OP, basically, what everybody is saying is that there is no difference in regards to prestige and chances for later acceptance into, say, law school. You could follow you different majors in either, and your chances at finding a job would be very high after graduating from either. Both have powerful alumni networks, both have excellent internship programs, both have amazing faculty, academics, student body, etc.
As other posters, and I, have written, the most important things in determining your success are fit and finances. As long as you can afford either, choose based on where you feel you’d fit the best. Since the two are very different, as I wrote, “fit” should be your major deciding factors. So you need to figure out which environment you prefer, that of a Liberal Arts College in a rural setting in the NE, or a small private university in an urban setting in the SE.
As for food, Midd has better food on campus by far, but at Emory you will have access to Atlanta and the opportunities there. So, I would say that Emory has the edge.