Look at www.collegedata.com and you will see the mid range stats of freshmen for the various universities and it will give you a general idea of how you fit in. Is the 3.7 gpa UW or weighted? Do you have SAT or ACT test scores? No one on this forum will be mean to you if you volunteer your stats. It can only help us so that we can give you better guidance.
One piece of info you should pay attention to is the percentage of students that the smaller LAC’s take.through ED. Many colleges try to protect their yield and will reject students if they do not show interest etc. If you do not have a private counselor, I would suggest working with one. They can help you strategize and provide a consistent voice about the process.