Huge EFC - Help!

Well, you should really start your own thread instead of hijacking the OP’s. Do you have a second home? Rental properties? Is the $160 total gross or AGI? What’s the university? What is the form of the $5k in financial aid – a loan or a grant?

If you input all the numbers correctly in the NPC and the CSS, then, yes, you should definitely appeal. All colleges have a formal appeals process. Be very, very polite. Ask why the actual award given differs from the NPC.