<p>That study that BC linked from Wall Street Journal yesterday is online at the JAMA site:</p>
<p><a href=“http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/307/1/47.full.pdf[/url]”>http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/307/1/47.full.pdf</a></p>
<p>The study is a lot more interesting than the stupid conclusion that is going to appear in the media (eating low protein slows weight gain).</p>
<p>They took a group of subjects and stuck them in a highly controlled metabolic lab where they could prepare their meals (sending exact duplicates to a lab for calorie testing), measure their body fat using scans, and measure their energy expenditures.</p>
<p>First they put them on a fixed diet for a couple of weeks to determine a weight steady energy in/energy out baseline. This baseline diet was the standard recommended ultra-high carb diet:</p>
<p>15% protein
25% fat
60% carb</p>
<p>On average, this diet provided about 85 to 90 grams of protein a day.</p>
<p>After determining how many calories each person needed on this diet to be weight stable (about 2500), they increased the calories by 40% (about 1000 calories a day) by increasing either fat or protein, while leaving carbs fixed at the same amount.</p>
<p>So, now they were all eating 40% more calories, all eating the same carbohydrates (now about 42% of the new calorie total), but the protein varied in three groups:</p>
<p>Low Protein (5%): now eating 46 grams protein per day
Normal Protein (15%): now eating 140 grams protein per day
High Protein (25%): now eating 228 grams protein per day</p>
<p>What’s interesting is that all three groups gained nearly the same amount of body fat. But, the normal and high protein groups also gained a similar amount of lean body mass. Thus, they got bigger when they ate more, but their body fat percentage changed relatively little. The low protein group actually lost lean body mass while gaining fat. The scale didn’t go up as much, but their percentage of body fat increased more significantly. In my opinion, gaining fat while losing lean body mass is the worst of all worlds from a fitness standpoint.</p>
<p>And this study shows why. They did not allow the participants to exercise while over-feeding them, but they did measure their resting energy expenditures and their overall energy expenditures. Resting energy expenditure was about 2/3rds of their total at the start and protein made a huge difference. Here’s the change in resting energy expenditure on the high calorie diets for all three groups:</p>
<p>Low Protein: burned 21 calories a day less
Normal Protein (15%): burned 160 calories a day more
High Protein (25%): burned 227 calories a day more</p>
<p>That’s right, the group eating 46 grams of protein a day burned fewer calories at rest despite eating over 900 more calories a day. That’s a recipe for an energy in/energy out disaster.</p>
<p>Imagine if we added exercise to the brew? It’s pretty clear from this study that keeping protein consumption reasonably high is very beneficial in terms of energy expenditure and lean body mass. Unfortunately, this is the exact opposite of the take-home message the media is going to report (that you should eat less protein to keep from gaining scale weight)</p>
<p>BTW, these are not super high protein levels. With my meat oriented diet, I don’t that I average the 140 grams of day protein of the “normal protein” group in this study.</p>