Current students: What classes are you taking and how do you like them so far?

<p>Elanorci, thank you so much for being so detailed in your responses! <3</p>

<p>@ Interficio</p>

<p>That one is dead.</p>

<p>No problem! :slight_smile: let me know if you have any other questions.
(Yeah, being dead usually is a good reason for professors to stop teaching…)
Interficio, this one is the ‘Seven Sins of Memory’ guy.</p>

<p>Though with some professors, it seems as though that might not stop them…</p>

<p>School ended over two months ago, but so long as I’m on this message board I’ll write about my courses from the Spring 2011 term. I took Life Sciences 1b (introductory genetics and evolution), Physical Sciences 1 (introductory inorganic chemistry), Expository Writing 20, and intermediate-level Spanish. </p>

<p>Life Sciences 1b was the most asinine and pathetic class I have ever taken. My teaching fellow (individual who directs weekly laboratory and discussion section) was absolutely useless. His English was on par with a language from another planet and such tiresome absurdity quickly turned that portion of my schedule into an utter waste of time. The lecture instruction was also uniformly horrendous and neither professor seemed to have the interest or pedagogical aptitude to teach effectively. Both head preceptors, who dealt with course logistics and held some teaching responsibilities, were also atrocious. One could obtain more effective teaching performances from a troupe of fourth-graders. Save for perhaps a few teaching fellows I never met, the entire teaching staff should be fired. </p>

<p>The textbook to the class was also the worst course reference I have ever seen in my life. Unsurprisingly it was co-written by Dan Hartl, who instructed one half of that debacle. The final exam was frequently not reflective of the material taught over the course of the term and/or did not properly accord with problem-solving expectations. Perhaps it was partly a manifestation of judgment errors on part of the teaching staff, but I’d wager that it mostly a reprisal on the class for a Facebook cheating incident, which, all in all, was a misdeed of just a select fraction of individuals. In the end, it was a rather underhanded endeavor to deflate the course grades and was easily the most asinine academic test I’ve ever taken. </p>

<p>Physical Science 1 was also about as useful as a load of bovine defecation. Both instructors and one fill-in were absolutely dismal, though arguably less so than the lot above, but that’s not dispensing anything positive. My laboratory teaching fellow also didn’t provide the expected common service of speaking intelligible English, so I never bothered seeking his assistance. And similar to Life Sciences 1b, there was a ludicrous amount of discord between the instruction, homework, and exams. Neither of the former two were sufficient or even passable preparation for the latter. One quarter of the second test (a single extended problem-solving exercise) was professionally disqualifying to the entire course administration and likely gave half the class the visceral impulse to tear the entire thing in half. Grades on the test were understandably very low, though not due to modest preparations on part of the students. The third and fourth (final) exams were more adequate parallels to the material than the first two and for that reason, I’d elevate my opinion of this class above LS1b, though its substantial shortcomings are embarrassingly and absurdly unacceptable. </p>

<p>Test grading was also a nightmare, in my case. Of the five tests that were provided over the course of the term, there were substantial grading errors on all but one, in which my grade was inaccurately reduced by 5% (or more) of the exam’s value. The graders were often too careless to recognize error propagation and would mark an entire multi-part question wrong despite the problem-solving being accurate and correct on all subsequent portions. I frequently submitted regrades, but anything properly accounted for by the new grader would often be countered with other grading faults, oversights or general recklessness, such as failing to credit anything that falls outside the standard problem-solving methodology or near word-by-word justifications present in the grading key, despite still factually and accurately deriving (or stating) the same answer. </p>

<p>None of what was provided in those courses should be even remotely excusable for supposedly the world’s finest university. I understand that LS1b (supposedly) made a concerted effort to improve over last year’s class after the dreadful course evaluations. Yet it’s clear from this year’s horror that course administration has absolutely no concept on how to repair such a feeble part of the biology curriculum. And sadly with the staff and course blueprints as they are, it’s difficult to see any parts that would be immediately and wholly remediable. </p>

<p>Also, to add insult to injury, one of my grades came back a full letter mark lower than what it should have been after I inquired about my final exam score and aggregated the semester’s results in accordance with weighted averages (my other grade was two notches lower than calculated/expected). Deriving my final grade by hand was a slightly fuzzier process for LS1b due to the use of a grading curve, which remained a total mystery. Each time I asked a course official about what the grading curve entailed, I received lousy and uninformative answers about whatever methodology/numerical breakdown was employed. In the end, I wouldn’t be surprised if my grade was bungled somewhere along the way in at least one of the two. Errors of grade reporting and calculation inevitably do occur, but the lack of an online grading portal doesn’t permit any student supervision to ensure proper grade transcription.</p>

<p>I also enrolled in a science-themed writing course, given that’s where my academic interests lie. My instructor was blatantly elitist and, quite unfortunately, ideologically opposed to allocating A-range grades. I earned a B+ on each of the three papers and completed all the assignments in between, which, to my understanding, were to be awarded full credit based on on-time, quality completion. (Many were also ludicrously irrelevant relative to what the class was doing.) Yet, I was given a B in the class, despite never missing an assignment, maintaining proper attendance, and never earning any grade at or below B for the entire progression of the course. </p>

<p>On top of that, I also took a college composition course (of supremely greater quality) in my final year of high school, so I honestly cannot say I learned a single tidbit about university essay/writing expectations, which is regrettable given the expectations one should expect out of an instructor so overweening in her grading conventions. And based on examples of her own work, her rhetorical competencies wouldn’t have landed her much of a quality mark either. </p>

<p>I thought my Spanish course was poorly taught, as well, and there was little continuity. As a result, I couldn’t stand it, but I will commend the instructor for dispensing the proper grade, which isn’t something I can credit to the others. </p>

<p>In the eight classes I took at this university, I honestly cannot say I would rate a single class as even mediocre in quality. I’ve attended several schools in my life and, by a clear mile, I have never experienced such thoroughly pathetic educational quality or a ceaseless array of academic screw-overs in my entire life. Instead of wringing my hands over what the circus will bring in years two, three, and four, I’ll consider it a lost year and start anew elsewhere. I’ve lost my rapport with this university and I’m never setting foot there again.</p>

<p>@Mifune, where are you transferring to? </p>

<p>For other people reading that post, I’d like to point out that he (or she?) took a straight load of the worst courses in the university, after which the courses get considerably better. Some Exposes are quite good, as mine was. PS1 and LS1a are weed-out classes. And lower-level Spanish doesn’t have a reputation for being particularly well-taught. I’m not arguing with Mifune’s decision to transfer; at a certain point of anger and frustration, it’s probably the right decision. But the most of our university is not like that. In fact, I think that any other four courses in the university would be a better set of four. (And I’m assuming that fall semester, they took LS1a, which is also not good.) The administration seems also to have responded to the LS1b debacle at least a little bit; I’m very out of the pre-med loop, but I heard several friends cursing their decision to take the course this year when the new (apparently better) teaching staff was announced.</p>

<p>^Just want to add that what I’ve heard from several faculty members supports this – the departments certainly feel they’re improving the quality of teaching in LS1b by recruiting the professors they’ve tapped to teach it next year.</p>

<p>Wow, mifune, I feel so bad that you had that awful experience. My son just graduated, and he loved almost every course that he took, but he was not on a pre-med track (he was a physics major). His expos class was great (he had lunch with the instructor once a year after freshman year), his freshman seminar on Leonard Bernstein was exquisite, and he had great research opportunities from sophomore year onward. </p>

<p>I’ve also heard miserable things about the Life Sciences courses, so I hope that they do clean up that mess. Good luck to you wherever you end up.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I don’t know whether you were trying to be intentionally funny, but your description of LS1b made me smile :). Hopefully the new professors will do a better job with the course next year. </p>

<p>I’m glad to see you back posting though. Do keep in touch, and all the best to you whereas you’ll be.</p>

<p>Facebook cheating incident? Funny to see how meticulous the admissions committee is in choosing the cream of the crop, in fields that include academic integrity, and still there are students referred to the administrative board for plagiarism and collusion…</p>

<p>@erstaunen: Half of the problem was that they didn’t, apparently, make it super clear when collaboration was allowed and when it wasn’t. My friends said nobody stopped or discouraged them from talking during in-class quizzes, so they assumed they were collaborative. Then the teaching staff went berserk that people were on Facebook talking about it as a larger segment of the class, rather than just a few people sitting near each other. In this case, it seemed to be a mismatch of expectations for behavior resulting from poor communication, rather than any willful or even witting rule-breaking. I’m not saying the teaching staff’s expectations were wrong, just that they don’t seem to have been clear about them.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I don’t know, but I’m spending the majority of the next school year in Europe, and will likely attend university there, then transfer back to the U.S. thereafter. However, if I do continue on next year it will be merely the spring term, as virtually all fall-term deadlines have passed. I still hope to graduate by 2014, even though I’m excluding Harvard from my academic record since nearly half my grades weren’t very genuine indicators of my academic progress. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>The funny thing is that I actually became so inured to the atrociousness of LS1b and PS1 that I nearly tricked myself into believing that LS1a was somewhat good in retrospect. In reality, before last semester, LS1a was the most hideous load of rubbish I had ever encountered. In the initial softening up process, the class was quite fair and pleasantly challenging, but it teetered into a clear nosedive in the latter portions. I also had a grading dispute that was never resolved in that class and if such transpired again (which it did – twice, and potentially three times – the next term), I vowed never to return.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Without much exaggeration, I could gather a group of capable second-graders and be more impressed with their proficiencies in conceptual instruction. In fact, unlike two of my teaching fellows, I would be delighted that they speak a language that’s actually been heard on Earth before.</p>

<p>Good luck! I admire how funny you are about it (“language that’s actually been heard on Earth before”: nearly lol’d), and hope it all works out.</p>

<p>Anyone want to update this thread with fall classes from this year?
(Also, to add to the pile of ls1b bashing: I went to look at my final exam from the spring to find that they’d forgotten to grade an ENTIRE question. The points that had been lost from their error resulted in my grade going up. I submitted this request in OCTOBER, and the grade is still not changed on my transcript, despite three or four emails and their consistent reassurance that they’re just getting to it. So dumb.)</p>

<p>I’m a freshman. This fall, I took Life Sciences 1a, Economics 1011a, Math 23a, and Japanese Ba. I’ll tackle these one-by-one:</p>

<p>Life Science 1a.</p>

<p>This was a great one. It is, essentially, a chemical approach to introductory microbiology. I loved the material, I loved that there was no required textbook, I loved the tests, I loved the homework. The course designers did not assume I was an idiot, which is a great change from most classes I’d taken. The material was assigned, you read it when you wished, and you were accountable for knowing it well– however, the tests were not regurgitating competitions. Your understanding of the material was taken for granted. Most of the questions on the tests, although not all, asked for inferences that were completely reasonable given the course notes, but which still required thought. Some of these involved arriving independently at real scientific breakthroughs and medical mechanisms. I learned more about biology and organic chemistry in this semester than I learned in Bio Honors, Bio AP, Chem Honors, and Chem AP combined, and the material was totally different in focus and scope– a background similar to mine is definitely unnecessary. Many people take this class because it’s a premed requirement, and then they complain about it. They probably should not be doctors. Some complain that the tests are hard: when they say this, what they mean is that they could find no place to fit the paragraphs of information they’d memorized without thinking. Others take this class as their only PSet class, and they complain about the length of the assignments. This is as close to a joke as I’ve heard. The course, excluding in-course time, took about two or three hours a week. True, I’d say I was in the lower quintile of time spent, but I bet not being on facebook during lectures probably helped, and a reasonable expectation for someone with no background is about… say, four hours a week max, excluding about four to six hours to review for each of the two midterms and the final.</p>

<p>Economics 1011a. </p>

<p>This is the honors/mathematical intermediate microeconomics course. Because of a class I’m about to mention, I could not spend as much time as I wanted with the material, but there’s a lot to be had. Be warned: it is essentially a weeder class for Wall Street people, and the quantitative approach taken often obfuscates and confuses rather than enlightening. If you plan on going into economics, and have any background at all in economics (an understanding of multivariate calculus, especially constrained optimization, removes any need for an economics background), skip Ec 10 and go to this course. It is what real economists do, and exposure to it will help make more firm any doubts or hopes you have about your future in economics. The professor has a spiffy manner of dress, and an entertaining acerbic wit. More importantly, he knows the material like the back of his hand, and several sections of the course involve concepts and arguments he originated or clarified. Most importantly, he’s a good teacher. </p>

<p>Mathematics 23a.</p>

<p>If you like mathematics at all– if you have any respect for the most elegant science– I strongly recommend AVOIDING THIS CLASS. This class was hard to manage and keep straight in my head. I’ve always been rather scatterbrained, and a ridiculously long syllabus with internal contradictions, pages of hoops to jump through, and unbelievably complicated grading formulae were no help in that regard. The manner of teaching was completely incompatible with me. Imagine the following lesson taking place in a preschool, and you’ll see what I mean:</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Apply that teaching methodology to linear algebra and you have the idea. I thought the book would clear things up, but it is about as useful as the “Random Article” button on wikipedia. Ugh… I’m done talking about this junky class. Take 21 or 25 if you want to use math or expand it. And if you have the background for 55, take it! I looked over some problems a friend of mine was working on for that class, and THAT is what math should look like. Anyways…</p>

<p>Japanese Ba.</p>

<p>Spectacularly designed, well-taught, fairly graded, full of fun people… Most of my better friends, I made in that class. Unfortunately, one of these is graduating from the law school this year, so he won’t be sticking around. My personal view is that Japanese is the most beautiful language I’ve heard. I can’t stand Romance languages or other Asian languages, and the only Germanic language I like to listen to is English– incidentally, English tends to be the most economic in expressing meaning, perhaps because of its expansive vocabulary. We’re lucky. But I should be reviewing this class insofar as it is well-taught, not insofar as its subject entertains me. It is well-taught, 'nuff said.</p>

<p>Yo thanks for reviving this thing! I’ve neglected putting my classes since they’re getting so obscure that I’m sure no one cares about them.</p>

<p>I may be interested. Any good ones I should look forward to?</p>

<p>Hmm I’m an scea admit and H is my first choice. Currently I’m struggling in Calc BC, but still want to do multivariable Calc/linear alg in college. Is math 21 for me? Would this still be too challenging for someone who is having issues with Calc BC (first time I’ve ever had issues with math, class is EXTREMELY fast paced, we’re already done with the AP syllabus.)</p>

<p>Sent from my LG-P509 using CC</p>

<p>You will take a math placement test that will recommend the best course for you. Math 21 assumes comfort with Calc BC so if you’re feeling shaky on it, I would recommend taking 1b. But, again, you’ll take a placement test later and you’ll have the opportunity to chat with some of the Math instructors in your first few days at Harvard.</p>

<p>Math 21 seems like it would be a good fit for you, Interficio.</p>