Dancer for years and physics wiz...university suggestions

Regarding #31 & #32, @momofsmartdancer and @homerdog yes,… it is about plan B. As a parent I can’t overlook the reality of the ballet world,…numbers taken into programs, numbers that climb the ranks,… she has declined some offerings as to , at the minimum, finish HS at home.

I appreciate everyone’s various perspectives,…as this conversion has moved several directions.

Has anyone know or had experience with preparing for plan B at s strong science based school while maneuvering through auditions,…even maybe college deferring for a year?

@USdncrUSSRsoul No, my daughter did not consider deferring. I think as she got older (15/16), she thought it was less likely that she could get a trainee position with a company. She is a lovely, well-trained dancer, but probably not in the top 1%. Also, she was burned out and ready to lead a more “normal” life.
But I did want to mention to you that one of the girls at our studio who did recently go pro (she is now with Joffrey’s studio company), was also a great student and had been accepted to Northwestern. When she got a trainee offer from Joffrey she was able to defer Northwestern.
I think it is smart to work both angles – apply to college but also do auditions for trainee positions – then your daughter can consider all of her options.

@USdncrUSSRsoul I think the state flagship universities are a great plan B. If your state has a decent system at all, they are traditionally strong in STEM and have a simpler application path than the elite private schools. It should be easier to balance applying to a strong state flagship with the audition process.

Ask yourself, how truly competitive is your daughter in the dance world? Is she getting coveted, funded summer intensive spots with top ballet companies? Does she stand out at her current program? How much attention is she getting outside of her program? If the answers are in the affirmative and she truly has the desire to pursue going pro, I too would suggest she pursue both simultaneously. She can always defer college acceptances for a year - and sometimes two years.

@doschicos Two years? Wow. Never imagined that would be possible. Yet taking into account an admissions perspective, would that send a crazy message? How would you even go about discussing this without offending them? And who would you want to discuss this with,…regional admissions or someone in the admissions department? Simultaneously is probably the route. more food for thought-thank you thank you!!

You don’t discuss it ahead of time. You get accepted and then you discuss a gap year which is pretty common these days for a year. You can’t assume two but it’s not unheard of either.

@USdncrUSSRsoul
One thing to consider when deferring is scholarship $. I don’t think that I found that any of the tuition+ scholarship offers that my daughter received would allow a student to defer and use the scholarship the following year. She decided to maximize scholarship opportunities so that we can save her college fund for med school rather than choosing a highly selective school that would not give much in the way of scholarship money.

“Has anyone know or had experience with preparing for plan B at s strong science based school while maneuvering through auditions,…even maybe college deferring for a year?”

We had success in getting colleges to defer merit aid but don’t assume it is doable everywhere.

@USdncrUSSRsoul

Your prior comment (below) left me somewhat confused. Is she looking into Biomedical Engineering or Physics?

We researched the engineering field for my daughter. That was a couple of years ago- so I forget some of the specific info. The general idea I got was that people did not really think that going into Biomedical Engineering as an undergraduate was a good idea. I think it was explained that they get a little bit of bio and a little bit of chemistry, but not enough of either to make them competitive in the job market. My husband is an engineer- so I also got some input from him. If she is determined to go the engineering route, mechanical engineering pays the best. My husband is in Materials Science and works for a fortune 500 company. From what I have read, some people find that to be a more interesting field in engineering than mechanical. They are always looking for qualified female engineers where he works. They do hire and promote qualified women at the highest levels where he works.

I also learned that the coursework for various types of engineering degrees is pretty standardized. All of the programs that are “certified” have comparable course offerings and coursework. Unless you go to one of the top ten programs for engineering, I don’t think companies care where you get your degree other than whether or not it is a certified program. And, about 4 years after graduation, companies care much more about your results; where you got your degree does not have much impact on your employment opportunities.

Also, probably the most important thing to consider if she wants to do both: engineering is one of the most time-consuming degrees there is. Not only is the coursework very difficult, but they actually require significantly more credit hours to graduate than other majors. Most engineering majors do not have great social lives while in college since they have to spend some of their weekends studying. I think it would be very difficult (if not impossible) to combine an engineering major with many hours spent dancing.

Your daughter might want to consider a degree through the department of natural sciences. I found out that it is not difficult to get a 2nd degree in engineering or masters degree and make-up some of the missing engineering coursework for someone that has a degree in physics or chemistry. That is my daughter’s back-up plan if she changes her mind about med school. One of her favorite subjects is chemistry, so she is considering chemical engineering.

“she is looking at Biochemical Engineering. She has been offered an internship this summer, which is working around her SI commitment-she is determined to do both. I am reading and thinking that the ballet department and physics department needs to be strong and location is very important.”

@momofsmartdancer Yes, I would say she is probably guessing too early as to where she can apply her academic strengths. I believe this is still a genuine hurdle for most high school students as well as many undergraduates-declaring a major and figuring out a job related direction. Not a lot has changed there since my time in college. And for that, she is looking at a summer internship to truly “understand” the engineering possibilities.

Her strengths are Physics, Chemistry and Math. She has visited many sites on her own to match her strengths with careers-interesting results to say the least. She realizes the commitment to those areas but I’m seeing she isn’t ready to give up ballet. The need to know is strong. The path traditionally becomes divided at very early stages for dancer, as you know. She is very aware that even if she danced professionally, her time is limited-they “retire” young. She is determined to forge a new path and Im trying to assist navigating those unusual approaches.

Deferring maybe a route, but the post @doschicos mentions a good point,…deferring and the impact on scholarships. New thought (thank you and this is why I love this site, so many eyes viewing from different angles)! …“a brain is a terrible thing to waste.” With that said, I respect her passion for ballet and must support her dream to reach for both.

@momofsmartdancer Yes, I would say she is probably guessing too early as to where she can apply her academic strengths. I believe this is still a genuine hurdle for most high school students as well as many undergraduates-declaring a major and figuring out a job related direction. Not a lot has changed there since my time in college. And for that, she is looking at a summer internship to truly “understand” the engineering possibilities.

Her strengths are Physics, Chemistry and Math. She has visited many sites on her own to match her strengths with careers-interesting results to say the least. She realizes the commitment to those areas but I’m seeing she isn’t ready to give up ballet. The need to know is strong. The path traditionally becomes divided at very early stages for dancer, as you know. She is very aware that even if she danced professionally, her time is limited-they “retire” young. She is determined to forge a new path and Im trying to assist navigating those unusual approaches.

Deferring maybe a route, but a good point,…deferring and the impact on scholarships. New thought (thank you and this is why I love this site, so many eyes viewing from different angles)! With that said, I respect her passion for ballet and must support her dream to reach for both.

My daughter was never interested in pursuing a dance career professionally, but she attended a pre-professional ballet studio and then an arts magnet high school as dance major, so there were classmates and studio-mates who did pursue dance careers, either by directly apprenticing to or joining dance companies or by going through BFA programs.

When my daughter was at Barnard, I know she had at least one classmate who danced professionally with a ballet company before coming to Barnard — I don’t know whether that was someone who deferred admission or simply applied later.

If my daughter had wanted to dance ballet professionally, then I would have encouraged her to apprentice directly to a company. Ballet is for the young – I think a young woman who goes for a BFA is setting herself up to miss critical years for her career. My daughter’s friends who got BFA’s were modern dancers, not ballerinas.

Are you talking about the college application process? (senior year of high school). There are no special requirements to get into a school with strong STEM offerings, other than GPA, test scores, etc. So she could just submit applications as appropriate – but nothing sould interfer with or prevent her from auditioning to dance programs in the same time frame.

Simultaneously applying to dance and STEM options is pretty easy. I thought you were talking about trying to dance and study STEM at the same time, which is considerably harder to pull off.

@calmom This is about the college process.

@aroundhere I’m not sure if she can determine at this time whether dancing and studying at the college level can happen. it appears from everyone’s input, the best route is to do both at the same time. See where acceptances at the college level happen and where auditions results come in from.

If your daughter is a strong enough student, Columbia SEAS may be one school to consider applying to.
It has applied physics and biomedical engineering departments, among others. The engineering schools I’m familiar with are relatively light on female applicants, so qualified female applicants may have a somewhat easier admit %.
Barnard’s dance offerings are available to Columbia students. And there are good dance schools around as well.

But NYC is expensive, and engineering programs are very academically demanding and time consuming.

This describes my D18 almost exactly (35 ACT, 4.0 GPA, etc and 15 years of dance, wants to dance professionally with a focus on ballet, but looking at college first).

We are now in the middle of the process so we’ll see what happens, but we decided to take a mixed approach, with some top ballet programs and some top academic schools and some that are slightly less prestigious but offer a reasonable combination of both. We ruled out some possibilities on grounds of cost (we will get minimal need-based aid in most cases), including NYU, Michigan, Barnard.

We put Indiana, Oklahoma and Utah in the top ballet programs, probably in that order (along with a lottery ticket at Julliard). The big advantage of the latter two is that they are nearly free for top students (Oklahoma for NMF and Utah for 4.0 GPA). Oklahoma was keen to tell us they have more National Merit scholars than any other school in the country and they are fine with dancers in the Honors College, dual majors, etc.

We put Berkeley, UCLA (and a lottery ticket at Princeton) in the top academic programs. These two should be plausible reach schools as we are in CA, they are also quite affordable with in-state tuition.

Then we put schools like Fordham, Butler, USC, Chapman and multiple other UCs in the combination bucket. All with decent merit for high academics (or in state tuition) and (in several cases) not quite as competitive for the dance programs.

So hopefully we will get to next April with some choices in two or three of these categories. And then we’ll see. The key thing to note is that ballet selectivity at many of these schools is comparable to Ivy league academic selectivity.

Lessons so far: this requires lots of work, lots of auditions, lots of videos for pre-screening. And a lot of cost for applications, travel to auditions etc. I would certainly advise doing a summer program at one of the top ballet programs to help with admissions there. And do as much as possible in terms of essays (and potentially even videos) over the summer.

Someone has recently put together a website that lists university dance programs by state. It looks very thorough. It is at smartdancer com.
When my daughter was looking at college dance options, we looked through the old posts under the “College Dance” section of the dancemom com website. I recall seeing that a lot of people felt that the ballet programs at many universities were weak compared to their home studio ballet. It seems that even those not wishing to focus on ballet performance still want a high level of ballet course offerings and also want to have a greater frequency of ballet classes/ week.
Many post about their experiences after visiting and auditioning at BFA programs. It might save you and your daughter some time to read through those to help narrow down options to suit her interests.

This is a very helpful chain of discussion. I have a son in the similar situation, 4.6 GPA and top 1% SAT science student , dreaming to pursue dance and physical therapy. He is classically trained, but not tall enough to have a good career in ballet so he is looking for schools that offers good contemporary training and strong academics. Not super talented but works hard. Boys do get much better opportunities in dance. He is applying for USC (first choice), Harvard, Princeton, Columbia, NYU Tisch, SUNY Purchase, Northwestern, Stanford and a couple of UC schools. He currently trains at an excellent classical (Russian) ballet studio in Southern Cal, so he is also considering going to Cal State to complete his GE requirements (probably takes him a year) while training at his current studio and then transfer or apply again if he is not happy with the outcome of his college choices this year.

I just visited USC with my daughter who is class of 2020 in high school, so only a sophomore, on their Discover USC day. She loves ballet but took a long break from doing it so she’s at a lower level and wouldn’t be considering a BFA or major in dance. However, she hopes to take classes wherever she does go to school and maybe even would minor. We attended a one hour and fifteen minute presentation at the Kaufman School of Dance, including a student panel. It was really impressive. This really seems to be a conservatory within USC - pretty cool for a serious dancer who also wants to be serious about academics. @SCMHAALUM you may have already visited Kaufman, and I see it’s his first choice so you/he obviously realize its value but in case others aren’t aware of it (I wasn’t - it’s only 5 years old and my daughter only started getting into dance again a few years ago so it wasn’t on my radar til recently) I thought I’d mention how great it seemed. There was one young man who’s in the school and he is also doing a pre-med track because he intends to try to dance professionally when he’s young and later become a surgeon! Ambitious - but I hope he can do it!

@USdncrUSSRsoul @Twoin18 Where did your daughters end up applying? @CAtransplant Yes my son visited USC Kaufman in his junior year and took classes at the open house. The facility and faculty are amazing and he saw what it takes to get into that program. He moved away from home last summer to attend Orange County School of Arts and also trained outside of school. I can’t say he is very talented but through efforts he got through pre-screening and auditioned last weekend. 600+ applicants and about 110 auditioned. They are taking 25 or so students. He also found out that they are starting this progressive program where you can start grad school before finishing bachelor’s so he is planning to go on with PT school if he gets in. A few kids turned down Juliard to attend Kaufman because of the academic opportunities at USC. We are keeping our fingers crossed. Good luck with auditions!