Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>^^if your school is like most, you can opt out of having his rank on his transcript at all…find out…</p>

<p>Problem is, for most, if not all, honors programs, they will subsequently request a rank (or percentage) from the High school even if it is not on the transcript…</p>

<p>Mom24boys, what’s the school?</p>

<p>There might be more flexibility, with the 5% meant to be a guideline. You or your son can call and ask if 5% is hard and fast, or if the honors admissions program considers mitigating factors. Exceptional SAT scores + strong grades in 10th and 11th in a challenging curriculum outweighs a weak freshman year in my book. If the college doesn’t want to allow for maturation, it’s their loss. :)</p>

<p>Rodney - County wide policy is rank has to be on transcript. </p>

<p>SlitheyTove - U of Pitt. I have talked to the honors college and exchanged some e-mails and I think they would be willing to bend, I just thought it would be easy to bend if transcript did not have rank.</p>

<p>I guess we will have to wait and see. So any other suggestions for schools like U of Pitt - I’m pretty sure he will get in, but attending will depend on merit (currently 1st choices are Rochester, Case Western and Pitt).</p>

<p>Mom24boys, I think it would be okay to send the transcript before Oct. 1st without the class rank. If the school asks for it, I would be honest and say that it won’t be available until after Oct. 1st. Our county doesn’t release class rank until 10/1 either. I know that Pitt agreed to accept an unofficial transcript dated prior to that date from my friends D.</p>

<p>I also remember that your son has BU as a possibility. He might qualify for the Trustee’s Scholarship, which I believe is full tuition. There’s a separate application due in the fall.</p>

<p>I was going to guess Pitt! Yes, they are flexible. Or at least that was very much the impression I got from my visit with D1 a few years back. The philosophy was (is?) that you were choosing to be in the Honors College, rather than it choosing you. Your son can apply with a clear conscience.</p>

<p>Mom24boys, why don’t you call the college (or have your S do it, apropos of previous discussion) & ask if the class rank is decisive in every case? We were told by one college honors office that it would look beyond the “requisite” GPA to consider the student’s whole profile.
When you say you are looking for other colleges like Pitt, Rochester and Case - what are the criteria? Urban research universities with strong undergrad engineering and math? Particular size range of undergrad cohort? </p>

<p>Did everyone read “Home Colleging” by Patricia Marx (New Yorker, Sept 19, 2011)? Here’s the link to the abstract, and the first few paragraphs: [“Home</a> Colleging” : The New Yorker](<a href=“http://www.newyorker.com/humor/2011/09/19/110919sh_shouts_marx]“Home”>http://www.newyorker.com/humor/2011/09/19/110919sh_shouts_marx)</p>

<p>lisztserve:</p>

<p>That is very funny! I’m sure we all can relate to parts of that article!</p>

<p>Listserve: Thank you, the article is laugh out loud funny.</p>

<p>Criteria is evolving, when we started looking I was 100% sure he wanted quirky, geeky all tech school in the suburbs. I was 100% wrong. After visiting a lot of schools, he wants urban, mid-size (5000-20000), happy students, diversity, engineering (but not cut throat) and the option to switch to physics or math if engineering doesn’t work. He wants to get out of Maryland, I want him in drivable range or direct Southwest flight.</p>

<p>I want good disability services, merit aid and some Jewish life. BU is still on the list. Alabama is also on the list because of its Aspergers Support program and National Merit.</p>

<p>He and I have talked to several people at Pitt and the answers where different, but guardedly optimistic.</p>

<p>mom24boys- check into Drexel. I think it meets all of your criteria.</p>

<p>Interesting chart on The Choice…
I just came across this post yesterday on the Choice. It shows select universities and the number of applicants, acceptance rate, and what percent was excepted ED vs. Regular.<br>
Elon stands out. 86% acceptance rate for ED vs only 29% for RD. There are other schools that have higher ED rates, but none this extreme. I think this chart might be interesting to Junior parents.
Here is a link.
[College</a> Admissions Advice - The Choice Blog - NYTimes.com](<a href=“http://thechoice.blogs.nytimes.com/]College”>http://thechoice.blogs.nytimes.com/)</p>

<p>There is a link on the chart that takes you to the full chart with more schools…</p>

<p>Socaldad: I think one of the reasons that Elon has such a high ED rate is because of the small # of kids who use it vs the entire applicant pool (runs around 400 v 10,000 for the remaining decision dates as you can see on the chart)…it has been my impression that the EA option there reduces the “urge” to apply ED for many kids…</p>

<p>If that ever changed, I would imagine the ED #'s and subsequent acceptance rate would be very different…</p>

<p>This burned at least two of my students this year…neither were accepted; and it was at the top of their lists…</p>

<p>What really surprised me was the Lehigh ED rate above 60%…</p>

<p>I knew it was getting ridiculous, but UMass admission rate is now 11%! So much for being our state public school option.</p>

<p>^ I think that was in error. 11% would be much lower than every public university in the US (and lower than Penn, Chicago, Cornell, Northwestern, WUSTL…) This shows the acceptance rate at UMass-Amherst for the Class of 2016 at 62%. </p>

<p>[Admissions</a> Roundup: Class of 2016](<a href=“http://mycca.net/_blog/MyCCA_News/post/Admissions_Roundup_Class_of_2016/]Admissions”>http://mycca.net/_blog/MyCCA_News/post/Admissions_Roundup_Class_of_2016/)</p>

<p>Huh? That is strange. But I do know it can be difficult for in-state students to get in. You’re probably right about it being an error: There’s no way it’s that low.</p>

<p>EDIT: Ok, duh! I just realized that there talking about Amherst College, not UMass Amherst. Silly me :eek:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I had noticed the surprising Elon numbers as well, and I think there is a calculation error. I did the calculations myself with the raw data and came up with a 49% RD acceptance rate. My theory is that the error had something to do with Elon offering both EA and ED, while most schools only offer one or the other.</p>

<p>We just toured Penn State for my D2 who is a junior. She liked it a lot but the location and size worry me. Do kids feel isolated being so far away from a city? What about Jewish life on campus? If anyone has kids there, please let me know how they like it. She wants a large school with a lot of spirit and Penn State definitely meets those requirements.</p>

<p>Hey sacchi: the NYtimes chart for Elon does not account for the EA round at all…you would need to know the acceptance rates for each round to figure out the overall…</p>

<p>We have 86% for ED and 29% for RD but don’t know the # of applicants for the latter one, and we are completely missing the EA piece for both acceptance rate and # of applicants…</p>

<p>The only # released for both pieces was the ED back in January…I think if my memory serves me, approx 400 applied ED…or close to that give or take 50.</p>

<p>Elon EA, 6300 applied, 50% offered acceptance.</p>

<p>Based on ny times, and samtalya, if you want to go to elon, you would be crazy to apply rd. junior parents, who are interested, should visit now, and apply early.<br>
Looks like Leigh is similar…</p>

<p>Here is how I calculated the Elon numbers, using raw data from
<a href=“https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0ArlRBr9Qvz0mdEdLNzNsRnBKT3Z1dDZ5QTFCQVV1NkE&output=html[/url]”>2012 Admission Decisions - Google Drive;
and
<a href=“https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?hl=en_US&hl=en_US&key=0ArlRBr9Qvz0mdFNZOE9BM3gtRHFnaExVNnpBcVM4SEE&output=html[/url]”>Early Admission - Google Drive;

<p>I used the numbers reported in Dec of EA and ED applications and acceptances, and calculated the RD numbers by subtracting EA and ED from the totals.</p>

<p>Elon, Tot, ED, EA, RD
Applied, 10195, 400, 6329, 3466
Accepted, 5204, 343, 3162, 1699
Acc%, 51.0%, 85.8%, 50.0%, 49.0%</p>

<p>As a sanity check, here are numbers from Barnard, using same method. (Just picked Barnard since it was the first on the list with ED numbers provided, that didn’t also offer EA.) Its numbers match well.</p>

<p>Barnard, Tot, ED, EA, RD
Applied, 5440, 562, 0, 4878
Accepted 1141, 252, 0, 889
Acc%, 21.0% 44.8%, #DIV/0!, 18.2%</p>

<p>As I prepared these numbers, the one thing that occurred to me, which might make my calculation wrong after all, is that perhaps a large number of the EA students were deferred but ultimately accepted. In that case, the number of EA acceptances I got from the data available in Dec would no longer be accurate, so the number of RD acceptances I calculated would be wrong.</p>