Info on these 4 schools

Wow, just wow-if the values the Quakers have espoused for centuries-equality, integrity, charity toward your fellow human beings, stewardship of and peace on Earth-are now “PC” then the Earth could do with a little more PC.

And it should be noted that Haverford no longer has a formal religious affiliation, and students of all races and creeds enroll.

It does have an Honor Code; each applicant can decide if that works for them. It’s clear that the Honor Code and the values listed above don’t work for #16.

Hamilton, Amherst, Williams . . .

It’s actually a fairly long list. It normally means that the college is small and that offers a lot of sports. I often wonder what this says about colleges of “academic excellence” which admit so many students for reasons other than academic attainment. Pretty frustrating for the high achievers who get wait listed or rejected in favor of kids - not just athletes - who get admitted over them for special considerations.

Bill, those colleges don’t match the percent participation at Haverford. And if you look at Haverford’s SAT/GPA numbers, the students accepted are scholar athletes.
It’s also important to note that Haverford lists its value of scholar athletes prominently-so if that’s not for you, there are colleges with a better fit. So don’t see how this could be a cause of “frustration”. It’s all right there on the website.

Let’s go to the actual source of data. There are a number of schools that have equal to or greater sports participation than Haverford…easy to check here: https://ope.ed.gov/athletics/#/institution/search

Using most recent data of unduplicated number of athletes, Haverford has 31.0% students participating in at least one sport. Those with higher rates are Bowdoin 36%, Williams 36.5%, Colby 33%. Amherst at 31.3% is similar to Haverford. Those are the first 4 schools I looked at, I am sure there are more.

The four schools being considered by OP are Haverford, W&L, Amherst, and Hamilton. Didn’t look at any others besides those four; per the Haverford website, intercollegiate athletic participation is 34%.
.

Looks like Haverford is double counting students who play more than one sport. Regardless, now that OP has the actual data source for sport participation they have learned how to ‘fish’…OP never even said they were interested in sports participation %ages.

Yes, but OP did state that daughter wanted to continue participating in her sport at the college level.

NESCACs in general tend to be noted for their active sports participation.

https://www.newsweek.com/25-schools-stocked-jocks-71873

Again, OP is only considering the four school listed.
And that article you posted is almost 10 years old,

Ok I just googled, pc and Haverford and here’s the first article:

http://haverfordclerk.com/we-are-the-7-conservative-students-and-stigmatized-discourse-at-haverford/

Now if I’m researching any college, I’ll try and get as many viewpoints as possible, especially because I can’t visit any right now to get a feel for the campus.

Now here’s the thing I find really interesting, the article above says that conservatives felt stigmatized for their political beliefs, and here on this thread we see that playing out, kind of confirming what the article is saying.

A poster says Haverford is PC, using Fiske as a source, the responses to that:

“And another poster does impressions, not actually knowing any students at Haverford or even having visited the college.”

“Calling an entire campus PC is a patently uninformed critique, clearly issued by someone who has never visited the school .”

“Cherry picking quotes from a source after recommending the poster read it for themselves is kind of weird.”

“And using buzzwords like “PC” also reflects the fact that the poster has zero personal knowledge of Haverford, its students, and its graduates.”

The irony is rich.

Yes, there is all sorts of irony-and all sorts of points of view; for example, is Amherst PC?
https://www.bostonherald.com/2019/03/21/amherst-college-backs-down-on-pc-language-guide/

How about Hamilton?
https://spec.hamilton.edu/the-glaring-lack-of-political-diversity-at-hamilton-and-u-s-colleges-7fd97887002d

How about W&L?
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/removing-portraits-of-washington-and-lee-in-military-attire-is-an-insult/2018/11/02/d6c83924-de26-11e8-8bac-bfe01fcdc3a6_story.html

Yes, there is rich irony in the selective use of Google.

Yeah, let me expand on that a bit. It would seem to me, assuming you have no dog in this race and are just trying to be helpful, that simply pointing the OP to a source is sufficient. I’m pretty familiar with the Fiske Guide and I’m sure they have plenty of nice things to say about Haverford. Picking quotes out of context suggests 1) you have some sort of animus toward the subject or, 2) you don’t trust the OP to form their own opinion. Maybe both.

OP; it’s clear all four schools are solid academically and have a solid athletics program(but check each school for the specific athletic team). It will come down to location and “fit” no doubt, and only your daughter can decide that(with your assistance, of course).

And all have great retention/graduation rates, which reflects the satisfaction of the enrolled students with the school(although I’ll champion Haverford’s 97% one more time…).

She’s got no bad choices; so here’s hoping the virus subsides so you can make campus visits, and until then it’s a good idea to reach out to the team’s coach.

Best of luck with your college selection adventure!

@theloniusmonk: Thank you for posting the cite to the Haverford College newspaper. It is quite helpful & informative.

Doesn’t this comment appear in the margin of Haverford’s entry in Fiske, and aren’t all of Fiske’s marginal comments printed in bold type? If so, the above characterization appears unfair.

No.

If you read this article, I think that you will find that the Fiske Guide comments to be quite gentle & understated.

http://haverfordclerk.com/we-are-the-7-conservative-students-and-stigmatized-discourse-at-haverford/

And don’t miss the articles in #30-it seems calling someone or something “politically correct” works with just about every college. And gee, why no thank you for those articles?

And gee, why no apology ?

“Yes, there is rich irony in the selective use of Google.”

I specifically said that one should research all points of view for a topic like this. I didn’t imply that the other colleges didn’t also have PC issues. I would have googled Amherst if the discussion went that way.

You guys have given us to some great info and things to research. Thanks!!! I’m just glad no decision has to be made soon. I hope at the end of the research and talks with coaches and visits to schools she will have a clear choice on which school she should ED! She has already added Williams to her list!

Does anyone know any schools other than Washington and Lee and Williams that have a short month semester like the winter study and spring semester? She likes that idea and I haven’t heard what other schools might have that.

@merc81 Thanks for sharing that link. I somehow had never been to that site and it sure has some good info!

@Publisher She really loves the no core part about Amherst. She is a high stat kid but you just never know they are looking for. I’m sure everyone that applies to most of these schools are pretty amazing! I’m not sure how it even works with recruiting. I guess it helps but I hear such conflicting things. I’m not sure its her favorite just yet. It’s hard when you haven’t visited a school. We are much closer to W & L than any of the others so it is hard for me not to just push her on that one! ?

@oldlaw I appreciate it! She has reached out and has talked to several coaches. I think with all of this idle time she will probably find a couple of others schools and reach out to them. ? Finding the right school is so important but I know that the coach/team fit will be equally as important.