Denied at reach school (ND), help me pick school for me--Dayton, Marquette, Xavier, etc

You missed Miami even though you visited both Xavier and Dayton? You practically drove past it. :-?

Oh well, I suspect you are correct that Marquette is a better fit anyhow. I visited both Dayton and Miami on the same day. Strongly preferred Dayton; mainly because of the people. Miami is prettier, but also seemed impersonal.