Colleges for the Jewish "B" student (Part 1)

<p>HollieSue and Emmybet!</p>

<p>Great to “see” you both! :D</p>

<p>Hope the ups and downs of life have more ups than downs…can you believe our 2015 children are almost finished with their first year of college? Wow. Hope that your D’s have settled into a routine…HollieSue: yours is at Juniata (sp?)? Everything ok? Emmybet: glad to hear your D has had a good year…things were rough at first, but now it’s better? She’s made friends and likes the environment? Being near NYC is a huge plus, especially with a theater major! </p>

<p>ST: where do you come up with these you tube clips? Unbelieveable! :smiley: ;)</p>

<p>And look, it’s old home week! :)</p>

<p>Chocchip, any movie clip that you can remember you can probably find on youtube. The sad thing is that I remember that clip primarily from “The Sopranos” and not from the Godfather movies.</p>

<p>Emmy-So happy it worked out for your D. I remember when you visited D early on. Now you’re a CC success story. Can you elaborate on the “hangin in there” aspect of the process?</p>

<p>luvMom, I feel for you. we had so many lows throughout this process including zombie visits to colleges, essay-writing paralysis, nihilism, pitched battles over who was ruining whose life, etc. Some of the famous lines I remember: “I love college! The girls are gorgeous and the beach is nearby!” (one of first campus visits as a Junior to a southern school.) “It doesn’t matter where I go. They’re all the same. College is what you make of it” (half-way through an expensive four-city campus trek.) “Wait - could you start over? I wasn’t listening” (Half-hour into a one-on-one campus tour.) “I don’t have to apply anywhere else. I’m gonna get in” (in December of senior year, shortly before rejection by his ED school.)
I could NEVER have predicted where we’d be today based on where we started. We visited almost 20 schools, from CTCL to LACs to research Us to state U. His initial criteria were sunny weather, lenient drinking regulations, good campus food, “chill” kids, high female to male ratio, easy classes, car privileges for freshmen and guaranteed entree to a high-paying job after graduation. This view called for patience from his egghead parents. His 3 final top choices weren’t even ON the list until several weeks before their application deadlines, and we didn’t visit or interview until after apps were in. For some kids it is simply a growth process - complex, emotional, tied in to lots of issues (as you’ve noted). You know what, though? It was a wonderful opportunity to get to know him as he got to know himself. </p>

<p>Rodney, Case has one application/admission to all undergrad schools, and students can also cross-register in Cleveland Institutes of Art and Music.</p>

<p>Hmm. Really, you are right. It IS just a question of “hangin in there”!</p>

<p>D did struggle first semester - she loved the program, what she was learning, and felt the school was the right choice for the most part. But her adjustment issues came from dealing with her personal life, mostly in the details of living on campus - roommates, classmates, transportation, food, time management, mood management, etc.</p>

<p>She had some bad luck - a poor housing situation, plus some situations that cut down her ability to connect with people and to do things that she needs to be happy. Even though she knew some of these problems going in, she was overloaded and surprised by how they affected her. She also had some maturing to do in how to address problems and make things work for herself. </p>

<p>Some of these issues have actually resolved - she’s changed things about her schedule and how she does things to suit her needs, and she’s focused on making more friends and reaching out to professors. Some things couldn’t be changed, but she has found ways to avoid those irritations. And over time she also has gotten into the “meat” of the educational and social experience, which has washed away many of the disappointments from last fall. </p>

<p>I don’t have any secrets for someone who deals with this issue next year - and honestly I’d say more kids than we expect have this experience. But I’d say that if it happens to your child: look at the details, make sure there isn’t something truly wrong going on (like illness, depression, insurmountable challenges, etc.), then just keep telling them they will be all right, that they are capable of finding solutions. Cheer their small successes, and be patient. Help them to be patient. It’s far too easy to be overly idealistic about college, and that makes reality feel much harsher than it really is.</p>

<p>My D had to decide to face things that only she could change (as opposed to wishing the place and people would just “be different”), and she had to see all of the wonderful opportunities she could have if she reached for them. She needed some time, and to get the complaints out of her system, and to rack up a few successes so she could feel more confident.</p>

<p>Once I knew she was fundamentally OK, I let her deal with this on her own. I did make sure I wasn’t getting an unhealthy amount of negativity dumped on me, though. There came a point when I told her I couldn’t hear only about the endless problems - that she had to find someone else (perhaps a counselor) to help her, or she needed to change how she talked about things. That was a scary thing for me to do, but sometimes you have to get real. Don’t be afraid to say that either they’re talking about leaving/transferring - which is totally OK, but they’re going to have to get that ball rolling - or they’re going to have to find ways to make this work. Most kids find a solution, either at that school or at a different one that has what they’ve learned they need.</p>

<p>Good luck to all of the '12s, '13s and beyond! This is a very exciting time in all of your lives. Having a college grad and a soon to be college sophomore, I can honestly say that it is a wonderful journey, and that having grown-up kids is a new and rewarding challenge. Many things are very serious, and sometimes very scary, but it is a rich experience for all of us. </p>

<p>PS - My Tufts '11 grad is doing fine, too, working in her field for peanuts, and moving into a grad program next spring.</p>

<p>Welcome back, HollieSue! Concerned for your D…want to share? Wishing her a healthy spring, summer, year, life!</p>

<p>Welcome back EmmyBet! So glad your D is NOW having fun. It’s always a process – life. Never easy. 2 steps forward, 1 step back. Lessons learned. To endure, to earn, to appreciate. Glad she found her way. </p>

<p>Don’t be strangers you 2!</p>

<p>Knew I could count on y’all to not only make me feel better, but to give sage advice to boot.</p>

<p>MiamiDAP, “for 4 most important years of her life”…Yeah, that’s what worries me, but thanks for believing that D will find her way. I believe she will, too. Actually, before my DD traveled to Israel, she chose the schools we visited which ranged from safety to reach. With D’s understanding, I cut uber-reaches off her list, then made reservations & travel arrangements while she was away. (If you have a kid that plans trips, well, kudos to you!) DD was interested in, and actually felt connected to (having done a little research) all but 1. Mind you, she was not enthused, merely interested! Her interest waned, not due to the amount of campuses visited (I know many families who visited several colleges, because they could, because of time & distance, because school was in session, on Spring Break. 5 schools in 8 days just wasn’t a big deal.), nor to the inability to visualize herself on each campus, but to the realization that despite great effort on her part, acceptance is still a crapshoot and rejection is a possibility. This played on her fears, and the wall went up. </p>

<p>BTW, in Israel, D led as close to a college experience (for 2 months) as a HS kid gets…most challenging academics ever, dorm life (sharing with roomies, doing her own laundry, etc), sole responsibility for studying, time management, waking herself in the morning :), independence & freedom from parents-lol, making new friends. She excelled & was so happy! And that was part of our present problem…After about 3 days home, school was boring, her home teachers didn’t rate in comparison to her Israeli instructors, her heart was breaking from missing her new friends, and living once again with family now seemed confining. You’d think, then, that she’d rush in pursuit of college. But, no. D, perhaps too serious and analytical, realizes how transient life can be, that people you love can come & go, that nothing is forever. (This she communicates. She cries. My heart breaks.) So, D does the ostrich thing, staving off reality. </p>

<p>momjr, Thanks for your support & kind words. As long as our kids know we’re behind them 100% (I told my D this again this am), time’s a healer. Hate to think about the alternatives (community college, gap year), but know it’s not the end of the world. Unfortunately, to add insult to injury, The Boyfriend (detest The Boyfriend! Why, oh why must their even be a Boyfriend?) reneged about going with D to the Prom. Found her dress on the floor and asked…</p>

<p>pamom59,

– hilarious! Like you, I don’t feel the trip was truly wasted time. On the more superficial level, my DD rated the campuses on physical beauty, dining & dorms. On the deeper side, she met with a professor (but couldn’t quite gather the nerve to actually articulate anything, much less converse), and asked (me) about 4-year vs 5-year Teaching/College of Education programs. Funny story - One of our best Student Ambassadors (Tour Guides) told us how "ticked” she was when her parents “dragged” her to visit colleges during Spring Break, but how it was the best thing they could have done…She thanked them 2 years later! My DD has ears and they work.</p>

<p>Slitheytove, Can’t begin to express how greatly I appreciate your kindness in backing me up & your humor-the classic debacle. Not sure I’m delighted to be in the category of “misery loves company”, but certainly good to know that others have “been there, done that”. Really, your caring is curing.</p>

<p>shawbridge, Re: Canada - My DH & I celebrated our anniversary @ the Jazz Fest in Montreal one year. Not a city girl, I was surprised how much I loved, really loved, the Montreal vibe, culture, feel. Nice college town, too. My neighbor is Canadian. He’s already prepping his 4-year-old for McGill-lol. Re: Rejection – appreciate your input. Honestly, it’s thoughtful, even a bit courageous of you to share your my-child-was-less-than-perfect-but-rose-up story. Some of us would not venture there, but it is mighty helpful! I’m reminded of socalad42’s story of his D’s rise to maturity and how much it inspired me.</p>

<p>champs, Taking so many deep breaths I’m getting light-headed! Thx for the good thoughts. Yes, D needs time and space.</p>

<p>laplatinum, Grateful for the success story. Gives me hope! Only recently have I heard that such a thing as “College Consultants” exist. I’ll check into this. Funny your D emailed you from her room. My private, reserved, close-mouthed, gotta-play-20-questions-to-elicit-1-response-kinda D texts me from her bedroom, too! Sometimes she’ll write notes & leave them where I’ll find them. So, I’m waiting for contact! Often, parents who have Chatty-Cathy, open-book type kids just don’t get it. (My son, thank goodness, gabs about anything & everything the second he gets home from school.) </p>

<p>listserve, OK, I stand corrected…misery does love company! It feels good to relate, to belly-laugh about the stress, & to take strength from your journey! Though I can foresee essay angst, and can feel in the pit of my nauseous stomach your DS’s ED rejection, please, no nihilism in my future!</p>

<p>So, as EmmyBet says, I’m “hanging in there”! Most grateful to you, one & all. Swear I’ll write college reviews soon, just need to get productive right now.</p>

<p>Hi folks. I enjoyed reading your post Emmybet. College woes and the temptation to rescue your kid doesn’t end for freshman year. My S1’s experience was charmed until this second semester of Junior year. As a result of being a returning study abroad student he has an unfortunate roommate situation this spring semester. I was really worried about how this would affect his ability to function in school but resisted the huge temptation to intervene. A little embarassing for a Junior! Anyway it seems he’s ironed out a bunch of the kinks with his roommate without involving anyone else. Its not great and they won’t live together again but it is managable, and a growth experience for him.</p>

<p>And now and longlast we have a college committment. My S is going to TAMU. We’ve declined admission from UT Austin. I’m sorry Socal, I know you saw this coming. want Thank you for all of the support you provided. My S wouldn’t talk about the process until he made a decison and then at my urging he sat on it a couple of weeks. Once he made it this last time it was unshakable so he is set. Its odd how my focus changed as he was going through this. Aside from all of the great things about UT, as the reality of my S’s heath issues have become more real aside from all other considerations the closeness and accessibility of Austin became tremendously attractive. When I discussed this with him, my S quickly dismissed me telling me that that was not a reason to pick a school. I hope he is right! At the moment he is on a boatload of medicine, weaning off of prednisone but doing very well. Its a double edged sword, with each decrease in doasage I’m thrilled to get him off of it but worried that problems will return. For those of you who missed it, he was diagnosed with ulcerative colitis in February. In the mean time he hasn’t missed a beat and had been away several excursions including one to Eisner since then. He is learning to deal with this without me, so far so good.</p>

<p>spectrum - congrats on the TAMU decision - sounds like a well-thought out decision making process and I am glad to hear his health is improving as well.</p>

<p>rejection is not a tragedy, it is just another learning experience. College selection is NOT stressful, unless it is artificially made. It is one of the most exciting times and full of anticipation and great times at HS as finish line is getting closer.
D. has learned so much and in such a positive way, that it has helped her greatly to apply to Med. Schools, again choosing her schools based on her personal criteria and nothing else. If a kid does not feel good applying to schools (any level) that possibly will reject, why to do so? It is beyond me. Some are handling it OK, but if not, avoid all together, it is not worth it. Eventually they will learn to deal with rejections, unavoidable, but at 18 it may be just too early for some, while perfectly timed for others. My own D. was in second group, wne to her #2 with the smile on he face and looking back strongly believes that #1 was not as good of a choice for her UG.
Parent is the only person who can evaluate emotional maturity of a chilc. it should be taken into consideration very carefully.</p>

<p>Spectrum,</p>

<p>First, glad to see your S is getting a handle on his condition. I hope it continues to be a situation he can handle.
Second, Congrats on TAMU. It sounds like that was the way it should go. Since A&M is leaving the division, I will not root against you. Seriously, congrats…I enjoyed sharing the process with you…</p>

<p>Lovmom, though i am not at all deserving, I missed getting a little of the love you showered…Trust me, it is a long journey, and it will all work out.</p>

<p>Sending virtual hugs to socaldad42 just before Lovmom showers the love back atcha! It is hard for some parents to accept that some of our teenagers have to “leave notes around”, text, or email to communicate with us. My HS junior is the same way as her older sister who sent that original email from the other room telling me I was permitted to show up at the meeting with the private college counselor. Good outcome for my older daughter these several years later (she’s now a lawyer in London, practicing with a US-based law firm)–and it gives me hope to get through the Inferno with these last two.</p>

<p>I’m sorry to hear that some of the college students are having some struggles, but I appreciate everyone posting about both the good and bad, as it gives us all some perspective. A lot of people on CC seem to think, and I admit that I used to be one of them, that if a student could just achieve the goal to get into his/her dream school, he/she would live happily ever after. </p>

<p>Hearing about the good and bad of others make me better appreciate the good things and be more understanding and accepting of the bad things in the lives of my own two kids, college 2014 S and HS 2013 D.</p>

<p>Can I just say that I LOVE THIS THREAD? </p>

<p>Luvnmom- Like you, we did a major spring break college trip extravaganza. We went to six colleges in about five days. It was exhausting, it was sometimes tense, I had a meltdown on day three but life went on. There were also laughs and lessons learned and experiences gained. Hopefully, in time, you will see positives from the trip. I try to repeat the CC adage “Love the kid on the couch” many times over. Every one of our kids has countless strengths. :slight_smile: Your D might be taking “the scenic route” but in the end, she’ll get there and very probably with a lot greater grasp of what she does and doesn’t want.</p>

<p>HollieSue- I don’t want to pry into your D’s private affairs, so let me ask about this and you can judge whether you wish to respond or not. Juniata is one of the “possibles” on my daughter’s list (2013). Are there things about the school that you wish you had known? Any advice to give regarding that?</p>

<p>Emmybet- I greatly appreciate your feedback on how the first year has been for you and your daughter. I can imagine that I would be in your position and would eventually need to tell my D to get help if needed and not just tell me the negatives. I already see that tendency in her at times- to initially tell me only what is not going well- and then I worry while she is doing all right. </p>

<p>One of the things I have always loved best about this thread is the honesty. We hear about all kids across a wide variety of spectrums and it helps me so much. A great big thank you to all the parents on this thread who don’t try to present the perfect kid, but the kid who is just right in whatever form. :-)</p>

<p>The Chapman University Holocaust Memorial Library. It is located on the top floor of Chapman’s main library. It is incredible. </p>

<p>[Sala</a> and Aron Samueli Holocaust Memorial Library | Chapman University](<a href=“http://www.chapman.edu/research-and-institutions/holocaust-education/samueli-holocaust-memorial-library.aspx]Sala”>Page Not Found | Chapman University)</p>

<p>[Holocaust</a> Education at Chapman University | Chapman University](<a href=“http://www.chapman.edu/research-and-institutions/holocaust-education/index.aspx]Holocaust”>Holocaust Education at Chapman University | Chapman University)</p>

<p>Elie Wiesel has connected himself to only two Universities in the USA: Chapman University and Boston College</p>

<p><a href=“http://blogs.chapman.edu/happenings/2012/02/28/elie-wiesel-visit-to-be-highligted-by-conversations-with-students-faculty/[/url]”>http://blogs.chapman.edu/happenings/2012/02/28/elie-wiesel-visit-to-be-highligted-by-conversations-with-students-faculty/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>^^ I think you mean Boston University.</p>

<p>Sukahjoy: Thanks for the interesting information about Chapman. Elie Wiesel is a professor at Boston University, not Boston College. My D was fortunate to hear him lecture in the fall.</p>

<p>Spectrum: Congrats on the TAMU decision. I understand your worries about your son’s health. I hope he continues to do well.</p>

<p>Great to have holliesue and emmybet check in and share both good and bad experiences. we need you “old” :slight_smile: timers on this thread to guide us.</p>

<p>Spectrum, congrats on the decision. sounds like you have really done a very sound and patient job with S in getting to this point.</p>

<p>First & foremost, spectrum, so glad your son is on the road to good health and to TAMU - Congrats! You’ve done well, as he clearly believes in himself!!!</p>

<p>socaldad42,

Thank you for your kindness,
which I will not forget;
You’re one of the nicest people
that I have never met!
…On this thread, we are all deserving, as mutual support is the gift we give one another.:)</p>

<p>As sacchi, emmybet & holliesue remind us, parenting does not end when the fat envelope arrives & we wave goodbye, but rather takes a different course. Teaching responsibility and independence can hurt while it helps.</p>

<p>vandy, One day, when my girl & I look back, and together, surely laugh, I’ll fondly relate to her your “taking the scenic route” version…thank you for the giggle.</p>

<p>I, too, wish to say how much I love this thread! I appreciate the comments you each make about the struggles and successes of parenting and of our children. When I had my last two children “later in life” I was still several years ahead of the first batch going off to college and wondered just how I would manage it all. Now, as the second to last heads off this fall and it will be just the “little one” (read, entering her junior year) and me, I have a longer view of this process. I must say, however, that in years between the first group and these last two, much changed in the college admissions process and I found myself wholly unprepared for the level of competition, the impact of the economy, and other factors. TY for this little thread of sanity.</p>

<p>Just wanted to check in… S has decided to attend the University of Vermont. He will be joining S1 who is currently a junior at UVM. After all the college visits and 11 acceptances, it seems unbelievable that they will end up at the same school! While it’s not my first choice for S2, he is very excited, and so I am excited for him. Got my fingers crossed!</p>

<p>Many thanks to all of you for the great advice and insight along the way. I wish all of our kids a fabulous launch in August!</p>