Colleges your child crossed off the list after visiting, schools that moved up on the list. Why? (NO REPLIES)

Adding our recent Virginia tours. We are merit chasers from the West, and this is our second college application cycle, so we have already done a bunch of tours. This area was new to us. I will go from least favorite to favorite.

Washington and Lee - Went in with low expectations given how Greek the student body is, and our visit definitely confirmed those concerns. 70%-80% Greek. The vast majority of women we saw on campus were wearing their sorority insignia; the vibe was extremely Greek and extremely preppy, and really not our Ds scene at all. Our tour guide was quite good. She was a non-Greek-affiliated recruited field hockey player. She said it is possible to have a good social life on campus without being in the Greek system, but she mostly referenced “being able to go to the Greek events even if you aren’t a member” vs. “there is a robust social life completely outside of Greek life”. It is a small school (1800), and it definitely felt small. The info session was good. It is in the Blue Ridge Mountains, which has its own charms, but being from the Mountain West, we couldn’t convince our D that they were even mountains at all. lol. We have a very different sense of scale for calling something a mountain vs. a hill.

The campus itself is nice, but nothing spectacular. The academic area was quite compact, all matchy-matchy red brick. Jeffersonian design is clear. A lot of huge white columns. Some probably love that, just not our vibe, and we found that there was too much of it in too small a space. Having visited it the day after the gorgeous University of Richmond campus definitely didn’t help matters. There is a small acknowledgment of the college’s specific ties to slavery (the college itself owned slaves). I know it is a difficult historical reality for schools in the South to grapple with and take ownership of, but I wasn’t particularly impressed with their commitment to the issue; it didn’t feel full-throated, and maybe wasn’t, given that Lee is obviously a major factor in the school’s past. Lexington is very cute, and the school abuts the town, so it is extremely easy to get into town. The Virginia Military Institute also abuts the campus, and it is a unique experience to see all the military kids in their camo or all white in orderly groups streaming to the different (all beige and militaristic looking) buildings.

The full-ride Johnson Scholarship, given to 10% of the incoming class, is an amazing opportunity, but she will not be applying. Off the list.

University of Richmond - Probably the nicest campus we have ever visited. Solidly near the top of our top five in terms of the beauty of the campus itself (the others being St. Olaf, University of San Diego (beautiful campus, but student body very much not her type), University of Arizona, Santa Clara). Pristine grounds, beautiful buildings. Although all were matching red(ish) brick, there was enough variety in the buildings themselves, and new vs. old, to make the campus look interesting. The dining hall is really nice (St Olaf beats it for design of the space itself, and maybe University of San Diego for the food, but it is one of the best we have experienced). The student commons spans the lake on campus and has floor-to-ceiling windows and a balcony overlooking the lake. Truly spectacular. Diversity was decent. Academics seemed very solid, size is great (3200). The city of Richmond itself is very cool. We stayed in “The Fan” neighborhood and really loved it. Cute shops, good restaurants, fun area to visit. The campus itself is a bit secluded from the city, though, off in its own swanky area, so I imagine it is only on occasion that students spend significant amounts of time in the city.

The only downside was the vibe of the student body. While not as preppy and certainly not as Greek as Washington and Lee, it was still way more so than D’s preference. I think it would be possible to find her people there, but it would definitely be a minority of the student body. She was very impressed with the academics, and the campus and the available PPEL and Leadership majors. Not sure if it will make the final list though due to the student body.

William and Mary: Definitely our favorite college visit of this trip. Campus was lovely. Not in the pristine, manicured manner of the University of Richmond, but historical, stately, warm, inviting, green, with big trees, etc. Felt like a quieter, smaller UNC-CH. The academics felt very aligned with our daughter’s interests, and the student body seemed much more her style than any school we have visited in the East / Southeast. (which, to be fair, only includes these three plus UNC and a brief stroll through Georgetown). Have read a lot of negative reviews of the food and the dorms. It appears they are working on improving both - replacing or updating all dorms and building a new (really nice!) dining hall. Because of that, there was quite a bit of construction on campus, but even with that, my D loved it. I read someone describe it as “Colonial Hogwarts for Ravenclaws”, and it is a pretty good description.

Smart, engaged, interesting, well-rounded students; “East coast” feeling but not overly preppy or Greek. Seems it is a lot of Northern Virginians. Williamsburg itself is kind of an odd aspect of campus life. Campus is right next to the start of Colonial Williamsburg, so there really isn’t a college town / strip of college-oriented shops, restaurants, etc. It is campus, then a cool but not college-focused massive tourist area and then outside of that just regular suburb stuff (strip malls, etc.) There didn’t seem to be anywhere cool for students to hang out off campus. (If someone knows where students hang out, please add to the “off-topic” thread - we are genuinely curious). She will definitely be applying. Older D received the Monroe scholarship, but it was still expensive. If D27 gets lucky enough to receive the 1693 Scholarship it would be her top choice right now (along with St Olaf).

[Adding: I forgot to mention we did notice a lot of kids sitting / eating /studying alone at William and Mary. Maybe a more introverted student body, or maybe it was the culture itself? Not sure. Worth nothing and doing a bit more research into. Also adding: if a student wants to work in D.C. or politics or the East Coast generally, W&M seems amazing - the alum network, specifically for politics, is truly incredible. Our D doesn’t want that though, and likely will live somewhere West of the Mississippi where W&M isn’t well known and doesn’t have much of a network.]

18 Likes