@ak9800 you can find my stats here: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/fordham-university/1935477-chance-at-presidential-scholar.html#latest
My advice to you is to make your uncommon essay truly uncommon. UChicago is the hardest school to predict in terms of admissions and if you can demonstrate your interest and write an incredible uncommon essay, you are maximizing your chances at admission.