I would choose the one that accepted me. What I would not do, is engage in such an exercise until March 10, assuming I had acceptances to both. At that point, I might solicit opinions, while simultaneously providing my own pros/cons for each. Keep in mind, though, that what one person considers a negative can be a positive to another. “Fit” is, IMO, an important part of the decision process.
In terms of applying, if both interest you, apply to both.
For the mindless diversionary game, a thread already exists:
http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/prep-school-cafe/1482088-would-you-rather-boarding-school-edition.html#latest