F & M, Dickinson, Gettysburg, Connecticut College or American University

Less than a week to go before Decision Day and my son is not even close to a decision. Ugh! We visited Connecticut College and it feels like the best fit for my son because of the course offerings and honor code, but a 4 hour train ride may be too much for my homebody. I am afraid that he will choose Ursinus just because it is the closest and offered the most aid. He also likes American bc it is in DC and a faster train ride, but it does not seem to offer the best program since he really enjoys the Classics. Dickinson and F & M are still in the running though. Any thoughts on these schools would be appreciated.