@VANYU2021Mom CAS does not give out merit academic scholarships without need. So I’d be surprised if your D’s scholarship isn’t need based. Was your EFC above the COA of about $72K? If your EFC was below that at all, your D’s package was based on financial need, plus academic merit. If NYU decides they really want you, they will meet all of your need and can come out with excellent packages that include academic “merit scholarships.” However, if your EFC is above the cost of attendance, you are not considered for the academic scholarship component.
For CAS students, the only exception for pure merit aid is the MLK scholarships that will be given out regardless of need.
For Steinhardt students, pure merit aid (no need) is given for talent in art and music.
https://www.nyu.edu/admissions/undergraduate-admissions/aid-and-costs/scholarships.html