Good college/university crossed with an opportunity to fence

Can’t speak for fencing specifically, but most of the schools on the list are NCAA Division III institutions, which are generally pretty open to walk-ons.

Brown and Lafayette compete in NCAA Division I, so they are more serious about athletics. However, Lafayette is very small for a DI school; they are basically a liberal arts college that offers athletic scholarships in some of the higher-profile sports. They do not offer athletic scholarships in fencing, so I suspect that the Lafayette fencing program, while technically DI, is actually not much different from many small-school DIII programs.

My guess is that a 33 ACT gives your D credibility as a prospective applicant at any of these schools. I think it would be OK for her to email the coaches and ask if participation on the fencing team as a walk-on is an option. She should indicate that she is not trying to be recruited as a fencer, or seeking a tip in admissions.