Final MT Decisions Background - Class of 2023

So, I am so glad to be able to start this essay on my Son’s journey through this process. CC has been an invaluable help in this incredibly challenging process.Thank you to all who responded, added input and advice.

Programs Applied to:
Coastal Carolina, Western Carolina, Catholic, Missouri State, James Madison, Nazareth, U Tampa, Suny Cortland, Muhlenberg, American , Stevens Point, Indiana, Penn State, Baldwin Wallace, CCM, CMU, Fredonia, Ball State, Rider, UNCSA, Point Park, Pace, WestCONN, Syracuse, BOCO, Oklahoma, Emerson, Shenandoah, Michigan, Pace.

Prescreens: Passed all but CMU, Ithaca, Michigan.

Artistically accepted (eventually) after audition to:
Coastal Carolina (redirected BFA acting), Western Carolina(BFA), Catholic (BM), Missouri State(BFA), James Madison(BA), Nazareth(BFA), U Tampa(BFA), Suny Cortland(BA), Muhlenberg (BA), American (BA) , Viterbo(BFA), Stevens point(BFA).

Accepted but redirected to BA theater:
Indiana, WestConn, Baldwin Wallace, Ball State,

Rejected after audition from:
Penn State, Pace, BOCO, CCM, CMU, Rider, Fredonia, Ithaca, Syracuse, Point Park, Oklahoma, Shenandoah, Michigan, Emerson MT redirected to BFA acting but withdrew before audition,

Coach: None

Summer Programs: Penn State S.T.A.T.E junior year.

I realized that is a lot (30), but that was the plan - we weren’t taking chances after we read last year’s forum of kids getting to April w/out an acceptance and the numbers of applicants rising as evidenced by CMU telling us 1500 applied last year for 10 or so spots. The admission director at Shenandoah asked us early on “how many programs are you applying to? Make it at least 15-20” So we did. It was then that I realized we were in for an expensive ride (credit card be damned!)

Background:

My son started performing when he was 7 in a local youth theater, amid trying football, baseball, and soccer. He was tall for his age, so sports seemed natural. But he quickly shined on stage in various youth theaters and school theater. We quickly realized that his voice was different than the other kids his age, so by the time he was 10 we enrolled him with a vocal coach. He started to get leads in every show, so we supported what he said was what brought him joy. He started doing local theater groups and was cast in “Oliver” for 25 shows at a dinner theater in Westchester, NY (where we live). If he could do 25 shows at 12 years old, and liked it, then he could handle this career choice. He said after the 25 shows, “I want more”. He attended Penn State Summer program the summer of his junior year and “loved it”. He wanted Penn State badly at that point to be “the one”. Heartache awaited.

We did our first audition way back in October at Indiana, and scheduled some big schools early in the process. Since we had his essays written and applications in by labor day, scheduling became very easy. A tip I learned was to check the audition dates for each school,make a chart, and do some logistics scheduling from October to March live auditions and unifeds in NY. We did not do Chicago. If I had to do it over again, we would not do his top tier schools early, as he got better as audition season progressed. So quick rejections came from Indiana and Baldwin which were 2 of the 1st schools we auditioned. Now comes the heartache. We auditioned for his top school Penn State on Dec. 1st for both acting and MT. He loved both programs, so he gave it a shot. We got a letter from The BFA acting that he was “deferred” which the director said was a “very good thing” and that you are on a list of students we are considering. He was very excited. MT was denied after audition. NOW, we called Penn to find out what “deferred” really meant, and the director was shocked. He said Sam ws “denied” from both programs, and it was a mistake. Sam was devastated. How could they do this to him. Especially a big school like that, to make a “mistake”. Pushing the wrong button on the computer should not happen at this level. He felt dejected that Friday we found out and went to bed upset. Had I checked the mail that day things would have been different because in the morning, we had a letter from Catholic U in DC that he was accepted into the Musical theater BM program after his remote audition. Wow. That changed the mood of the family. BTW, we did remote audition for Catholic, Tampa, American, and Western Carolina and were eventually accepted to every program. So remote auditions do work as long as prescreen tapes look good. From there it was a roller coaster of unifieds, live auditions and acceptances and denials. This is where it gets fun.

His last audition live was at Missouri State in NYC on March 9th. We really liked the program and they offered a nice merit scholarship plus in state tuition when we were academically accepted. The first week of March we were thinking we would either be accepting Catholic U , Viterbo, James Madison or Coastal (waitlisted). The other acceptances at this point (6 of them by then) were not high on our lists. Now came March 21, and we were making plans to visit Viterbo in April when Missouri State (Bob Westenberg) called us and accepted Sam into the MT program. We were ecstatic. Note: Future MT’er’s do not overlook this school in your journey, it is wonderful.
So plans changed and we were looking to get to Missouri for a visit. We bought tickets to go to Missouri with a detour to James Madision and then drive back to NYC. It would be a crazy 2 days. We cancelled Viterbo’s visit until after we visited Missouri. Just as we were set to go to Missouri, Western Carolina notified us that Sam was pulled off the waitlist and would be one of 10 in their Stage and Screen BFA MT program. WOW! Big surprise here. We had liked Western early in the game, but knew it was slim when they only accept 10 to MT. The Missouri visit was great. Loved the program, director, campus and the price. Sam felt really good here and he wanted to cancel JMU and Viterbo, which we did, but still wanted to see Western Carolina. So I got him tickets (more $$) to Western carolina for a last visit on April 22nd. I was sure he would choose MIssouri and their amazing program. He was shocked when he visited Western to say the least. The beautiful campus in the Blue Ridge mountains, artistic community of Asheville, the MT program with Terrance Mann on the faculty and directing one musical a year, and the kids were really welcoming. So it came down to Missouri and Western. Western was the ONLY school that I did not attend with him on a visit.

Final decision: Western Carolina School of Stage and Screen BFA MT. Western won him over. He said it was hands down “the feeling you get when you know it felt right”. I had to give it to him, he really convinced me that he knew what he wanted. We committed the next day, and he has been all smiles ever since then. It’s funny that he never bought “swag” at any school visits until he visited Western Carolina. I guess that was the sign that he had found his home. He will be a “Catamount”.

Congratulations @collegeboundSam

Congrats @collegeboundSam

Fantastic! Congratulations to your son and to you all @collegeboundSam! What a ride! :slight_smile:

Wow, What great stories of finding perfect fits. Congratulations @katzenbogen and @collegeboundSam!

Congratulations @klrbee16!

Congratulations @CaliMTdreams!

So happy for your family and Sam!! Congrats

@katzenbogen and @collegeboundSam Congratulations! Great stories!

YAY Sam! @collegeboundSam; Also, congrats to @katzenbogen, @CaliMTdreams, @kirbee16 and everyone else who has shared their final decision. So fun to read your stories!

@CaliMTdreams. Congratulations!!

@katzenbogen @collegboundSam Congratulations on finding their fit!!

Fantastic stories @CaliMTdreams @collegeboundSam and @katzenbogen. Glad your kids all found their perfect school and you are done!

@katzenbogen Hi, my daughter has also committed to UC Irvine as a MT hopeful for the fall. I’m a newbie on the site, and not really sure how to direct message, but I’d love for our daughters to get in contact!

So excited to see some more final decisions today!!!

It feels surreal to finally be done! Here goes…

Schools applied to: CMU, Penn State, Pace, Ithaca, Elon, OKCU, Baldwin Wallace, Point Park, Miami, Montclair, Rider, Hartt, CCM, Michigan, Coastal Carolina, BoCo, MSM, Syracuse, U of Arizona, NYU Tisch, Shenandoah, Florida State, UAB, Molloy/Cap 21, Texas State

Prescreens passed: Elon, Coastal Carolina, Rider, Ithaca (Acting)

Artistic acceptances: Hartt MT, Rider MT, Manhattan School of Music MT, U of Alabama/Birmingham MT, Oklahoma City Acting

Waitlists - all for MT: Texas State, Molloy/Cap 21, U of Arizona, NYU Tisch

Coach: MTCA - the best decision we made!!! I never would’ve survived this without them.

Like most, my daughter has been involved in theater since 2nd grade. In 9th grade she realized this was the path she wanted to pursue for college and beyond. Our high school doesn’t have a strong theater program so she began attending a half day pre-college conservatory program in the city near us. It is an intense program and includes dance every day which was an area she wanted to improve upon. They put on multiple shows throughout the year and the training is excellent. She has also taken private voice lessons locally from a wonderful instructor for 4 years. Most of the students in the conservatory program move on to study MT in college. We saw them go through the audition process and quickly realized how competitive and difficult it was. My daughter is also in the dreaded and over represented blonde hair & blue eyed group. We entered this with a realistic view and knew there would be a lot of rejections ahead. I found CC and am so grateful for the information, tips, suggestions and support. We signed on with MTCA and their guidance and support was invaluable. I was adamant about preparing early so she had all her material picked out by April of last year and spent the summer perfecting her pieces. She also wrote her common app essay over the summer and worked on the applications and supplements once the applications opened up. One thing she didn’t anticipate was all the essays - there were so many! We used MTCA’s essay coach for some help and it was money well spent. Prescreens were filmed in early September and she began submitting applications at the end of September. We used a professional to do the filming - I’m technologically challenged and could never have produced a quality video. D received 3 quick prescreen no’s before she got a yes and the no’s kept coming. She had terrible prescreen results (8 no’s) and it was a rough start to the process. Looking back, we probably should’ve tried to re-film them but she had her big fall show and there didn’t seem to be any time. I think this is worth mentioning - she had done a voice masterclass in August with the head of one of the programs where her prescreen was rejected. This program head was pretty tough on the kids in the class and gave some brutally honest evaluations. However, my daughter received high praise from this person - told her she was incredibly talented, had no notes for her, etc. Fast forward 2 months and she didn’t even pass the prescreen for the school! That just baffled me but was a good reminder of the unpredictability of this process. As the prescreen no’s kept rolling in I began to panic but tried to remain positive for my daughter. There were MANY sleepless nights for me during this time! She handled the rejections really well (much better than me) and kept moving forward. She added some schools that weren’t originally on the list when the no’s started adding up.

In the end she did 17 auditions. She had 2 on campus auditions in November, 2 in December, and 1 in January. The rest were done at NY & Chicago Unifieds. I highly recommend doing fall auditions if your child is ready. OKCU was her first audition and she received the BFA Acting acceptance 11/30. It wasn’t exactly what she wanted but she was excited for a BFA acceptance at a school she loved. It was also a confidence booster after receiving so many prescreen rejections. Her Hartt acceptance came on 12/14 from the 12/7 audition - we both cried when we read the email. It was such a huge relief to have an MT acceptance and she had loved her audition experience there. She went into Unifieds with a lot less stress. In NY she did the Combines and received a call back from Texas State. She auditioned for them that weekend and applied when we got home. She was waitlisted there and ultimately released from the waitlist. She adores Kaitlin Hopkins and would’ve accepted on the spot if offered a place. I was thankful Kaitlin released her early and it isn’t hanging over her head now. The Rider acceptance came from NY Unifieds. Her NYU Tisch audition was January 21 and finished out our NY trip. NYU resulted in a waitlist. In Chicago she did 2 walk ins at UAB & Molloy/Cap 21. She loved both of those auditions and applied to them. From Chicago she was accepted at UAB & MSM and waitlisted at Molloy/Cap 21 and U of Arizona. I have to interject how much I love the faculty at UAB. They were absolutely wonderful in the parent meeting and are doing some exciting things. This is definitely an up and coming program! MSM was the last school she heard from on 3/28. All decisions were in and she narrowed her choices down to Hartt, Rider and MSM. She was so grateful to have options and felt very torn about the decision. After visiting all three campuses there was a clear favorite. She walked out of the last class she sat in on and said “this is it”!

Final decision: Manhattan School of Music, Musical Theatre

She loved the faculty, students, classes and Liza Gennaro. Liza met with us and answered all our questions. She was so forthcoming and kind. She has a clear vision of the program and has made some exciting changes. I was concerned about the newness of the program but after speaking to Liza I know they are well positioned to turn out employable artists. The students are held to a very high standard and are exposed to industry professionals on a daily basis. John Kander recently sat in on their Cabaret rehearsals and worked with the students!! The faculty are phenomenal. D was in complete awe of David Loud after she sat in on his class - talk about an impressive resume! My daughter is beyond excited and I’m beyond relieved to be done. I loved the one on one time we shared but I wouldn’t want to go through this again!!

@ac2680 congrats!

@ac2680 I am sure your D will love MSM - and living in NYC! Congratulations!!!

Hooray @ac2680 !!!

@ac2680 Congratulations! And I second your interjection re: the UAB faculty! They were so lovely!