I’m assuming he’s a junior? I think a gap year is definitely in order - look into exchange programs like Rotary. Best year of my life. Problem is, he’ll have to get up the energy to do the college selection/application process next year. So maybe encourage him to put a reach or two on his list?
I totally understand where he’s coming from. A couple points I’d like to make:
- the salary difference won’t be astronomical. Honestly most jobs won’t really care if you graduated from Yale, or a state school as long as you worked hard and fit their needs. (obviously some careers are more impacted by school than others)
- Allow him to apply wherever he wants, encourage a couple reach schools. Others have mentioned this but I think it’s a great idea. That way if he decides in April that he wants a more rigorous program he has the option, but he also has his fair pick.
Best of luck to you and him!
Case Western Reserve U offers strong music ensembles, and music double majors, environmental science and
also teaching credentials. If he wants a PhD, the teaching credential is not needed, only if he wants to teach high school science. He might be wise to look at the science credentials needed by state if he wants to teach high school sciences. Some states require a broad range of chemistry, physics, biology, geology and environmental science classes.
Case is not as intense as super selective schools.
Here are links for Case Western’s environmental science and music programs- Cleveland Institute of Music teachers are also teaching Case students. Its an excellent musical student body with a lot of double majors.
https://eeps.case.edu
https://music.case.edu
I think it would be harder to double major at JHU or Vanderbilt, but those both also have excellent music programs.
@Trixy34 Great minds and all that (#11)
You may be interested in this article by the Nobel laureate Tom Cech on the topic of how well liberal arts colleges prepare students for a career in science. He himself went to a LAC, but looks at the topic from a balanced point of view:
http://www.thecollegesolution.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/cech_article2.pdf
re: a double major in music…
Is your son thinking of a BA in music (which is usually more of an academic music degree) or a BM (which is more of a pre-professional, performance degree)? It matters. Some schools have one but not the other, others have both. You should head over to the music major forum and read this article stickied at the top, which discusses the various ways to study music in college, which should help your son clarify what type of program he is looking for: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/music-major/1948726-double-degree-dilemma-essay-written-by-david-lane.html
Be aware that a BM degree program at any school is quite intense, usually requires an audition, and usually involves approximately 3/4 music classes (and a great deal of class/rehearsal time) and 1/4 non-music classes, whereas as a BA in music is usually the opposite ratio. BM programs are usually part of a School of Music, with its own graduation requirements that other than some gen ed requirements will not overlap with say the School of Arts and Sciences or wherever an Environmental Science major is housed, so doing a bachelor in music (BM) program along with environmental science would be a double degree program at most schools rather than a double major, and is likely to take 5 years. Double degree programs are, by their nature, very intense and the double degree students that my music major son knows basically do not have time to sleep. A teaching certification will require additional coursework, too.
If your S does a BA in Music that is usually much easier to combine with other majors/minors but if the school has both a BM program and a BA in Music investigate carefully because at some ensembles and music opportunities and professors may be available only to BM students. BA Music programs also vary quite a bit so worth digging into course requirements to see if it will give your son what he wants. He may also be perfectly happy just participating in ensembles and taking lessons as a non music major. I guess the bottom line is, if he wants to do any music study in college, he should figure out now what he is looking for in a music program and research his options early because that could be a major factor in school selection. Professor choice on his instrument also might affect his list of schools or how they rank in his mind.
If you want to explore the music component further, head on over to the Music Major forum where there are lots of very helpful people who have been there and might have some good suggestions for schools once your son narrows down what type of music study he is looking for.
Your son is a junior. He is going to change a lot between now and when he goes to college. He is also going to change a lot in college. I would gently encourage him to apply to a range of schools…this way he has options if he changes his mind.
I agree that a gap year may help…either before college or before entering a PhD program. It’s very hard to go through 4 years of college followed by 4+ years of a PhD program. Some do it, others need a break.
What is he looking to get a PhD in? What are the requirements for entrance into the programs that he may be interested in? You have been given some very good advice about music.
If your son says he can’t do another insane 4 years, I would listen to him. Mental health issues on college campus are real.
You are getting good advice here. Where does your sons desire to be a university professor come from? Do you personally know a professor?
I suggest you try to get your son connected with a couple of professors in his field of interest. Ask for an interview, maybe through the Admissions office. I would go first to the most local universities. Or have a phone or email exchange with professors if they are not local.
I know little about how professors get or retain employment, or how they navigate tenure. I do know it is not an easy path. Most universities will push professors to get grant money for research, so his focus may not get to be actual teaching.
There are schools that put teachers focus on the undergrad classroom, like Clemson. And LACs most likely will keep the profeeors focus to n teaching and avoid using TAs
Have multiple, ongoing conversations about his thought process on wanting to be a professor. And then make sure he knows the long, hard process to get to that goal.
You have time, so breathe deeply. Applications are only one step, and final decisions are a long way off.
If Gap Year becomes a real thing, you can ask about a deferral and retaining scholarship money. It might be less stressful during Gap Year to know where he is headed and be out from under all the application and essay pressures.
At a top college, your son is right that he will be working almost around the clock. A typical workload between classes that are two or three days apart for four classes total per semester may be 500 pages of reading and a problem set to do between classes, plus two weeks in which to complete an essay on top of this. Then add in extracurriculars that involve extensive work, too. With efficiency and determination, there is still time for relaxation and socialization, but there is no doubt that the workload is a bit nuts.
For students who dislike a heavier workload, the elite colleges are not a place they will be happy. Nothing wrong with a top student who wants more balance in life heading to a less elite college, where (s)he even may get a nice merit scholarship.
Last night, a group of high school friends was comparing college experiences. The differences between experiences at different colleges are really dramatic- much more dramatic than I would have anticipated, even after a few years of reading about colleges on College Confidential.
Some colleges have heavier workloads and others have lighter. Some colleges are really intellectually challenging and delve into primary sources; at other colleges, a course with an almost identical title may be much more simplistic and involve just reading a secondary source that summarizes the primary sources. Some college experiences are centered on intellectual conversations and exploration of ideas; other college experiences are about gaining a pre-professional set of skills. At some colleges, ideas are discussed in the dorms and dining halls and people live to think; at other colleges, the exchange of ideas mostly may be limited to the classroom. At some colleges, your son may be surrounded by students who are as smart as he is and be super stimulated by their ideas; in other colleges, he may feel that he is one of the smartest people there. Colleges may have more of an on-campus culture or an in-the-city culture. Colleges may have or not have fraternity culture, sports culture, artsy culture, etc. How they meet and interact with peers may be different at different colleges: some colleges will provide structures that support meeting people from diverse backgrounds, whereas at other colleges, students may find their own friends more independently.
Of course, different colleges will provide different mixes of all of the above. As a parent, it will be a great feeling for you when your child reflects that the college he chose was the right one for him- that the experience he is having is the experience he sought.
So yes, he should explore different colleges and conside the possible trade-offs. Then, when the time comes, he can make an informed decision about where he, as an individual with his own personality, will thrive best.
I might recommend applying to a mix of “prestige” & dream & “likelies”, in addition to some where your student is likely to get some great scholarship $$. Make sure to show interest in every school (visit, email, interview, etc).
If he’s looking for his doctorate, some of the opportunities may build on each other as he goes from undergrad, to grad school, to ultimately his doctorate.
Great advice and choices posted. Another suggestion for a safety could be Eckerd College he would be able to double major, they are well known for environmental studies and sciences. There is a Phi Beta Kappa chapter and a Ford Apprentice Scholar program for those who would like to pursue teaching at a college level. eckerd.edu/environmental-studies/opportunities/research/ There must be other small LAC programs that offer similar programs.
My son said the same thing. He was just plain tired out about academics. Didn’t want a competitive school. Wanted a laid back, relaxed atmosphere. We looked at a number of schools, and he honed into the ones that appeared to be what he wanted in terms of environment.
He picked a small LAC with unusual programs and off the beaten path. Loved the experience which I felt was the best thing about this. Graduated with a math/econ double major and has been doing well.
Yes, I would have preferred that he took on the big names as well and considered them, and, yes, gotten into them and gone to one, AND get the same level of satisfaction, happiness, enjoyment, love of learning and competence in his very marketable fields of study. He did have a few such choices. But, you know, he had a wonderful 4 years there, great friends, doing well–I’m grateful and happy about it…
So shop around and see what works for your son. Not always what we parents find ideal.
A break sounds good.
Check out the College of Wooster in OH. They are routinely rated highly for strong teaching and they have a brand new state-of-the-art Science facility. I know several students who had very nice graduate school acceptances upon graduation - the required Independent Study that all seniors complete is attractive to grad schools and great preparation too. Additionally, they’ve got a strong music program (my DD just graduated w/ a B.M. from there and is on a fully funded PhD path). However, even kids in other majors at Wooster seem to be “musical” w tons of ensembles and opportunities for non-music majors. An added perk is that your DS would likely qualify for a lot of merit aid from them…
Many of my favorites have already been mentioned above, if your child is open to LACs. Oberlin, St Olaf, and College of Wooster, he might also consider Lawrence and Dickinson (near Harrisburg, PA). He would likely be eligible for merit at all.
Slightly larger, also with merit available and good music offerings are Case Western (already mentioned) and U of Rochester.
Good for him for wanting to dial things back a bit. That shows some wisdom, I think. All of the options above, BTW, will offer a quality educational experience. LACs also provide a strong foundation for academic careers and grad student placement.
My kid applied to almost all of the schools listed above so message me if you have any questions.
There’s been some wonderful advice given here. I only want to add that “intense” can mean different things to different people and it’s important to figure out what it means to this kid. Is he using intense to mean competition for a spot in the hierarchy? Does it refer to hours of studying for required classes, most of which are not of interest and feel like drudgery? Or is it simply being in an academic setting that feels too much? Does he light up when he has more individual attention and opportunities for extended study? Once you and he are able to identify where the intensity lies, you’re in a better position to guide the search. At that point, you can visit a range of schools and determine with specificity how they operate, both within the major, and outside of it.
My kid goes to a school that is almost always described as intense and cutthroat. It is not. At least it’s not for the right kid in the right major. For mine, it’s a collaborative environment where people work together. I don’t think my kid would thrive in a larger, more impersonal setting even though the classes might be easier. In fact, that might be terribly frustrating. Everyone is different. My point is that you should not take anyone’s characterization of any school as definitive. Figure out what it is that he wants and likes, what he does not like, and look at everything without prejudgment. Then rule it in or out based on that educated look.
That said, IMO, a gap year sounds wonderful as long as it is works from a financial standpoint.
@BrowniesAnytime Being top 10% and taking multiple APs isn’t enough for getting into Princeton and Hopkins type schools. Is he avoiding competition because he is afraid of rejection? You never know what’s Going on in their minds.
It looks like he’s a junior. Why not just let him kick back a bit his senior year of high school? Right now he thinks he’d like a secondary school science teaching certificate, so have him use a free period as a class assistant for a science class.
Unless there is some burning family need for him to earn a high salary, stop worrying about that issue. He’s not going to make boatloads of money in education either as a secondary school teacher or as a college professor. But both are good gigs for the right person.
Seconding Case Western and St Olaf. Probably the best fits for Environmental Science + Music + studious student body without being pressure cookers.
URochester, Lawrence, Dickinson are other good choices.
Clemson, Duke, JHU are all excellent universities but they’re all high pressure/competitive environments.
You need to find collaborative environments with serious academics.
See if he’s enjoy a “gap year abroad”. He could study in a high school in a foreign country, become nearly bilingual/bicultural, travel a bit, all without much pressure since he’d be out of his current school. What foreign language has he studied?
What schedule has he planned for senior year? Let’s see if we can lighten the pressure while keeping enough rigor.