Someone on Reddit emailed Poets and Quants and got this message:
This is the response I received from Poets&Quants:
Ours is an opt-in ranking meaning schools have to submit their data and administer our alumni survey to be ranked. Kelley opted not to participate this year.
Received an email on the 21st to register for the info session. Friday the 27th at 5:30pm. Registration closes tomorrow at noon so I would call if you are unsure. It was a “you applied” not accepted email so join us so to speak. However, she just heard a few hours ago she was accepted to Hutton.
She now isn’t sure she wants to do that or JLLC. So I guess that is why they are having these sessions.
Anyone have a kid go through the Hutton Honors College? Is it difficult, is there a benefit other than Briscoe and sign up for classes early. Is JLLC a better option?
My kid is finishing her first year in Hutton. There is no registration advantage for joining. To remain a member you have to keep your GPA above 3.5 and take 2 required honors classes at minimum to stay in the college. There are more requirements if you want to pursue the Honors notation.
She likes that she is eligible for honors sections that are smaller that the regular classes. She is also interested in the study abroad options and scholarships. She also has access to an honors advisor.
You can be in the Hutton Honors College and live in other learning communities or just the regular dorms. Being in the honors college just makes you eligible for the learning community.
My daughter will take her 2nd required class next fall. The areas she was interested in fit the required external minor/major requirement. She is pursuing a dual degree and an additional minor. If your kid is open to or interested in this, it is an easy fit. If not, it could be an undue burden.
Did anyone come across stats for this year’s admissions results at IU? Kelley aside, for the overall admission rate, was it still over 70%? Trying to figure out if this will be a target school for my S27 based on the most recent stats.
I think all the schools publish their CDSs mid-May to June. If you are unfamiliar just search the school name and CDS. It is a wealth of knowledge about each school so you can tailor the application to each one. What I have noticed, now that results are coming in for each school, are parents who say, “I don’t understand why my kid didn’t get in because they have XX SAT and XX GPA.” Not understanding there are other things that many schools value with equal importance. This year is my first year doing this with a student and it’s definitely not the 90s anymore. GPAs are ridiculously inflated around the country’s HSs and test scores are only just starting to be considered very important at schools again.
What my daughter did was arrange her EC’s to each school based on what they listed on the CDS as very important to not-considered in their admission process. Then submit and then re-arrange things then submit again. I don’t think many people do this or know that they can with the common app.
Also, realize IU is still test optional so their test scores are skewed far too high. Only 57% of kids submitted test scores. They publish their middle 50% at 1300. It’s inflated at every test optional school. Refer to the 2019 data to get a better idea but submitting or not submitting test scores not at the middle 50% number is tricky. Something to ask a counselor.
70% acceptance rate is pretty high and the 2025 CDS states they value GPA, rank, and rigor as most important followed by essay and test scores. So if the test score isn’t great make sure they write a great essay. Start early summer and polish polish polish. Don’t use AI. They will get caught and have their app thrown out. Spoke to an official at the DC IU event a couple weeks ago and they said they throw out more apps for AI use than any other reason. Virginia Tech started this year to actually use AI to read essays instead of a human. They used two humans last year and this year it’s one human and one AI reader. This is where every school is headed. With the number of applications reaching over 100k it’s difficult for these school’s AOs to keep up. So steer your student clear of it. It is very tempting to want to use it.
If you are on here researching you are ahead of the game. Good luck to your student.
This is a good idea, yet no one would ever know if it was important in the admissions decision or not. IME many application readers don’t consider activity #1 necessarily ‘better’ than #10. There are so many times I read an app and see an activity towards the bottom of the list and think to myself I would have led with that!
Well this is interesting, partially because AI detectors are less than accurate. Did they give the students a chance to demonstrate that it wasn’t AI, like the UCs do? I understand you might not have followed up with that question , but I believe that schools that are using AI in their process should make that public.
We have a relative who is a professor at a top 20 school and their university uses a proprietary AI detection for their current students. However, she says she doesn’t need it. After years of reading student papers it’s obvious to her which are AI. She said some are so blatant that the student just cuts and pastes the essay leaving in the prompt.
VT has gone public in a published article on their site. They stated they developed their own AI reader not detector. They stated they have been testing it over the course of a couple years and rolled it out this year. However, if AI is reading it and evaluating you can bet it is also detecting.
The IU people also didn’t state they used AI detectors. They also read thousands of essays and I’m sure to them it is obvious which are AI. However, I personally don’t believe that the AI detectors are not accurate. Even if the essay is just partially polished with AI. I have done quite a bit of testing with them and the accuracy is 99%. I put in works from famed authors to personal ones, to numerous obscure authors. Using AI to just change one sentence here or there and it’s picked up. These are just AI detectors available to the public. Add in the resources a university puts into developing their own and I’m certain they are doing the applications due diligence. AI is rapidly evolving in the time frame of months let alone years. The AI detectors and AI itself of just 6 months ago are completely different and 6 months from now will be equally changed. One thing is for certain there is too much cheating which is why the Ivy’s have moved to adding an unedited 90 second video submission called Glimpse. ND added it this year as an optional submission. I imagine all the schools will follow suit.
The reason I did all this research and testing is because I knew my kid was using it after proof reading her essays. They were so vastly different than her school work that it threw up a red flag. After confronting her and discussing that this is no different than cheating on a test she tossed them and started over. Wrote some great essays with hard work.
Just a few comments…I do think schools that are using AI to check essays should publicly say that. It’s tricky because some schools specifically allow AI to help brainstorm/structure one’s common app personal statement, while others don’t. It’s not dissimilar to what’s happening at many colleges where some profs allow AI and others don’t.
I agree about the fast changing of nature of AI, and how different things will look every six months. Regarding adding things like a glimpse video, that’s great, but takes time to review. I do wonder if they are all reviewed, or just for the relatively stronger apps. Seems easier to just not require a personal statement rather than adding additional app requirements.
For your research I will note a couple of things: I read apps and have no idea what is generated by AI and what is not. And, the highly esteemed peeps at my institution say they aren’t close to building a good in-house AI detector and/or transcript and application evaluator.
I was talking to my S27 about AI and college essays last night and mentioned that some colleges will start to use a video. He replied, “You just use AI beforehand to come up with the script and then record it. How is that different?”
He isn’t wrong. My daughter did the Glimpse video for Notre Dame and she needed to memorize a speech and it showed. She knew it was not great but she isn’t a ticktock social media person so it went against her I’m sure. You download an app and it lets you record as many times as you want before you submit. However, you cannot edit it so its a 90 second little elevator pitch.
I think it’s also another stupid money grab that appears to be the cottage industry of higher education. On the flip side, I also understand if it gets harder and harder for AOs to weed out quality applications and this could be just another tool to help them.
To bring all this back to IU and their 70% acceptance rate. Just keep in mind their CDS desires. That is the biggest thing that helped my daughter with applications. Not everything is GPA and SAT. Pay close attention to, “demonstrated interest.” IU doesn’t care but some schools care about this. We are told many are changing that on the CDS because people just spam email and call the school to get a tick mark next to their name. Purdue cares about this and so we did a tour, did a tour/interview with a business school person, and she hand wrote a letter to the AOs. We have no idea if it mattered but she was deferred then got in.
I am not sure how knowledgeable you are about this whole process. I’m trying to think back to this time last year and we barely started and my kid goes to a college prep school. We just got lucky she is a hard worker and is a leader in the things she enjoys. The whole thing was overwhelming us at the start because so many parents had a road map from freshman year till Junior year. We didn’t do anything or press her to do anything. Again, we just got lucky. Could she have gotten into a top top school if we did? Maybe but would she be happy? Most likely no.
If we had to do it all over again we would have had her study for the SAT/ACT long before she started and would probably had her take some summer classes or a tutor. About this point you are in I would have had her study for the SAT a hour a day over the summer before the August test date. Just target a test score for whatever school your son is shooting for. My daughter had no “dream school” so she just took the test a few times and at some point she said I cannot do this anymore.
This is my third kid so pretty familiar with the whole process and keeping his choices realistic. My older 2 were typical overachievers and learned through them that even a 4.0+ and a 35 ACT doesn’t necessarily get you into your reach schools (looking at you, UF and Wisconsin!).
Agree about the SAT/ACT studying and finally learned the 3rd time around. He studied all last summer (after Sophomore year) and took the ACT in September is probably done - might take it one more time just for the Math section but what a relief to start Junior year knowing most of that grind was behind him. However we are struggling to find a few more “target/safeties” to add to his very small list of schools.
Ok, gotcha. I won’t continue to give you info you already know.
We were thinking the same thing about safeties and targets. Now that this is all over she got into several reaches and got rejected by some safeties. What I think we figured out is the state schools are a different animal for out of state. You mention UF. They are required to take a certain amount of instate students who meet academic thresholds. In addition, they are tuition free. So that changes the dynamic of who your older one were competing against. I think you throw the stats out the window if you are not in state. TX and GA are also the same with their states mandate. I believe the private schools are easier to figure out since everyone is on a level playing field.
I asked this question to one of the Kelly deans at the IU DC event a couple weeks ago. They said Indiana has no mandate to how many instate kids they admit. 85% of Kelley are out of state. Now, I think she also meant that IU as a whole also has no mandate to take instate students but I cannot be certain because we were discussing Kelley school specifically.
Now we thought our kid wasn’t getting into Kelley nor was she getting into some other schools and here she got into Kelley and got into the honors school. She got into UMD, Lehigh, and a few other competitive schools. Yet she was rejected outright by Univ of Tenn. Nothing against Tenn. I’m sure it’s a great school but it’s not these others. So you just have to apply to a lot of schools along the spectrum. I know application fees add up but in the grand scheme its not that much.