I played sports at the D3 level and studied engineering. My best grades were actually when my sport was in season. Why? Because while playing I had to manage my time. When out of season, my scheduling got out of control at times and my studies suffered.
Playing sports at a D1 level is a whole other ballgame, but D3 sports aren’t the same commitment to travel and my practices were at a more “study friendly” time.
I’d also avoid the 3-2 programs. Many reasons but one you may not also consider is that you’re starting your career one year later, which can mean leaving your $70k salary on the table for that year.