So sorry for not revisiting this thread! I haven’t checked in on CC for a little while…
Yes, as @wisteria100 pointed out, my daughter will be going to Haverford. She applied ED1 to Williams but was deferred. She thought about holding out for RD, but she liked Haverford equally well and the Williams deferral letter kind of indicated that a deferral is pretty much a rejection. She applied to Haverford ED2 and was admitted!
She immediately withdrew her other apps, but interestingly, Colby didn’t process that withdrawal, and she wound up getting accepted there as well. She was already committed to Haverford, but it’s kind of nice to know she would have had other good options if Haverford hadn’t worked out. 