OP: Do you have access to a copy of the Fiske Guide To Colleges 2020 ?
If so, read the sections on Northwestern University then the sections covering Haverford College / Bryn Mawr College.
OP: Do you have access to a copy of the Fiske Guide To Colleges 2020 ?
If so, read the sections on Northwestern University then the sections covering Haverford College / Bryn Mawr College.
“The academics at Haverford are demanding and top notch but the school is structured to minimize competition.”
You can say that about a lot of schools though, including Northwestern, but once you get into pre-med or engineering at NU, it does get competitive.
Anyway I saw a good suggestion that given campuses being shut down, the virtual tours along and checking out the online student papers could give a good feel of both campuses.
So I the question seems to be: “How does H structure its academics to minimize competition?” How does that effort differ from other schools?
I can’t speak about NW practices to lower competition as I haven’t heard of those efforts. You might be the expert on that end of things @theloniusmonk
H/BMC both have explicitly set up campus cultures to lower stress. They differ slightly in how this occurs but the broad outline is the same. They both have honor codes based in the Quaker tradition (though BMC is no longer formally Quaker). The tradition holds that each person is responsible for his or herself. And they take this seriously. And it lowers stress. There’s no one checking on you that you’re cheating or dishonest.
A quorum of students decides each year on the honor code specifics but generally they students agree (and some other person please correct the nuances of my language because they may still have a student who’s actively involved in this currently!) not to compete with each other, and to take exams and do papers through self-supervision. There are no proctors for exams. Exams, if I’m remembering correctly, take three or four forms. Some are take-home and the time to complete these tasks could be hours or days and the exams can sometimes turn into projects. The materials allowed are explained and students are expected to use only those materials. Another form of exams–the student picks up an exam, signs it out, takes it to an “exam room” in which several other students may or may not be taking the same exam. There’s no supervision. They time themselves, and agree not to cheat in any way. A third type, exams are left in a hallway outside the prof’s door. The students when they’re ready pick up the exam and return it to the folder under their name–no one checks on them to ensure they are complying. They just do it on their own. All of the students have folders in teh hallway and everyone agrees not to look at other student’s work or materials not allowed, as stipulated on the exam. There are other forms of this but in a nutshell the students largely self-schedule exams, self-monitor time and materials they can use, and generally this works out as planned. If there’s question of cheating, then the student government has a protocol that can be followed but this rarely occurs.
This structure lowers stress because of self-scheduling, everyone doing things at their own pace – no 300 students all breathing heavily in a single room; students don’t as a rule compare who scored what on an exam or final paper, etc. This culture allows students to learn for learning’s sake and not to compete with others.
The students agree to this when they start the year. This is the opposite of cut-throat.
Personally when I am on campus the relaxation is palpable. This culture extends way beyond the exam culture and you feel it everywhere–people leave their stuff around and it doesn’t get stolen. People leave dorm rooms open. There are no RAs checking up that you’re not doing things in teh dorms that aren’t allowed. It’s all about personal responsibility and generally it seems to work.
“I can’t speak about NW practices to lower competition as I haven’t heard of those efforts. You might be the expert on that end of things @theloniusmonk”
It wasn’t anything to do with NW reducing stress, just the nature of stem vs. non-stem. I know a few non-STEM students/alum from NW, they said it wasn’t that competitive, if at all. Yes the professors had high standards and the kids worked hard. However STEM, again pre-med, engineering is inherently more competitive. I know it’s similar if the not same at local schools, Berkeley, Stanford, Santa Clara et al.
“This structure lowers stress because of self-scheduling, everyone doing things at their own pace – no 300 students all breathing heavily in a single room;”
It would be really hard to avoid those large classes in introductory subjects like calculus, chem, English computer science, even at smaller schools like Northwestern and Stanford, agree there. Smaller colleges like St. Marys or Santa Clara, you would be able to avoid >100 size classes freshman year.
I am currently trying to transfer out of Haverford, BUT for pre-med I have to admit that it takes the cake! The professors care so much and the students are ALWAYS working together. 
@mlplover69: Interesting post.
If I may ask, why are you trying to transfer out ?
P.S. I read your prior posts in the transfer thread. Were you admitted to Northwestern ? BU ? USC ?
OP: Both Northwestern University & Haverford College have incredibly high retention rates (NU at 98% and HC at 97%). (USC = 96% & BU = 93% if curious.)
P.P.S. Okay, after reading all of your prior posts, I understand. Tough to give up a full ride to Haverford so it must have been a mismatch which is not uncommon with QB.
I think that your experience could be very helpful to OP.
Another real plus to Haverford, IMO, is the very high level of student driven governance. It’s really refreshing and is part and parcel with the importance of the Haverford Honor Code. It does make Haverford unique, IMO. The only other school I can think of that comes close is Grinnell.
@Publisher LOL I wasn’t expecting all of that! I’ve gotten into BU so far and USC requested for my spring grades. My college journey has been different from most people but overall, Haverford wasn’t a good fit for me. I LOVED my friends there and my professors were amazing (I still email them), but fit wise and what I wanted to study…it just wasn’t for me unfortunately. However, I do plan on visiting whenever I get the chance! I never hated it, but like you said it was just a mismatch.
Appreciate your diplomacy.
Nevertheless, I think that OP has two very different options and I was hoping that your experience could shed some light.
Thanks for replying to my question.