I desperately need help choosing!! UCSB vs UW Seattle Honors vs Lehigh vs Bryn Mawr (plus some more)

Based on what you wrote you are looking at a long haul past undergrad in either med school or pursuing an MPH (or both). That means more years of expensive professional grad school after you graduate. Or if you want to stay in the humanities, expensive MA/PhD routes in a field that doesn’t generally give a lot of grad student support compared to the hard sciences. I would save the enormous amount of money that you’ll save in-state at UW so you don’t have to go into enormous debt for med school or grads school.

UW has one of the very best schools of public health on the planet. And one of the most comprehensive and diverse set of offerings in the health sciences of anyplace on the planet from nursing to med school to public health to research sciences like molecular biology and virology. You will have none of that at the typical small liberal arts college like Bryn Mawr or Mount Holyoke.

I would say that if you want to stay on the west coast after college then think hard about UW. If you want to be a northeaster and end up in the DC/NYC/Boston corridor then go east for college.

MHC is more internationally minded and has a more “self contained” campus as if it were its own village sort of. It’s also further away from the other universities in the consortium, but the universities in the consortium provide maximum diversity, from the traditional public flagship to the hippie haven to elite NESCAC and another Seven Sister.

Bryn Mawr and Haverford are known for their honor code, taken very seriously. There’s a philosophy of honesty and frank discussion that permeates everything.
The campuses are beautiful and the city easy to access. Most activities take place on campus though - the city is just an option (they’re not urban campuses.)

Neither MHC nor Bryn Mawr are as intense as Wellesley, or even Smith. They’re not mellow though. The women who attend have wishes for what they want their lives to be and don’t want to sit iddly hoping that’ll miraculously “happen”, but are ready to work to make the wishes come true. I don’t know if that makes sense to you?

UWS Honors would be a good choice, except they’re very explicit that a student should NOT choose them if they expect “a small college in a large university”. That’s not what they’re about. And the cut-throat competition in STEM is due to the breadth of talent and the neccessary culling to match numbers of students to numbers of places in the different majors and fields. As a result, based on what you said mattered to you, and if other colleges are affordable, I wouldn’t think UWS Honors is a good fit.

OP, @MYOS1634 is one of the most authoritative and knowledgeable voices on this whole website. You can be assured that she knows of what she speaks.

FWIW, I think MHC is a little more alternative in vibe than Bryn Mawr, but I am not an expert.

Different perspectives & different experiences should be respected.

If there was a badge for “Diplomacy & Officiating”, it would go to @MYOS1634.

@MYOS1634 Yes, I totally get what you’re saying about MHC and BMC students working hard towards attaining their goals and I definitely think that’s an attitude I would really enjoy being around in college. I also do like the part about MHC’s consortium being a bit more diverse since it kind of sounds like BMC and Haverford (and even Swarthmore to an extent) are all pretty similar in terms of school culture/values and I kind of get the idea that Penn’s role in the consortium is more separated than they try to make it seem. And I also agree about UW Honors; while on paper UW sounds like a good option in many respects for me simply due to the STEM opportunities and cost, and I do understand why it’s as cutthroat in STEM as it is, I just have a lot of reservations about it being the right fit for me personally. Also thank you so much for taking the time to write down all these insights for me about all of these schools; it’s been super helpful!

@maddie99: You need to deposit somewhere in the next two days if I understand correctly your situation.

Don’t panic.

You may be admitted to Scripps from the waitlist–especially if not in need of financial aid & if your letter-of-continued interest indicates that “if accepted to Scripps College, I will attend.”

It is okay to deposit at any school which has accepted you, then go to a different school which accepted you off of the waitlist.

@Publisher Thank you for all your comments; it’s been an enormous help! (And everyone else who commented too, of course!) I think after all the insights on this thread, I have it narrowed down to Bryn Mawr, Mount Holyoke or possibly UW for a school to commit to by May 1. All things considered, Scripps does sound like it would probably be the best fit and a good compromise between the bigger schools I’m looking at and the LAC-type ones, so I’ll see what happens with that in the coming weeks!

@maddie99: All are outstanding schools.

Average first year retention is very good at Bryn Mawr (93%) & at Mount Holyoke (91%).

Excellent at UW-Seattle (94%).

When considering LACs, fit is of critical importance due to the small size of the student body.

Based on your answers, you seem to be a fit for the all female schools. And, of course, UW-Seattle Honors should be an easy fit. But, you may need a change of scenery from the Pacific Northwest.

Life is, in large part, about choices & decisions. Sometimes one can have too many options. Whatever decision you make, you will have an exciting first year at college.

To me, it’s a lot less complicated than it appears.

If cost is a concern (and it always should be considering you have med school ahead of you), UW Honors is a bargain and a cool school with excellent professors, but don’t go if you really really want to get away from home.

If cost isn’t a concern, and you want a school a bit more socially active and liberal, UCSB. Love that campus, it’s in an ideal location, and the professors are supposedly great. You can avoid partying without a lot of effort I’ve heard. But it’s a bigger school and you likely will have TAs instead of professors.

If cost also isn’t a concern, and you want quieter, UCSD. For my tastes, it’s a bit boring, but the weather is nice. There is a bent towards science, and you are surrounded by biotech companies in La Jolla and San Diego. But it is called UC Socially Dead for a reason. My impression is students are more introverted.

If you want more attention, smaller class sizes, and professors instead of TAs, Bryn Mawr is it. It’s far from you, and women only, so if either is a concern, don’t go there.

No reason to pick Davis over UCSB and UCSD, although I like it better than UCSD. But you’re focusing on science so San Diego is better.

Take another look at schools on niche. I find their rankings are really accurate.

UCSB is too laid back (not very academically oriented) for this student, IMO. I personally don’t think UCSD is anything special. For the money, I would far prefer to see her at UW than pay high OOS fees.

I also think MHC might offer you a little more of the diversity it seems you would enjoy.

I agree with your assessment: “it kind of sounds like BMC and Haverford (and even Swarthmore to an extent) are all pretty similar in terms of school culture/values and I kind of get the idea that Penn’s role in the consortium is more separated than they try to make it seem.”

MHC isn’t totally in the boonies. I do think BM might be a bit stronger for science. But again, how important is your sport?

Re Scripps, if your LOCI indicated you will attend if accepted, you have a better chance of getting off waitlist. And of course, financial status might affect WL too. Overall, it seems you might thrive at a women’s college. Good luck.

I can see why Scripps is a favorite, given what you say you’re looking for. It would be a great place to pursue your breadth of interests while also preparing for the possibility of med school. The consortium is far more blended than any of its east coast counterparts, putting a larger co-ed community at your fingertips while still reaping the benefits of a women’s college. Plus it’s not all the way across the country. I hope the waitlist moves for you!

There are some majors/programs that I could see the appeal of UC OOS, but they’re such rough places for premed and don’t have the ease of exploring/changing majors and programs that an LAC would offer you. And there’s no equivalent of UW Honors on offer. UW Honors is a great program; my CA daughter would have happily chosen that over any UC. (UW was a runner-up to Scripps for her, even though she didn’t get into Honors.) A change of scene is nice but for double the price? UW won’t feel like you’re thrown in with all the same people from high school; it’s big enough to be a whole new world even though it’s not too far from home. And in these weird times, proximity to home could be really valuable - no travel worries, flexibility to get home as needed. I’d really try to dial down the familiarity-breeds-contempt effect and give UW Honors the consideration it deserves - the Honors program and housing really do sweeten the deal.

MHC and BM are great too, but I’m not sure you sound sold enough for the cost and the distance. I wouldn’t weight cross-reg at UPenn heavily AT ALL - it’s really not that easy in terms of scheduling and logistics. (cross-reg at Haverford is, of course, very easy and with Swarthmore is doable here and there, but UPenn is a project)

My inclination would be to deposit at UW and hold out for the west coast waitlist/appeal options that you are most hoping for, and of those I’d favor the privates over the OOS publics. Good luck!