There are a lot of schools which punch above their weight for “elite” type hiring, or whatever that’s a proxy for, that are NOT bro-like. So if that’s a goal-- again, Tufts, Swarthmore, Brandeis, Holy Cross (a very underrated intellectual place IMHO) and back to McGill/Chicago.
Trust me- the “bro” environment is going to be a LOT more influential in your D’s overall college experience than whether the campus abuts, is adjacent to, is far from an urban environment. And for the very, very minimal odds of getting a McKinsey offer from Lehigh vs. Swarthmore… nah, not worth it! The everyday environment, how influential the drinking culture is, how many social and cultural opportunities there are, involvement in the community- these are a much more potent predictor of how much a kid loves their college than the machinations four years down the road of “how hard is it to submit my resume for a resume drop if I’m not at a core school?” (not hard). Most HS kids don’t know what consultants do all day, and once they realize that the second cut in recruiting is all about quant and analytical skills (numbers, so many numbers!) that’s it for consulting!