Does NMSF matter for the top-tiers?

As little as 3 years ago (when this thread was written), I thought it did a lot.

It does not matter that much. I also think the PSAT/NMSQT is a corrupt test when compared to real SAT.

  1. No Essay Section, which drastically changes scores. Also, essay is one of most important parts of application!
  2. Shorter Test: 1 minor error can knock you down 50 points. That's sad.
  3. Insane grammar curve: This year, as 11th grade, I got 710W which I though was bad, but I only got 2 questions wrong, none of which I have learned the rules for.
  4. Some people just get lucky (or unlucky) on PSAT. There is someone in my school with 2250 PSAT but 2130 SAT 6 months later after studying. How is that possible? She must have gotten lucky on PSAT. BTW, she qualified for NMSF. My scores were opposite (2130 PSAT, 2250 SAT, essay helped a lot), Commended Scholar

On the other hand, last years Salutatorian got 2140 PSAT, 2330 SAT, and got into UPENN.

  1. It is just one of thousands of companies (but unfortunately one of the best known) giving out merit scholarship money. Find another company that actually bases scholarship on real SAT.

I think this should be the process:

  1. October: Students take full 10 section SAT.
  2. September: Students with above 2100 automatically qualify for NMSF (about 30000)
  3. December: Students with good SAT, GPA, EC, move on to NMF (About 14000)
  4. March: 8500 get scholarship.