How to Establish Instate Residency in OH (previously was - Why I got rejected)

Yes full ride. Do they have your major or major of interest.

Full ride is good. ASU is good. Maybe even some credits can transfer.

You’re able to take her to class with you? That’s awesome if they allow it, but make sure (in writing) that they will allow it. You don’t want to go into anything without being sure.

2 Likes

Did you take her to classes at tOSU? If not, why would that need to start now.

At Case Western, it doesn’t matter that you are instate or not.
It’s a good sign they told you to reactivate your application and follow the streamlined “reapply” system. Your tOSU 4.0 will go a long way.
If you get into CWRU it’d likely be much cheaper than tOSU OOS and much faster for you, with no uncertainty wrt E1->C2. Would you be able to move to Cleveland with your mom?

Forget tOSU. Focus on other opportunities, starting with Case.

Once that’s solved, follow the UI/UX path if that’s the one you’re interested in - there should some overlap with CS anyway. Working in the private sector & in Tech with a STEM major then switching to teaching by earning a certificate is easier than starting as a STEM educator then earning a new major and trying to break into Tech.

Wright State and Cleveland State are equivalent. Whichever is cheaper and/or allows you to apply to honors or already admitted you to Honors for special access/opportunities, would be best for you if Case doesn’t work out.
Cincinnati is a bit better than either of those (a notch below tOSU which itself is a notch below Case/Denison - I specify since you’re concerned about rigor and reputation but all would be fine) and had the co-op system but were you admitted with instate tuition and to CS co-op (or did you not apply to co-op because of your mom)?

3 Likes

OP- the world is filled with successful and happy people who had some speedbumps on their way to getting an education. You are not behind in any way- you are figuring out how to make lemonade out of the lemons you have in front of you.

How disabled is your mom that she needs to attend classes with you? I’m not sure that’s a viable plan. Some of your classes are likely to require labs, a seminar, a breakout group of 5 students to work on a project, etc. It’s one thing for a professor to allow a visitor in a lecture hall of 100 students, but not sure about a small work room situation. But for sure you should discuss this with your admissions rep.

You’ve got this. Seems like you have some affordable options-- which is great. Don’t get caught up in the prestige game- every single one of these (including the online ASU program) can get you where you want to go. And so sorting out the lifestyle issues, your mom’s medical needs, etc. is more important than parsing the miniscule differences between one university and the next.

Good luck!

6 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.

Hi everyone,

I wanted to post an update since it’s been almost a year since my last post, and unfortunately, I’m still stuck in the same situation with Ohio State University (OSU).

Last year, I shared my story about trying to get in-state residency. I came from Palestine in 2023 because of the war, and since then, I’ve only lived in Ohio. I have a U.S. passport, and my entire family are U.S. citizens too. We came here legally and permanently this is home.

I’ve been doing everything alone. I’m the only English speaker in my family, and I take care of an elderly and disabled family member. I move between two homes to help them with daily needs and appointments while working and studying at the same time.

When I first applied to OSU, they mistakenly listed me as an international student, even though my Common App was filled out correctly. Later, they changed it to “domestic out-of-state”

Since then, I’ve done everything they told me to do.

I moved into my own place, put everything under my name, sent proof of employment and self-employment, and explained that my tutoring income is real and will be filed on my 2025 tax return (Schedule C) once the IRS releases it. But they keep saying that because it’s not taxed yet, it doesn’t count.

They also told me that they couldn’t even review my residency unless I was registered for classes, so I registered and then they denied me, saying my income wasn’t enough to cover tuition. That doesn’t make any sense because the only reason I registered was to allow them to review my file.

I also sent my car registration to prove that I’m financially responsible for my vehicle. Now they’re asking for the car title, but that’s impossible I’m still making payments, and the bank legally holds the title until the loan is fully paid off. I already provided proof of the payments, but they said it’s not enough.

I meet every requirement; they just keep finding new excuses. Every time they deny me and ask for more documentation and I’m tried of this

I’m independent for financial aid purposes, and I don’t get help from anyone. I pay for my rent, utilities, tuition, transportation everything from my own work and financial aid. But no matter what I show them, they keep saying it’s “not enough.”

I also changed my major to a program that’s only offered at OSU. I could technically transfer to Cleveland State or a university an hour away, but I can’t leave my family. They depend on me every day, and changing to another major just to move would destroy everything I’ve worked for. Because that is my passion

I’m almost 20 and I’m still stuck I feel I’m in the same circle I’m not moving any forward in my life i am stuck

Now it’s even worse spring classes are already full, and I know I won’t be able to register anyway because of my balance and residency status. I feel completely stuck. That is exactly what happened last year and I dropped my spring classes

And my new major is very competitive and has yearly admission so dropping one semester = one year late

I honestly don’t know what to do anymore.

Should I drop all my classes and stop, or should I keep going even though I know I won’t be able to register for spring or get my transcript? I’m scared of making the wrong choice

I know online advice can only go so far, but I don’t know who else to ask.

I’ve never lived in another state.

I live here, work here, study here, and take care of my family here.

Ohio is my home.

2 Likes

Have you met the minimum time required for residency ?

Are you a registered voter ?

There has to be someone in the department to help you. Obviously on this end, no one can help you but they must have an office person who can explain to you your shortfall.

Have you filled this out ? This should tell you if you are a resident or not by their meaning.

In theory, you could be stateless.

Do you have to show taxes paid for an entire year (some require that)? Are you on your parents’ health insurance? All of my kids paid for a couple of years tuition and rent, but couldn’t be independent due to being on our health insurance and because we co-signed loans.

I lived in ohio for like 2 years

1-Yes I filled taxes

2- I have Medicaid

3- I’m independent parents divorced live with one of them who has mental disabilities and I’m taking care of her t

This doesn’t necessarily mean you are legally independent.

Someone in the office of residency can tell you wjy you don’t qualify.

Fill out the worksheet I linked.

There’s something you are missing.

Unless you are paying all your own bills (rent, food, etc) I don’t think you are independent. Are utility bills in your name, etc?

1 Like

Are you over age 24? Where do your parents reside? Just because you pay all of your own bills does not make you eligible for instate status…for college tuition purposes

Are you currently enrolled in college? If so…where? If in Ohio, it is very difficult to establish residency for instate status if you are already enrolled as a college student there.

IIRC, one of the places you lived was not in Ohio. Is that correct?

As I suggested a year ago (I think) you need to reach out to a law clinic at a law school near you. They sound dodgy but they are not- they are staffed by law students and supervised by professors AND by working lawyers. You need an Immigration clinic (every law school has one right now given what is going on nationally) and you need an intrepid law student/law professor to walk you through the process and go to bat for you. If there is something missing, they will find it. If there’s something you need to do, they will tell you.

Don’t keep spinning your wheels.

However- may I suggest a little flexibility regarding your major? If shifting a bit gives you other options– it’s worth considering. There are very few majors which are so foundational that you cannot enter the field without that specific major. Math majors get jobs as actuaries. Mechanical engineers get jobs in aerospace. Psych majors get jobs in market research. Etc.

Remind us what it is you want to do eventually?

4 Likes

OK here’s what I understand from this very lengthy post (and I’m going to refer to the similarities between California residency and your residency in the Ohio State University system.)

When a student arrives from overseas, and establishes citizenship in the US, if that child did not attend high school in the US, then the university relies on an “out-of-state” transcript.

If you have an “out of country” transcript, and you if you begin school immediately, like a community college, you pay out of state tuition because public colleges rely on taxpayer funds and you did not attend HS in the US. Your parents weren’t paying into the “system” for the state, so you pay the difference. Your uncle was not your parent, so the school couldn’t use his funding base.

In California, for residency purposes, you would be designated as an out of state domestic student. If you continued, as an out of state community college student, to transfer, then you would also be designated as an out of state university student at the public college. Why? Because in our state, you have to work full-time, for at least a year, contributing tax income to our state.

You cannot begin a public school education, immediately, because that indicates that you are in the state for educational purposes (which means out of state fees).

Now here’s the trick: when students move, with their working parents, to California, the parents begin earning income, working full-time in California, contributing to the state in their taxes. Such that, their children can attend a public university, in California, but that first year they will pay out of state residency fees.

In California, we have something called the residency determination date. That is the day that the student enters California, and their parents begin working. Throughout the year, the parents have received drivers’ licenses, are paying full rent or mortgage, with taxes going to the state. The parents have documented proof that they are in the state to work. They have kept proof of monthly utility, and mortgage or rents with educational receipts.

A lot of states have copied the rules that California has set, for non-residents attempting to get into their public universities.

Your issue is that you were considered out of state because you immediately went to school in Ohio. Your previous high school experience was outside of the state. So, although you are a citizen, you weren’t a resident of Ohio, before you attended their public system.

I understand that you didn’t know. No one does, initially. But you complicated matters by not indicating that you resided with your parent.

It didn’t matter that your uncle paid your costs; you still resided with your parent.

Then you indicated that you were a foster child. You didn’t know that the term, “foster child” in the US, typically means that you don’t reside with a parent and it is a “government label” provided by Social Services. It’s not something that you can categorize yourself. The university can find your foster care “number”.

Then, your uncle, provided financial support and was not your legal parent, nor guardian.

So now your residency determination officer has a file with a number of inconsistencies based on their viewpoint.

You still haven’t worked, full-time for a year, without attending a school.

You need documented proof of residency with the date that you begin working full-time for 366 days.

You need to keep every paystub for those 366 days.

You need to keep every rent and utility payment for a year. You can probably live with your mom but you need to take over her rent payments. Edited to add: your name must be on the rent or mortgage receipt as payor. That means get a checkbook or have the lease changed to your name.

And remember, you have to do this for a year, without taking one class.

This is what we do in California. You have to go to or find the “residency determination office” at the Ohio State University and ask about their requirements. Don’t guess! Follow their printed checklist.

There are no guarantees because your file has been really inconsistent. If you can’t afford the Ohio State University, then find a place where you can afford to attend. You seem to be on a prestige hunt. In the US, it doesn’t matter, especially for CS!

4 Likes

Did you claim your mom as your dependent on your tax return?

Did anyone claim you as a dependent on their taxes, and if so…who did?

1 Like

What you are asking for is a change from OOS status to instate statue for tuition purposes.

As an already enrolled student, this requested change will be very challenging to get.

I’m having trouble understanding how you are considered independent for financial aid and tuition purposes.

You can be considered a resident of a state by having a job, drivers license, voter registration, paying all your bills. But these are not the test for instate tuition status if you are not an independent student as defined by the college/state. In the very vast majority of cases, undergrad students are dependent students for financial aid for tuition purposes.

1 Like

I agree, but if her parent she lives with is an Ohio resident, she should still be instate for tuition purposes, just not automatically for FAFSA purposes. She still might get a good deal of aid from parent being unemployed.

I’d also show the school you are on medicaid. Medicaid will not require you to be a resident for a year (although if you qualified for it more than a year ago…) but it would be another ‘proof of residency’.

Some states give you the title to the vehicle with a lien on it, others actually have the bank hold the title. If the latter, the DVM would have a record of it for your registration.

Make an appointment with the tuition office. Show up with all your papers. See if the hang up is that they think you are still a dependent FOR RESIDENCY purposes (as opposed to TAX purposes, or FAFSA purposes) and if so, show them all the papers of the parent who claimed you on their taxes last year If no one claimed you, show the parent who could have claimed you, but didn’t, tax return.

1 Like