Engineering Shortage or not?

<p>

</p>

<p>98% of engineers end up doing engineering work? Really? According to the data, the country graduates about 70,000 engineers a year. 2% of that is 1400. You think there are really only 1400 engineers a year who end up doing non-engineering work?</p>

<p>I’ll put it to you this way. MIT graduates about 1000 BS engineers a year. About 1/3 go to engineering graduate school. Of the rest, only about 1/2 of them take engineering jobs. Hence, that’s about 300 MIT BS engineers who end up working in consulting, banking, or go to law school or (yes) medical school or do other non-engineering jobs. </p>

<p>That’s just MIT. Add up the engineers from Stanford, Berkeley, Princeton, and all those other elite engineering schools and I think you will rapidly exceed 1400. </p>

<p>And what’s this talk about discriminating against engineering majors? I think a FAR more accurate statement would be discriminating against low-graded majors. Engineering is not the only low-graded major. I would argue that ALL technical majors, including the natural sciences, are graded low. </p>

<p>Which is why I said it before, I’ll say it again - engineers don’t have it the worst. Natural science majors have it the worst. At least the engineer can get a decent job. The natural science majors can’t even do that. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>And what would that be? Name one. Are you going to come out and name a grade-inflated major like Film Studies?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>In this particular case, I think you’re offbase. It has been well understood that there has been a veritable explosion in people getting science degrees, especially in Biology or related science degrees (Biochemistry, Genetics, MCB, etc.) But this has nothing to do with engineering, except for the corner case of BioEngineering.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Wrong. My data is from 2005.</p>

<p>Again:</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.nursing2004.com/pt/pt-core/template-journal/nursing/media/46SalarySurvey.pdf[/url]”>http://www.nursing2004.com/pt/pt-core/template-journal/nursing/media/46SalarySurvey.pdf&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>But the question is, do all nurses get overtime? I don’t think so. Just because you want to work overtime hours doesn’t mean you’re going to get it. You actually have to be working in a hospital or a clinic where the demand is stretched such that they ask for you to stick around and do more work . You can’t just simply “decide” to hang around the hospital in your free time and then request to get paid for it. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>And when did I say that engineering was a perfect undergrad major. Point out the quote where I specifically said that. In fact, I have written many a post talking about the problems of engineering.</p>

<p>However, I maintain that it is still one of the best, if not the best undergraduate major to have. Does that mean it’s perfect? Nope, never said it was. But it is still far better than almost every single other one out there, for the reasons that I named.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Once again, we disagree. In particular, nobody seems to factor in the fact that most engineers come from no-name schools. Look, the guy who graduated last in his engineering class from Montana Tech was probably never going to get into medical school.</p>

<p>I would again submit that only about half of all premeds who even make it to the application stage actually get in somewhere. Even Harvard boasts of only a 90% premed placement rate. And all of that has to do with those premeds who apply. Plenty of people don’t even apply because they know they won’t get in anywhere. If you have a GPA under a 2.5, you are not going to get in. And even Harvard has some students that have less than a 2.5</p>

<p>The point is, y’all keep talking about medicine as if any old fool can just go and become doctors. Tell that to the half of the premeds who applied and didn’t get in anywhere. Obviously these people thought they had a chance, because they took the time and spent the money to apply. Yet of even those people, half of them were wrong. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Yeah, maybe greater, but certainly not ‘great’. There are plenty of people who take easy majors and still can’t get in anywhere. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>First of all, what I find TREMENDOUSLY ironic is that you’re now touting nursing. But you’re not majoring in nursing. Why not? In fact, from what you’ve written, you’re majoring in engineering. Why? Here you are touting how great nursing is and how engineering is not, and yet YOU’RE MAJORING IN ENGINEERING. What’s up with that? Please do tell.</p>

<p>Secondly, do you really think that all those liberal arts majors really know all the pitfalls that await them? Trust me, most don’t. Don’t believe me? You can just take a stroll around CC and you will see how clueless plenty of liberal arts majors are about their future prospects. And I consider CC users to be an more-informed-than-average group of people.</p>

<p>Hence, the point is, if we can agree on nothing else, we can agree that engineering is more marketable than those other degrees. Why don’t you go and pick on those other degrees? </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Nobody is denying that there are problems with engineering. However, those problems are the same problems that almost all other people with just bachelor’s degrees face. And that’s the point.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Oh, I profoundly disagree. Accounting is a b**** of a major. Is it as difficult as engineering? No, probably not. But on the other hand, let’s not discount its difficulty. At the end of the day, it’s still a highly technical, quantitative major that is inherently difficult. </p>

<p>Look, again, I think we are forgetting that engineering as a whole isn’t that hard. Engineering at a top school is hard. But then there are plenty of no-name engineering schools out there, where engineering is much easier.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>We did go over the PA route. And I think we agreed that it was not a relevant point, for the simple fact that most PA’s already have undergrad degrees in something and then later complete the 2 year PA program. So the PA program effectively becomes a post-graduate program.</p>

<p>"Most applicants to PA programs hold a bachelor’s or master’s degree. "</p>

<p><a href=“http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos081.htm#earnings[/url]”>http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos081.htm#earnings&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>But back to nursing. So basically, you’ve come up with 1 major that you think can challenge engineering. That’s right ONE. Out of the hundreds of available majors out there, you have identified ONE. At worst, that means that engineering is the 2nd-best major out there. You should at least give credit to engineering for that. </p>

<p>Furthermore, for various reasons that I have already stated, I believe that engineering has the edge over nursing. Note, that doesn’t mean that I think nursing is bad. It’s just that I think that engineering has the edge. Why? Simple. With the available of post-bac BSN programs out there, somebody who already has an engineering degree can become a nurse in just 1 year. However, there is no easy way for a nurse to quickly switch over to engineering. And secondly, engineering is a far more widespread major than is nursing. I don’t know too many people who would turn down admission to UC to go to CalState just to get a nursing degree. I don’t know too many people who would turn down HYPSMC because they’d rather get a nursing degree from some other school. </p>

<p>However, what I find really ironic is that you say that I shouldn’t recommend engineering to people who don’t have the passion to do it, and yet here you are recommending nursing to people, but I don’t see you talking about passion for nursing as being important. That should cut both ways.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>First off, the notion that engineers don’t get overtime is not true. There are plenty of engineers who are working as hourly contractors, which means that they get overtime pay (or at the very worst, straight pay, but calculated over more than 40 hours a week). </p>

<p>Secondly, yes, I know some nurses that are salaried. More to the point, most doctors and lawyers, especially when they’re starting out, are salaried. Lawyers are the easiest case - most lawyers enter law firms where they’re expected to work 70+ hours a week in order to make partner - but nobody is paying them overtime to do it. Sure, they may be billing all those hours they work, but they’re not getting that money. The law firm is getting that money. </p>

<p>Now I agree that lawyers who make it to partner or enter private practice will bill more hours for more work. But do all lawyers make partner? Do all lawyers enter private practice and succeed? Plenty of lawyers just take salaried staff positions as inhouse counsel at companies. Others work for the government, i.e. in the prosecutor’s office, or for some government agency, etc. . None of these lawyers get any overtime. </p>

<p>Or consider the case of doctors. Doctors in residency make something like 40k a year. And yet resident doctors work ridiculous hours. In fact, some states are trying to pass laws that are trying to RESTRICT resident doctors to working “only” 80 hours a week. Yeah, “ONLY” 80 hours. Yet, nobody is paying them overtime for that. If you take a salaried position in a hospital as many doctors do, you don’t get any overtime. Hey, if you want to hang out at the hospital after your shift is over and do a few more surgeries, I don’t think anybody is going to stop you, but you can’t expect to get a fatter paycheck for it. </p>

<p>The same is true for accountants. Most accountants are salaried employees working for accounting firms, or for the accounting departments of companies. None of them make any overtime. </p>

<p>Hence, I would actually argue the exact opposite that you said. Most professions do NOT get overtime, nor can they bill for extra hours. Most professionals are salaried people of some kind. Overtime is actually a much more common feature of blue-collar work.</p>

<p>Now as far as blue-collar jobs like firemen, policemen, and all that. Ok, yes, they make overtime. But so what? You don’t need a college degree to get those jobs. There’s no such major as “firefighting” or “policing”. Surely you’re not advocating that everybody should just drop out of school to become cops? Hence, it still leaves open the question that if you want to get an undergraduate degree, it has to be in something. And besides, somebody who gets an engineering degree can decide to become a cop. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>This is not about ‘attacking’ anything. I am simply asking for fairness. Fairness because most of the other examples that have been given, like medicine or law, require graduate degrees, whereas engineering does not. That’s like me trying to compare college graduates vs. high school graduates and arriving at the conclusion that college graduates are better off, ignoring the fact that to in order to graduate from college, you first have to graduate from high school. </p>

<p>Secondly, ALL of the downsides of engineering have to be discussed in the context of all the other choices you can make out there. People have talked about how engineering is a braindead job where you can get attacked by management, ignoring the fact that MOST jobs out there are braindead jobs where you can get attacked by management. People have talked about how engineers can suffer from layoffs, conveniently ignoring the fact that MOST people with just undergrad degrees can suffer from layoffs. Some have said that engineering is a difficult major that grades harshly, conveniently ignoring the fact that there are plenty of non-engineering majors (like physics) out there that are also difficult and also grade harshly, but I find it funny that nobody wants to say boo about them. </p>

<p>Look, everything has to be put in its proper perspective. If you want to criticize engineering for certain features, then you have to be willing to criticize other majors that exhibit the same features. Most of the supposed problems of engineering that have been pointed out there are not specific to engineering.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>But they don’t love it by enough to switch to nursing. There’s gotta be a reason for that.</p>

<p>Look, at most schools, guys can always switch to majors that have more girls. Let’s face it. You can always switch out of engineering to Art History or French Literature or one of those other majors that have a lot of women in them. But most don’t do it. Why? #1 - lack of interest. And #2 (especially for nursing), they don’t want to break the ‘macho code’. Guys know what I’m talking about when I say that. </p>

<p>Look, whether we like it or not, male nurses have a serious image problem. The fact is, lots of guys are afraid to become nurses because they don’t want to be laughed at for taking a “woman’s job”. Yes, to the women who are reading this, I know that’s a bit sexist to say, but, again, I think the guys here know what I’m talking about. Whether we think it’s right or not, the fact is, a lot of guys just don’t think of nursing as being a “manly” profession. And even if a guy doesn’t personally think that way, he will know that other guys will think that way, and that will make him think twice about becoming a nurse. Sad but true.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Nursing is NOT an easy major. The easy majors would be things like Film Studies or Peace and Conflict Studies, etc. So the logical conclusion is that people who want to maximize their chances of getting into med-school should not choose to major in engineering, and not choose to major in nursing, but should choose to major in Film Studies.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>And there it is again - the presumption is that every engineer can just decide to become a doctor. A simple look at the numbers would demonstrate that this is false. 70,000 people get engineering BS degrees in the US. There are only 17,000 US med-school slots that open every year. Even if every single one of those 70,000 people decided that they should try to get into medical school, and the med-schools were to accept only them that would still leave 53,000 of them out in the cold. </p>

<p>Hence, I still don’t see how any of us can just flippantly say that everybody should just go become doctors. Very very few people become doctors. That’s like saying that everybody should just go win the lottery. Most people can’t win the lottery. Most people can’t become doctors.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Look, unggio83, I never said that nursing was bad. In fact, I believe nursing can actually be pretty good, however, I continue to maintain that engineering has the edge if, for no other reason, somebody with an engineering degree can become a nurse in 1 year by getting that accelerated BSN degree, but the reverse is not true.</p>

<p>However, fine, have it your way. If I’m going to say that nursing can be a relatively good major to choose, then you ought to say that engineering can be a relatively good major to choose.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>But don’t you see, Oh_DaD, even if these numbers are correct, it still means that engineering has been declining as a percentage of the number of bachelor’s degrees granted. More and more total Americans have been graduating from college, which should not be surprising as the population of the country continues to grow and also as education has become more important to the economy, thereby causing more Americans to want to go to college. Yet even if the number of engineering degrees has remained constant, that must mean that the percentage of engineers has declined.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’ll put it to you this way. I think we all know that from a common sense standpoint, Agriculture Schools have declined. Yet, I rarely if ever run across a school bragging about how it’s going to shut down or reduce the size of its agriculture program.</p>

<p>“And there it is again - the presumption is that every engineer can just decide to become a doctor.”</p>

<p>Well, every good engineer CAN become a doctor!!! Engineering is the harshest major…if you’re good at the toughest major, becoming a doctor is not that difficult.</p>

<p>Only thing is, you’ve got to apply! …without applying, you’ll never become a doctor.</p>

<p>Do professional schools such as medicine and law actually discriminate against engineering undergrads because of some stereotype about engineers (for instance, are they seen as being inflexible, etc?) Or are they underrepresented in the professions because of lower undergrad GPAs? Or maybe something else?</p>

<p>Or, is this just my incorrect perception?..Thanks!</p>

<p>Sakky, “engineering” is pretty broad. Do you have different opinions on chem/eecs/biomed/mech? Also, is physics a viable undergraduate major? And if I’d like to leave the door to medical school open, would biomed be better than the others (which are still perfectly fine options)?</p>

<p>lkf725, it’s a GPA thing - a good number of high-gpa’d engineers get into law and med school.</p>

<p>:)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>To be a doctor, not only you need to have a prolonged, extensive education, you also need to have a devoted time of your life. Being engineers gives you the versality to look at other opportunities, i.e. investing, banking, management, etc. which is generally not an option for doctors. What are you talking about?</p>

<p>sakky, I don’t know about your “macho job” idea. Also, film studies is a lot of work. Have you ever tried to read a movie? Sure, you aren’t doing a sheet of problem sets for 30 hours, but it is not so easy as you paint it. The grading tends to be much easier, but you and other engineering people tend to discount aspects of difficulty other than mathematical or scientific exactitude.</p>

<p>rtkysg, the doctor can, after receiving his or her BA/BS degree, look into those fields, too.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well first off, like I said, not every engineer is a good one. There are thousands of mediocre engineers out there.</p>

<p>Furthermore, like I said, just look at the numbers. They don’t match. There are 70,000 new BS engineers graduating in the US every year. Yet there are only 17,000 med-school openings in the US every year. So even if all these engineers were to apply to med-school and med-schools were to stop admitting bio majors, chem majors, and every other major, and only admitted engineers, that would still leave 53,000 engineers out in the cold, or 75% of them. Should these 53,000 people just go and commit suicide?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>So basically you’re castigating all those people (not just engineers, but all people) who don’t apply, is that what you’re saying? Again, look at the numbers. 1.3 million new bachelor’s degrees are conferred in the US. Yet only about 35,000 applications are sent to US med-schools every year. Hence, that means that 97% of all new graduates don’t apply to med-school. Are you saying that all these people are foolish? </p>

<p>That’s what I’ve been saying throughout this entire thread. Aehmo, why are you picking on just the engineers? You should be picking on ALL the people who aren’t trying to become doctors.</p>

<p>I think this subject has been beaten to death several times over. A few reminders:

  • please comment on issues and facts, not other members
  • if you find yourself quoting someone else in many of your posts, you are probably being overly argumentative. We disabled automatic quoting to avoid this kind of discussion.</p>

<p>Thanks for cooperating.</p>