I got in to Harvard but turned it down to go to ________________ because ________________.

@oyestershellatme Have you talked to your parents and the Financial aid office That is where I would start. If the cost is 35000 that probably means your parents make about 180000 per year. your parents should be willing to help a little. The financial aid office has been through this before and can give you some suggestions. They will try and make it happen

@florida26,

For upper middle income families living in high cost areas, Harvard can be prohibitively expensive. Financial aid phases out at about $250,000 with one child in college. That’s $65K to such a family. If you’re making that kind of money and living in Wyoming or Mississippi, you’re doing great. But if you’re 50 years old, finally making a few bucks, still paying off your own student loans, working in the NY metro area (or other high-cost metro areas), where a hut might cost $800K, then $65K is 26% of an already -stretched-too-thin income, especially after taxes.

These schools are great for poor people, and for people who are median income. These schools are great for people with really big bucks. They can suck for that slice of folks who are in the “doughnut hole.”

@oystershelleatme,

Good luck at IU. I know of some folks there. It’s a great school. Congratulations on your achievements so far, and your many more yet to come.

@florida26 Like I said, there are many reasons why I won’t be going to Harvard. Financial, being a major part of it, but not all of it. 35000 is only considering tuition. Adding room, board, and living expenses, it all adds up to some crazy amount that I can’t pay.
And yes, I did contact Harvard, but they weren’t willing to budge. I’m in an gray area were they can’t help me.

Plus I want to go to med/grad school, there is no point in being in debt at undergraduate. Also, IU’s environment is more nurturing and with the program I’m in, I know that I’ll have a good shot at getting a top 20 med/grad school. Harvard is too competitive for what I want now. Too cut throat.

@notjoe Thank you, I am excited for what is to follow :slight_smile:

If the cost to oyestershell is 35000 per year that is 140k over 4 years If the parents can contribute 12,500 per year that leaves a net of 90k for an amazing education and all the opportunities that can open up with it The 90k can be financed with student loans and other funding. I am sure if Harvard selected him they want to make it work. Visitas is next weekend. He should go and talk to the financial aid office Maybe something good can come out of it

@Florida12 *she

@florida26 I don’t want to go to harvard at this stage in my life, and that’s that.

MODERATOR’S NOTE: This thread is not the place to have back-and-forth conversations; that’s what PM’s are for. @oystershelleatme has provided reasons for not choosing Harvard. Period. End of discussion. Move on. Further posts which do not address the original question will be deleted.

Friend chose Vanderbilt/WashU over HYPS due to income levels/scholarships. He is a Siemens Finalist.

It sounds to me like @oystershelleatme is in this kind of “grey area”: parents make a bunch of money, but can’t or won’t pay more than a small amount towards the cost of attendance. If this is the case, and the student is required to take out loans, most posters on CC would agree that IU is the right choice. But Harvard is generally understood to give great need based aid to the middle/upper middle class.

@oystershelleatme sounds like you have other very good reasons for choosing IU, no need to defend those.

What has always interested me is that these boards are full of chat about people turning down Harvard for economic reasons, but Harvard’s yield rate remains sky-high. This year, fewer than 400 people anywhere are going to decline an offer of admission at Harvard, and all the evidence suggests that the vast, vast majority of those fewer-than-400 will be going to Yale, Stanford, Princeton, or MIT.

There is some urban legend and some cumulative effect over the years. If you stick to one year, you will see 300 people attending one of the 4 schools mentioned and the other 100 scattered throughout the country. If you ask someone who has seen kids make choices over a decade or longer, they may have come across lot more cases because there are over a 1000 kids who picked other schools. In Texas I have seen people pick Rice or Rice/Baylor, UT, and one famous case of someone moving from Michigan to go to Baylor over HY.

I’ve been waiting for over three months for clarification, and I can’t stand it any longer: The “clown school” referred to in Post #18, was it Cornell or Brown??

Sincerely,
~Curious in Peoria

^^ Totally agree with JHS

@moooop I live in Cambridge and know of a kid (from Cambridge) that got in to Harvard but left Sophomore year to go to actual Circus School. I think he initially wanted to defer for a year but ended up going for Freshman year and then left to join the circus, and is now back.

I suspect @nynyparent was being literal in post #18 and not making a snarky comment about other Ivies (or referring to the Ringling Animation/Graphic Design school).

My son got into Harvard this year and turned it down for Stanford, primarily because he’s planning to go into computer science. He met someone else recently who made the same decision this year, for the same reason. He also knows someone who turned down Harvard last year for Princeton, because it seemed like a better “fit.”

Girl at a local school was disappointed she had to go to Princeton. She didn’t get accepted at Harvard but wanted to go there over Princeton because Harvard was, according to her, “ranked higher.”.

I am reminded of the Mary Tyler Moore show episode where Murray was depressed and disappointed by where his life had ended up. He had a good job and a loving wife but still felt unfulfilled. And Lou Grant told him that even Carlo Ponti (Sophia Loren’s husband) probably had moments of despair, even though he slept.each night with the sexiest woman on the planet. In other words, no matter what u have, its human nature to want something.else.

S just picked Princeton over Harvard, but if it hadn’t been Princeton there were several schools still higher on his list than Harvard. It was never “the dream” for him, and even a likely letter didn’t elicit much excitement. He went to Visitas with an open mind, but still wasn’t inspired. When prefrosh and current students would ask in amazement how he could possibly even consider not choosing Harvard he would list the reasons, which would be countered with, “Yes, but it is HARVARD!”

@oystershelleatme, @florida26, @notjoe

This might seem late (after May 1st)…
I have been reading all these posts on CC, but this is first time posting…

If I am correct @florida26 is trying to help.
@notjoe has a great point in comparing income vs cost of living in certain High Cost area, especially with high mortgagee payment.

The fact is it wouldn’t hurt to ask Financial Aid office to reconsider and it is your responsibility to convince them…such as providing details of your family financial situation.

To All, It is my honor to say Harvard Financial Aid office is very reasonable and understanding. If you try, just like how you tried to get accepted to HYPSM. Harvard might just surprise you!!!