<p>That study makes perfect sense. When we are fat, we have a lot of extra lean mass (including extra muscle) just to carry all that extra fat around. As we lose fat, we also lose that extra lean mass. But, if you then turn around and start packing on the fat again, without exercise, the initial weight gain will include no lean muscle.</p>
<p>There are studies that show exercise is critical to maintaining weight loss. There’s also some evidence that exercise prevents insulin resistance, which will be a big help in avoiding fat gain.</p>
<hr>
<p>New Rules of Lifting workout for me. Not a particularly strong workout, but I punched the clock. Now, I expect I’ll fall asleep early. These workouts are kicking my butt.</p>
<p>The other issue with the fat/lean mass equation is that most post-menopausal women are likely to lose weight with severely calorie restricted low-fat (and low protein) diets. That, combined with little or no resistance strength training, is a recipe for disaster when it comes to preserving muscle mass.</p>
<p>Congratulations on Day 2 of your new streak. I was worried that you might have been wrecking havoc at the Mall of America instead of working out! :)</p>
<p>And in more less-than-wonderful news, people who have lost weight appear to be able to tolerate about 300 calories less a day than do people who haven’t lost weight. (And this is in supervised eating studies, with people living at the study center and being exhaustively measured.)
<a href=“The Fat Trap - The New York Times”>The Fat Trap - The New York Times;
That’s a great article and I like the balance in it. It mentions that researchers use a fast weight loss approach (which usually means starvation diets) and that maybe this isn’t the best way to do research on this topic so at least a few are doing longer-term research with slow weight-loss. Obviously doing the longer-term stuff is more of a problem with funding and resources.
I thought it interesting that those known to be successful do the equivalent of 28 miles a week walking.
<p>According to MyPlate, assuming three shakes and two cups of green beans each day, that’s: </p>
<p>530 calories
15% fat
33% protein
51% carbohydrate</p>
<p>You’ll lose weight fast on a 530 calorie starvation diet, but what a horrible way to do it. They lost an average of 3 pounds a week for 10 weeks. I was losing 2 pounds a week for the first 10 weeks, eating 1800 to 2000 calories a day and drinking half and half in my cofffee. I don’t think 3 pounds a week is all that fantastic considering the extreme starvation of living on 530 calories a day.</p>
<p>The diet is also pretty low in protein (44 grams per day). That’s adequate for health (below the recommended daily allowance), but pretty low if you are looking to build or maintain lean muscle mass. I shoot for moderate protein intake of at least 1/2 gram per pound of body weight per day. The athletic crowd would be pushing for closer to 3/4 or 1 gram per pound to build muscle. It’s vital during weight loss to keep protein consumption up (and exercise) to preserve lean muscle mass.</p>
<p>I’m not surprised that a diet program like that produces only temporary results. I have become convinced that the most effective approach to losing weight is to look at making permanent, long-term changes in the way you eat. That means looking at your diet and trying to triage the damage and just get rid of one or two worst offenders. Like cut the soda and juice (permanently) and then decide where to go from there. This means that a diet is eating more or less normally as you progressively modify and cut the prime offenders (Ok, I can live without sour gummi worms and Doritos, because I still have pork chops and cream in my coffee…) That’s the opposite approach from a 500 calorie a day starvation diet.</p>
<p>This paragraph in the NYTMES article caught my eye:</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>In the same way as the standard low-fat/low protein starvation diet recommendations may work against dieters, this paragraph suggests that the standard dieter exercise (treadmill, execise bikes, cardio, cardio, cardio) may work against them too.</p>
<p>Slow twitch muscle fibers are what you build doing marathon training, hours on the treadmill, long walks, etc. These muscles are optimized to go for along time burning minimum fuel and oxygen.</p>
<p>Fast twitch muscle fibers are what you build doing explosive short-term exercise like sprinting or jumping or weight lifting. By, definition, these muscles can’t go for long periods of time. They burn massive amounts of fuel and oxygen in a short burst and it is impossible to continue supplying them for more than a minute or two or three. When the fuel/oxygen is used up, the burn sets in.</p>
<p>If research shows that fast twitch muscle exercise burns more total calories during weight maintenance, then this would support Alwyn Cosgrove’s emphasis on strength training and high intensity intervals in his [Hierarchy</a> of Fat Loss](<a href=“AlwynCosgrove.com”>AlwynCosgrove.com).</p>
<p>I’ve seen other research that suggests buidling fast twitch muscle reduces insulin resistance, which is obviously beneficial in preventing fat storage.</p>
<p>So, if you want to keep the weight off, eat your protein and include some resistance strength training and explosive high intensity intervals in your exercise schedule.</p>
I don’t think that having a combination of slow twitch and fast twitch muscles would be bad though as there are things that you do that require efficiency and things that require explosive power.
The cardio stuff as a recommendation may be easier for most people to do, at least those coming from a sedentary state. If they get to higher levels, then it should work for them as long as they maintain it. The organization that tracks those that have lost at least 30 pounds for a year indicate the equivalent of 28 miles/week walking. I have no doubt that there are a lot of people in that group that are doing mostly cardio to maintain the weight loss.
The shake weight-loss seems to be the standard approach in diet research - kind of like using a certain kind of lab rat.
<p>Paging Interesteddad – can you share some of your healthy delicious dutch oven recipes? Santa brought me one this year and I’m stumped by it.</p>
<p>Walk/ran with the neighborhood jockettes three mornings straight and passed this morning. I just ache too much afterwards. I think there’s a sweet spot of just the right level of rigor to the exercise and I don’t think I can do what they do on a steady basis.</p>
<p>On dutch ovens, I love that I can use a single pot to brown the meat, brown the veggies, and then slow cook the whole thing in the oven. A pot roast illustrates this. Here’s the Marcela Hazan pot roast with red wine that I make:</p>
<p>Note that nothing in this recipe requires any precision. I use a whole can of tomatoes, because, once I open a can to get a 1/4 cup, it’s easier to just throw the whole can in. Because I use extra tomato, I often don’t need the extra stock/water. I also use a lot more veggies – carrots, onions, peppers, and celery than the recipe calls for. You could also add potato. Sometimes I add more big chunks of veggies with one hour to go and serve those as the side dish. Sometimes, I stir in a few tablespoons of white flour into the fat from the browned meat, to make a little roux and thicken the sauce for the pot roast a bit. Just depend on my mood.</p>
<p>Once I’m done browning everything on the stovetop, I put the cover on the dutch oven and throw it in the oven, turning the meat every 45 minutes or so. The leftover juice/veggies when the pot roast is gone can be mixed with a can or two of Progresso vegetable or vegetable/beef soup for a fantastic quasi-homemade soup.</p>
<p>On running with the neighbors. I think you are smart to listen to your body and back off. For one thing, it is a really good idea, in geezer fitness, to not try to do the same exercise activity two days in a row. If you are going to run one day, then lift weights, or do yoga, or swim, or do core exercises or bike or whatever the next day. That gives the muscles some recovery time and will help prevent over-use injuries.</p>
<p>From sad experience, even walking a few miles every day causes (or exacerbates) achilles tendinitis and P.F… . walking every other day seems to be my limit.</p>
It’s nice to be able to do 6 miles again. I haven’t been here in a long time though this time I’m doing it a lot faster than before.
The Capilene 3 arrived - the material is different from what I bought 25 years ago. It’s lighter and thinner. The old stuff was a very tight weave and wore like iron - we’ll see if the new stuff stands up as well. It will be interesting to see if it is as warm as the old stuff - if it is, then I’ll be impressed with what they can do with technology. If not, then I might pick up some Capilene 4.
<p>That’s a good study - basically showing that interval training can have remarkable results. It seems like a lot of trainers know this and that the scientific research community is playing catchup. What should follow is long-term studies (do they keep up the exercise routine after losing the weight). It’s good to see that they will be expanding the study to specific groups with obesity problems.</p>
<p>Skeletal muscle is further divided into several subtypes:</p>
<pre><code>Type I, slow oxidative, slow twitch, or “red” muscle is dense with capillaries and is rich in mitochondria and myoglobin, giving the muscle tissue its characteristic red color. It can carry more oxygen and sustain aerobic activity.
Type I muscle fiber are sometimes broken down into Type I and Type Ic categories, as a result of recent research.[4]
Type II, fast twitch muscle, has three major kinds that are, in order of increasing contractile speed:[5]
Type IIa, which, like slow muscle, is aerobic, rich in mitochondria and capillaries and appears red.
Type IIx (also known as type IId), which is less dense in mitochondria and myoglobin. This is the fastest muscle type in humans. It can contract more quickly and with a greater amount of force than oxidative muscle, but can sustain only short, anaerobic bursts of activity before muscle contraction becomes painful (often incorrectly attributed to a build-up of lactic acid). N.B. in some books and articles this muscle in humans was, confusingly, called type IIB.[6]
Type IIb, which is anaerobic, glycolytic, “white” muscle that is even less dense in mitochondria and myoglobin. In small animals like rodents this is the major fast muscle type, explaining the pale color of their flesh.
</code></pre>
<p>-- Wikipedia</p>
<p>I recall reading about this stuff first in my son’s AP Bio textbook.</p>
<p>Thanks, idad. I just needed a simple starting point for using this thing. And who doesn’t love a great pot roast?</p>
<p>Yes, I think the key for this era of life is variety and knowing limits. There’s a salt water lap pool at our fitness center. My New Year’s resolution is to start using it more. Also work more with weights. Just love my morning running pals but they are about 10 years younger and former hs/college athletes. I’m thinking once or twice per week, not daily.</p>
<p>My DH has lost about six pounds and is feeling and looking better. But he is having trouble with lower back pain. I think he overdoes the treadmill – every day, 45 minutes or so, just too much repetitive movement, imo. </p>
<p>This time of life is also about looking out for your aging partner, I’m finding. If he feels bad, I feel bad. And vice versa.</p>