He’s interesting and he’s a standout in the context of his school, but…I have a few questions. You refer to an “honors track.” How many kids are in that track. In the context of that group, how outstanding is he? He has 4s on AP tests. I assume very few kids take those exams, but how do those who do take them score? What dual credit courses did he take? How did he do in them? Why isn’t he using a college prof for a LOR if his grades were good?
I think in this sort of situation his parents’ background matters. You say he isn’t first generation, so you and/or his dad went to college. It also sounds as if he’s not eligible for fin aid at these schools, which means your family income is fairly high.
Colleges will judge your S in context and context is not just his high school. I may be way off base but I think an admissions committee will be less forgiving of a kid’s test scores if you and your H are professors at the local university–there must be some sort of college nearby for there to be dual credit courses-- or a doctor and lawyer, etc.
What did he do with his summers?
I think it’s definitely worth applying. He’s got great options already so there’s nothing to lose.