There is no question that Colgate and Union do not “halve” the contribution when there are two in college. Profile Schools for two would have each at about 60% of what one would have paid. But of course, the formulas vary wildly.
If you read my post 4, You will see that I agree with what you wrote for this student.
I d think that there were two kids in college at the same time did increase need based aid…as you noted @OHMomof2
I’m not sure we are disagreeing…but my point is…with two in college aid will be higher than with one at schools that guarantee to meet full need.