Indiana University Bloomington Early Action Class of 2030 Official Thread

Yes but if you look at it closely you are getting a BS in commerce or an MS in another field. It’s preparing you for Darden not a job in say finance.

If you wanna job in finance, marketing, etc and go to UVA you need to continue with Darden or another grad program.

No, that’s not accurate. Many McIntire grads go into finance jobs…IB, consulting, quant, non-IB banking, corp finance, etc.

Here are the details on job placements and internships.

The BS in commerce is the same as a BS in finance/another major, or a BBA. Different schools just call the degree different things. Generally, one needs 4+ years experience to be competitive for top MBA programs. It’s not advised that undergrads immediately go to an MBA program. Some would advise that a student with an undergrad business degree not do an MBA at all. IMO that depends on the student’s career progression and personal choice.

1 Like

Yes. They have direct admit but apparently also have a pretty large chunk who are internal transfers of existing students. Couldn’t find exact percentages, but estimates were like 55-60% / 45-40% so AI referred to it as a combination, favoring DA (by a little).

This is 100% correct. McIntire 100% prepares students for finance and IB jobs. But it is very risky going to UVA for business (commerce) though. Much riskier than going to IU as a pre-business major. Last year only 43% of applicants at UVA got into McIntire and there is no direct path, it’s a crapshoot who gets in and no one knows the formula. At least at IU, you know what you need to do to get into Kelley.

2 Likes

Hopefully your D will educate herself on her options. I posted the McIntire outcomes above. McIntire job placement is outstanding. But if you want McIntire you have to be ok with taking secondary admission risk.

ETA: For comparison, here are Kelley outcomes: https://careers.kelley.iu.edu/outcomes/

1 Like

I am a UVA alum and have family members who went to McIntire (referred to as the Comm school there). Just keep in mind the 43% is deceptively high. Kids who cannot maintain high grades their first year select themselves out so most of the applicants have top grades. I loved UVA but my son who only wants business didn’t want to take the risk so he is doing Kelley.

2 Likes

I don’t understand what you are disagreeing about. UVA McIntire is a top undergrad business school with similar outcomes to their peers, based on data/employer and industry hiring behaviors. It looks like 5% of grads went into marketing type roles with their BS in Commerce. It seems you are caught up in the name of the degree and/or your wife’s experience from decades ago (things are different now, I also worked for decades in the business world and have an M7 MBA.) I mean, just look at the data. Go to poets and quants to do more research. What is different compared to many of UVA’s peers is the holistic secondary admit to their undergrad business school.

1 Like

She is in HR and hires many candidates in the business field. It’s not decades ago.

I’ll say this, when she comes home after interviewing candidates there is a bias that she knows she shouldn’t have but schools have a culture that shows in young candidates. UVA produces serious kids. That matters. You can parse the degrees here and there but overall schools have a rep. However, some lack knowledge and its because of the program.

It’s a great school. Good luck

With respect to the eyeballs of all who are waiting for admissions answers regarding Kelley or other IU programs: please share feedback about UVA or Minnesota or other business schools on their respective boards. You can encourage ppl to follow those threads there. Or feel free to chat directly with those who’ve engaged in topics outside of IU Kelley. Thank you! And GOOOOO HOOSIERS! BRING HOME THE NATTY! :american_football:

2 Likes

I just wanna hear what people think about how fast the waitlist will move and when it will start

Thinking
If you are specific about Kelley responses?
One Factor: I would look at the EA decision dates from other fairly highly rated B-Schools to see which ones are still yet to release. There are quite a few still left to release in the next 2 weeks or so (for example UNC OOS EA and UIUC EA will likely release sometime between this Friday and next) - so I’d think within a week or two of that period, you might see some small movements but that also puts you into merit award release time period;

Some folks will wait until they have all their options on the table before starting to decline current offers / some folks will start to decline some offers once they have one, two or three offers which are more highly desirable before they will decline lower prioritized offers, and of course some people will have multiple offers, hold onto them until decision day on May 1st, and send in one deposit, allowing the other offers to ‘expire’ .

Two Factor: Kelley often offers quite a bit of merit to students who are DA (likely accepted in EA already), but it doesn’t look like this has release much if anything on merit awards yet (prior history is 2-4 weeks after acceptance) - so I suspect many will wait on that information before making any decisions. I think you might see some movement within a week or two of this information (if they don’t receive merit or enough merit they may be set to make a decision) But that time line is then 4-6 weeks away which puts you on top of;

Three Factor: Then the RD dates for alot of the Top 25 BSchools will be coming around, and students who were deferred EA at some schools (Like Texas deferred a lot of EA applicants to RD) or who only applied into RD will find out - and suspect you’ll see some movement within a week or two of that series of schools releases.

I suspect the biggest moves will actual occur after most T25 Bschools have released RD (2-4 weeks after) and before May 1st Decision day. I’m hopeful most T25 B-school kids and their parents are conscientious to understand how many people are waiting on Deferred, Wait List etc for highly valued spots to open up - and that once they make a solid decision they will only sit one the one school they are ‘certain’ they want to go to, and the second school they hold as a back up ‘just in case’ until May 1st and choose to declined options 3-4-5-6 etc pretty quickly. D26 has notified two schools already.

What you have to understand is that it’s not going to be a 1:1, you see somebody decline their offer and a waitlist spot gets offered an admissions - the admissions office sends out more acceptances than they will get accepted back, they know this - so they have a buffer of students that will need to say no first before the feel comfortable saying, okay lets turn over some new offers.

But thats just a guess.

2 Likes

Yep, sorry about that

Kelley will as always track Kelley DA Days attendance as a key factor to predicting yield and making waitlist moves.

2 Likes

Anyone have info on the LLC communities? Specifically the business one? Are the dorms dedicated to the LLC or just a portion?

I’m guessing there are no single sex dorms. Are they at least segregated by floor?

Some quieter than others? Any info would help.

My son Kelley DA is trying to register for DA day and it is saying he is not eligible. Any idea why this would be? He set up iu online account but it isn’t approved yet…

On Facebook they are saying it won’t open until Thursday

1 Like

Most floors are co-ed. If you are interested in single gender applying to Women in Stem may be a winner if looking for a girl only floor. The honors dorms are co-ed and not a quiet option shockily. The pod bathrooms are pretty nice.

Where on FB? Which page? Thanks!

Take it for what it is worth.

  • There will be limited waitlist movement. Kelley is trying to downsize a bit and they’d prefer anyone not direct admit to be part of pre-business versus add to auto class size. This is also a year they can afford a slightly lower yield as the GPA standard admit raises next year.

  • Kelley isn’t sure how to calculate yield this year. They were not planning to offer DA days, but now are. Why - to try to predict yield. Very unlikely to add anyone off waitlist prior to end of DA Days. I actually think they don’t care about other B-school admissions this year at all. That mattered in years prior when the auto-DA was a safety at IU.

  • They say Apr 17 (or whatever the decision date is) but that doesn’t mean they cannot add someone later. Those who they add will be those institutional priorities that are not reflected once they model yield and no reason to believe that will not be primarily women and a slight bit of geographical diversity as in the last few years. They add post-May 1 every single year as do many colleges now. And its ludicrous to think if you don’t major in Kelley you cannot do whatever you want in your career with whatever your major is.

  • This admissions change intends to up the admitted stats for ranking, lower the admit % for ranking, increase apps for ranking, improve yield modeling, and allow greater discretion for the class. That’s what the last 3 months of “holistic” was for. They admitted those who fit their goals. This doesn’t mean someone not admitted is not elite or not a great student. And this can be especially difficult for someone with amazing raw stats. The next 2 months is not to reexamine the waitlist as much as they may say its possible - it’s to enroll those admitted.

  • Financial aid is also being reimagined at IU. It’s hard not to feel wronged when the award is not what you might think makes it affordable. Nothing about this year will be similar to last. And welcome to OOS public school merit aid reality, they don’t care if its not affordable compared to your in-state. You are there to subsidize the in-state same as any big public.

  • The single biggest admissions event in IU history happened last night. Never every thought that would happen in my lifetime.

5 Likes

I’d add that many major employers that you’d assume are looking for business majors, don’t really care what kind of degree you have these days, just that you have a degree. I work for a major financial firm and most of our hiring is focused on “soft skills”…good problem solving skills, works well on a team, is resilient, has a desire and capacity to be a life long learner, is coachable and driven to succeed. We can teach them how to be marketers, analysts, financial writers, etc., but if they don’t have the soft skills, they are less likely to be successful. Most of the jobs these students will hold in their future careers don’t even exist yet or the way that job is done will change drastically. It’s far more important for them to learn to adapt to continuous change, be comfortable trying new things, be curious and be okay with failure…it’s how we learn and grow. I have a sociology degree and have worked in finance my entire career. We often times purposely hire people with unrelated degrees because broad perspective is valuable. All of our kids are going to be just fine no matter where they go to college!

4 Likes