When dropping D17 off at Move-In, I definitely noticed a decent representation from “flyover country” as well as the large urban areas. It was great to see so many smart kids from all over the place. A competitive applicant and (hopefully) NMF from rural FL will definitely have an edge not just at UChicago but other places as well. @okeydokeypokey, my bias leans toward your son finding his place at UChicago! My daughter was in the same situation - as an NMF she basically had tuition covered at her state flagship (UMN so comparable to FSU in terms of overall ranking and prestige) and was accepted into one of their more competitive colleges as well as the honors program. I’d say if NMF money is part of your college decision at this point do not apply EDI - stick with EA for now and see where it gets him. If deferred, he can always switch over to EDII and try from that angle (should he change his mind and decide UChicago is his #1). Make sure to talk to FA and work with the online net cost calculator before signing any binding agreement.
UChicago is going to be more expensive than FSU - perhaps by a lot - but there is also a huge difference between the two institutions. Has he visited yet?