@preppedparent
If I was an AO and I didn’t feel the candidate I was interviewing was a good fit for the school, I would tell them so, regardless of how much or little information about them I had. When it comes to fit, personality and attitude are what matter the most, and you learn about those things from a face-to-face meeting or interview; you can’t get them from a piece of paper listing the person’s ECs and test scores. While I can understand a bit of your frustration, I don’t think you’re justified in your negative opinion of the AO. Lastly, this thread isn’t a space to vent your frustrations, neither is it a place for you to brag in order to feel better about your daughter’s talents and academic ability.