S25 looked seriously at Hillsdale, he was very impressed with the academics and did a summer program with them that was fantastic. He decided in the end (I think, he still waffles and may throw in a last minute app) that he didn’t want to discuss politics for four years, he is in general looking for a less politically charged atmosphere - on either side. Also, Michigan is cold 
That said, I was worried about job and grad school prospects as well and did kind of a deep dive into their outcomes and they were great, for business at least. I agree with asking for med school acceptance rates/placement and also the number of students applying every year, it appears that it may not be very many.
Best of luck!
ETA - if you click through to the pdf placement reports there’s more extensive information.