Have 45k saved for college. Enough?

<p>

</p>

<p>lol, that is true… just dig out her vid when we visit the zoo, took the train ride… it was just like yesterday.</p>

<p>but wait, redwing… Where did you get the class of '13 COA figure? UC costs 30K/year right now for in state class of '14 for all intensive purposes, that is 120K right there, assuming the tuition will not increase for 4 years, which I am dreaming.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Ah, but having college savings won’t hurt chances at Merit scholarships, only need based financial aid. And regardless of how the money is saved, I think the chance of my kids qualifying for need based financial aid is about zero. (I ran my income and savings through the FAFSA quick calculator…results weren’t pretty to say the least.)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>That’s my estimate for COA. 80k total for 4 years. </p>

<p>Needless to say, I don’t live in California.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Absolutely true! When the kids graduated from high school, I turned 2 years of college costs into cash. When they finished their sophomore year, I turned the remaining 2 year of funds into cash. </p>

<p>You also have to remember that most parents pay for college through a number of different pots of $$$, of which savings is only one. There are student loans, parent loans, student summer and on campus jobs, home equity, current income flow, having a parent take a second job or having a SAH spouse go back to work, merit aid, etc.</p>

<p>$45K savings now, invested over 18 years, will take a lot of pressure off when baby is ready to make college choices. Be sure to learn about wise investing…</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Good grief, that’s insane. Earned my gradual degree in '89 and remember agonizing over the payments each of the four semesters for $2,500 at the flagship UC campus. </p>

<p>In that case the OP should put aside $300 per paycheck.</p>

<p>Talk to a VERY reputable financial advisor who will assess your career plans, real estate (if any), other savings, potential retirement funds, etc. There is no way that anyone here can offer you anything other than well intended, educated, advise, based on limited information given. Talk to an expert. You are not in the area, but he has written phenomenal books and is well known. Please check out any financial books by Ric Edlemen. </p>

<p>From his website, tips on picking a financial advisor:
[How</a> to Choose a Financial Advisor - 10 Questions to Ask When Evaluating Financial Advisors](<a href=“http://www.ricedelman.com/cs/education/article?articleId=990&titleParam=How%20to%20Choose%20a%20Financial%20Advisor%20-%2010%20Questions%20to%20Ask%20When%20Evaluating%20Financial%20Advisors]How”>http://www.ricedelman.com/cs/education/article?articleId=990&titleParam=How%20to%20Choose%20a%20Financial%20Advisor%20-%2010%20Questions%20to%20Ask%20When%20Evaluating%20Financial%20Advisors)</p>

<p>Best of luck.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I have! He reviewed my financial situation, and said, “wow, I’m very impressed…about the only thing you could do is start saving for college.” Hence, I’m here.</p>

<p>Then I would follow up with him regarding his suggestions on how to do so. If he doesn’t feel this is his best area of expertise, then ask for a referral.</p>

<p>Cheers!</p>

<p>We borrowed. We should have borrowed even more.
Then we saddled the kid with the PLUS besides his unsubsidized Stafford. :)</p>

<p>Loans are now permanently fixed at 2.75% for 20 more years and 2.25% for 10 more years (originally 25 and 15 years.) </p>

<p>Kid’s UGMA got wacked in 2000 and again 2001-2005 however, the UGMA is still sufficient to extinguish the debts.</p>

<p>Unless something has changed recently, a UGMA account that is converted into a 529 account will be assessed at the parents’ rate even though it is owned by the kid. It’s a loophole they haven’t gotten around to closing, and probably never will.</p>

<p>^^^but an UGMA legally converts to the kid when he turns 18. He wants to buy a car? It’s his money, and you can’t stop him. Not so with a 529 plan.</p>

<p>^ And a 529 owned by the parent can be reassigned to another kid (or other family member) if kid #1 ends up not going to college for whatever reason. Not so an UGMA which is kid #1’s money.</p>

<p>re: UGMA

  1. Kid got to discover that there is an UGMA
  2. Kid may have to fight for the UGMA
  3. If the parents can’t recognize the danger signals in kid mis-using newly found $, then parents need to get to know their children better.
  4. As custodian you can lock funds up.
  5. 529 is a terminal decision for a family with only one child. The exception is to use funds funds for close relative or for possible grandchildren.
  6. Keep as many options open for as long as possible.</p>

<p>Bclintonk in post 37 gives the best advice. Really. Stop treating it as though it has to be done and over with 18 years before the fact. Invest wisely, stay flexible and add on periodically (monthly, annually, whatever works best).</p>

<p>

If the OP’s philosophy is to pay for most but not all of college, then aiming to have 75% of the COA of an in-state public school saved may work for his kid. IMO, we didn’t want to restrict our kids to just public or instate schools and our philosophy was to pay for undergrad. That said, we certainly encouraged them to seek institution based and outside merit money. We saved in many different areas, but only one (the 529) was specifically earmarked for college. DH had savings and investments identified for each kid’s education through UGMA (eg USAA income fund) And when the kids went to school we paid from these funds and the rest for liquid income/$.</p>

<p>We added to our retirement and to their college funds every year. Worked for us.</p>

<p>As an aside, not understanding this statement, artlovesplus:

I thought you’ve mentioned your d is at UofC. Its certainly plenty costly, but per this, its cost (room&board) comes in at # 28 of the top 100: [CampusGrotto</a> - Most Expensive Colleges for 2009-2010](<a href=“http://www.campusgrotto.com/most-expensive-colleges-for-2009-2010.html]CampusGrotto”>America's Most Expensive Colleges - CampusGrotto)</p>

<p>Highest Total Cost 2009-2010
Total Cost = Tuition + Room/Board </p>

<p>College Cost

  1. Sarah Lawrence College $54,410
  2. New York University $51,991
  3. The George Washington University $51,730
  4. Bates College $51,300
  5. Skidmore College $51,196
  6. Johns Hopkins University $51,190
  7. Georgetown University $51,122
  8. Connecticut College $51,115
  9. Harvey Mudd College $51,037
  10. Vassar College $50,875
  11. Wesleyan University $50,862
  12. Claremont McKenna College $50,800
  13. Colgate University $50,660
  14. Carnegie Mellon University $50,640
  15. Haverford College $50,625
  16. Bowdoin College $50,485
  17. Middlebury College $50,400
  18. Mount Holyoke College $50,390
  19. Bard College $50,380
  20. Boston College $50,370
  21. Franklin & Marshall College $50,360
  22. Bard College at Simon’s Rock $50,340
  23. Scripps College $50,336
  24. Babson College $50,324
  25. Colby College $50,320
  26. Vanderbilt University $50,282
  27. Duke University $50,250
  28. University of Chicago $50,247
  29. Tufts University $50,178
  30. Oberlin College $50,166
  31. Smith College $50,132
  32. Cornell University $50,114
  33. Bucknell University $50,098
  34. University of Southern California $50,028
  35. Union College (NY) $49,983
  36. Dartmouth College $49,974
  37. Carleton College $49,974
  38. Dickinson College $49,860
  39. Washington University in St. Louis $49,860
  40. Bennington College $49,830
  41. Eugene Lang College $49,800
  42. Stevens Institute of Technology $49,800
  43. Northwestern University $49,791
  44. Boston University $49,758
  45. Reed College $49,690
  46. St. Lawrence University $49,680
  47. Fordham University - Lincoln Center $49,655
  48. Williams College $49,640
  49. Franklin W. Olin College of Engineering $49,630
  50. Wellesley College $49,612
  51. St. John’s College $49,592
  52. Hampshire College $49,545
  53. Fordham University - Rose Hill $49,541
  54. Columbia University $49,524
  55. Hamilton College $49,470
  56. Trinity College (CT) $49,460
  57. Drexel University $49,381
  58. Barnard College $49,372
  59. Pomona College $49,361
  60. Lafayette College $49,319
  61. Swarthmore College $49,250
  62. Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute $49,245
  63. Chapman University $49,174
  64. Hobart and William Smith College $49,168
  65. Wheaton College (MA) $49,155
  66. Bryn Mawr College $49,120
  67. University of Rochester $49,070
  68. MIT $48,870
  69. University of Notre Dame $48,850
  70. Stanford University $48,843
  71. College of the Holy Cross $48,800
  72. Occidental College $48,750
  73. Villanova University $48,750
  74. Pepperdine University $48,630
  75. Wake Forest University $48,618
  76. Lehigh University $48,530
  77. University of Richmond $48,490
  78. Amherst College $48,400
  79. Emory University $48,396
  80. Brandeis University $48,368
  81. Brown University $48,328
  82. Fairfield University $48,170
  83. University of San Diego $48,072
  84. Gettysburg College $48,060
  85. Worcester Polytechnic Institute $48,050
  86. Ursinus College $47,750
  87. Drew University $47,678
  88. Rollins College $47,540
  89. Yale University $47,500
  90. Santa Clara University $47,400
  91. American University $47,386
  92. Pitzer College $47,278
  93. Loyola University Maryland $47,190
  94. Washington and Lee University $47,165
  95. Kenyon College $47,070
  96. Princeton University $47,020
  97. Macalester College $46,942
  98. Colorado College $46,902
  99. Loyola Marymount University $46,880
  100. Northeastern University $46,860</p>

<p>And don’t forget to sign up for Upromise and Babymint. Free money is great. may not be a lot based on how you use the account, but its free <a href=“http://collegesavings.about.com/od/otherfundingsources/a/partnerprograms.htm[/url]”>http://collegesavings.about.com/od/otherfundingsources/a/partnerprograms.htm&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>No, it’s not a “terminal” decision. The money is there and can be used for any purpose. If used for non-education purpose, there are penalties. Many people say appreciation of the assets tax-deferred more than pays for the cost of the penalty.</p>

<p>babyontheway, good for you. We also saved quite a bit for our children’s education, started when they were born. We were pretty clear we were not going to get need based aid and considered it our job to pay for their schooling. Both of ours ended up with merit money which made the COA about the same as the state schools. We were told when they were about ten that we had saved enough. Then the return rates dropped off and the COAs did not. Long story short we ended up with a legal settlement on a business related matter. Put the money aside and used both it and the savings to pay for both to finish private school with NO debt.<br>
Oldest just finished and is saving on his own for grad school.<br>
I disagree with the idea that you shouldn’t save because it hurts your FA ability. The money you have saved was saved for college costs and it should be used for those costs. I have had people ask me how to hide those funds so they can get need based FA. Give me a break.</p>

<p>

Not true.</p>

<p>You can take back the money at any time. But the gains will be treated as ordinary income and taxed, and you will pay a 10% penalty, except under certain conditions:</p>

<p>

[What</a> is the penalty on an unused 529 plan?](<a href=“What is the Penalty on 529 Plan Withdrawals for Non-Qualified Expenses? - Savingforcollege.com”>What is the Penalty on 529 Plan Withdrawals for Non-Qualified Expenses? - Savingforcollege.com)</p>

<p>Come on, JYM, I just wrote the check for the “college bill” portion and it came out around $19,000/quater already. Add the book cost(2 books from mail order for $320, more to come) and the move in/move out cost, vacation airfare, storage over the summer and personal costs, it is going to be way over 60K/year. You really don’t have to show me a table from some theoratical calculation by a reporter.</p>

<p>Our total move in travling/lodging/food cost plus things we needed to buy locally, monitor, shampoo, hangers, storage boxes and such is over $3,000. Tell me it is not expensive. And we did stayed in hostels on campus, the first ever experience after the college.</p>

<p>Come on yourself, artloversplus. I am not disputing what your total out of pocket expenses might be. We all pay travel, books, storage, health service and student activities fees, supplies, hangers, etc etc in addition to tuition, room and board. But you claimed that your dau was at “the most expensive college” and that simply isn’t true. I was actually pleasantly surprised to not see my younger s’s school on that list. His tuition alone is 38,300 this year. Fortunately, his merit scholarship pays it.</p>

<p>According to this [Tuition</a> to increase 4.2 percent next academicyear - The Chicago Maroon](<a href=“Rambling and flat, this family turmoil doesn’t amount to a handful of cherries – Chicago Maroon”>Rambling and flat, this family turmoil doesn’t amount to a handful of cherries – Chicago Maroon) tuition is 40K. If you pay $19K a quarter, you’d be paying 57K for 3 quarters (assuming your D isn’t going in the summer) for the “college bill”. Is that correct? Did you have to pay for health insurance through the university as opposed to your child having it through your employer? That is expensive for sure, but is a separate cost. U of C is expensive- no question, its just not THE most expensive, as you claimed, and I disputed. You should be happy with that :)</p>