It’s Benacquisto, and a very good deal. I like USF a lot. It is know for medical fields.
I don’t think your not having a job helps or hurts the FAFSA only schools since you are the NCP. Father’s income may take her out of the Pell awards and she could lost that.
I’d stay away from NYU. They are not known for good financial aid.
At USC, the merit scholarship will remain. I don’t know if a $25k income increase will changed the need based aid much. Since you also had an income decrease.
I’d take the sure money.