke to her. Drexel’s info sessions were really well done and made a convincing case for the coop education program. She also liked the small class sizes, student diversity, and (surprisingly) my suburban D2 who never goes into the city that is 15 minutes away from our house now seems to look forward to city living! She likes that Drexel attracts career minded, academically focused students who are not looking at college primarily as a chance to “party.” So…while she has not officially announced, I think the decision is going to be Drexel!</p>
<p>I think that the one negative I hear frequently about UD is the Admitted Students Day. My friend took her DS last year to Admitted Students Day at UD and Penn State. Penn State won hands down (although UD was leading up that point). My friend chalked it up to just a “bad day” for UD (different complaints that others have said, but still). But it’s a repetitive theme. </p>
<p>It’s really too bad because it just doesn’t reflect the school. As a UD parent (of a very happy soph), I would love to give the school some feedback and suggestions. If anyone wants to PM me what a great Admitted Students Day offers (as compared to their experience at UD), I would welcome that.</p>
<p>pamom: I totally trust your experience - just want to point out that if you are used to dorm security in Philly, this is a completely different environment. My DD has visited her friend at Temple a couple of times and has told me about the security of the dorms there, which is unbelievably tight – and it’s for good reason. At Temple, one of the girls had to leave at 6 am to drive back to her school in VA and everyone who signed in with her the night before had to go down to the front desk with her when she signed out. At 6 am. Not popular but they had to do it. That’s just one example. Are you comparing UD to Drexel and Temple or to other suburban colleges? I’ve been to more than a dozen campuses and UD did not stand out to me as being lax. Just wondering.</p>
<p>LINYMOM- I was comparing the security at the urban campuses (Drexel, Temple, Pitt) to UD- granted I’m sure that UD’s system is probably not any different from other suburban campuses like Penn State- but given all the bomb threat drama now going on at Pitt I have a heightened sensitivity to security!</p>
<p>The best admitted student program that I attended was at Drexel. Students were assembled in different meeting rooms by college (business, engineering, arts and sciences, etc) and then given a presentation about that particular college by an admissions officer and a dean of the college. After the general presentation, the group was divided up by major, and we then got a presentation by a faculty dean in that major, as well as four students who told the stories of their academic and coop experiences at Drexel, as well as their future career/grad school plans. Then a Q&A session. Following this, participants could choose a variety of activities including campus tours, dorm tours (every dorm was open for tours), lunch in the dining hall, and optional presentations on financial aid, the coop program, the honors college, and study abroad. It was really comprehensive!</p>
<p>If you haven’t officially been welcomed to this thread, let me welcome you. Yes, UD is the University of Delaware. Do you have college-age children?</p>
<p>Wonder if the number taken off the UDEL waitlist would be less if the accepted student day was run better? really a shame…</p>
<p>Way back when my D1 was admitted to Vandy RD, and was making a decision, we attended accepted student day; mind you, this was our 2nd visit to the school…it was the WORST; my H was actually mad I made him take off from work to fly down to Nashville to attend…</p>
<p>at the time, I just assumed that they didn’t need to “convince” anybody; certainly didn’t convince my D…</p>
<p>Re the admitted students days, I do think they help to make s difference, atleast when the student has a few top favorites and is trying to make the end decision. At least for us it did. </p>
<p>My DD was leaning heavily CofC, quickly followed by PSU and UDel. JMU 4th on the list. After the admitted students day, JMU took the lead by a mile. It started with the opening of the program - which is quite impressive. How you manage to get about 150 students up at 730am on a snowy saturday morning, all wearing purple and gold, to line the walk and cheer for the new students, I will never know. I do know that from the first minute she walked onto the campus, to talking with students, professors, and even the president of the college, every single person made her feel welcome, wanted and accepted. She even got an email from one of the department heads later in the week. She had spoken with her about a double major and the dept head took it upon herself to email my D and confirm some things they discussed.</p>
<p>CofC was ok, but very much like an open house, which we had already attended. No real access to professors and a lot of conflicts in scheduling. UDel fell completely flat. She scratched PSU at the last minute after JMU, and said she wanted a little smaller than 44,000 and would rather go JMu. </p>
<p>So I think it can, and does often, make a difference.</p>
<p>Admitted Students Day at American absolutely made the difference for my daughter. She started out the college search process really believing that Brandeis was her b’shert. Visited spring of junior year and spent a shabbat there–said it was like camp, LOVED it. Added a few other schools to the list but pretty much thought Brandeis was the one. </p>
<p>She was admitted to 4 of her 5 schools, ruled out one, did admitted students programs at the other three, including Brandeis. AU was the last one. She had us pay the deposit at lunch time.</p>
<p>in my constant attempt to entertain…i give you a very funny John Stewart clip. Entitled Easter Vs. Passover. I promise some laugh out loud moments. Copy and paste. </p>
<p>socaldad: I posted that on my FB page a few days ago. Love Jon Stewart. The clip reminded me of the Ben Stiller movie, Keeping The Faith. With the Baptist choir coming through the back doors of the syngagogue singing Ain Cailohenu (sp?). Funny stuff.</p>