How close was your actual offer to the NPC?

Ithaca came up 5k short of what the NPC predicted. We are married, with no unusual circumstances. It predicted 28k in scholarships/grants. The actual package was a 15K scholarship and an 8k grant. McDaniel, a CTCL school with a much lower student population, offered 33k total (and the COA is 5k lower to begin with). I don’t think they’ll care what McDaniel offered, but it was worth a try. A few thousand could bring it within reach. My wife and I don’t think Ithaca is the better fit, but if it turns out to be affordable we won’t say no.