This. CMU will be just fine without OP. I don’t condone breaking an ED pledge, but if he really had a change of heart, he should apologize and go elsewhere.
A lot depends on what you think is “reasonable.” It clearly could be reasonable to prefer UM over CMU. A number of posters think (and I agree) that it’s also reasonable to expect someone signing a binding agreement to make a reasonable attempt to determine ahead of time how likely it is they will be able to fulfill it, and then make a reasonable attempt to try to fulfill it before saying it can’t be done. It’s not clear if that’s what happened here, but we don’t know the whole story.
On the flip side, the school needs to offer a FA package with a cost that could be reasonably fulfilled by the student and parents if it wants the agreement to be held to. We don’t know if that’s the case either.
It’s not the end of the world if someone just says, “No, I can’t pay this and I’m not going.” It’s just better if people follow the system they enter in to, even if it’s one like ED, which I think has some negative effects overall.
@12345hello123, didn’t you run the net price calculator before applying ED? It is quite disingenuous to go for the slight admissions bump from ED when you likely knew the school was expensive and your aid would be low. Are your parents UNABLE to pay?
The cost differential at full pay is only $5,000 a year between the two if you are OOS at Michigan. In that case, throwing over your ED acceptance at CMU for Michigan seems dishonest. You are just hiding behind the financial argument for other reasons.
@12345hello123
First, I would not want to break the ED agreement, barring extenuating circumstances.
Second, if you’ve been admitted to Carnegie Mellon for CS, I think the extra cost will be worth it.
@Much2learn: The OP isn’t admitted to CMU for CS.
The only way one can justify breaking the ED agreement is if the alternative costs significantly less to attend. Without any aid, Michigan costs roughly $8k/year less than CMU. That’s $30k over 4 years, which is not negligible, especially if that amount will be taken out in loans.
However, if 12345hello123 has a better FA package from CMU, and difference in the cost of attendance is narrowed, I do not think turning CMU down is justified.
Agreed. Given that OP is from California, Berkeley/UCLA/UCSD are the affordable alternatives. All are at least as strong in CS as Michigan and quite a bit cheaper for someone paying full freight; tuition + room/board at Michigan is double the COA at the UCs.
^^^^Wonderful advice, assuming the OP applied or was admitted to one of those schools. There are many top schools across the country, even some of the private ones, where staying in state and attending a stellar public university is the wiser choice.
Your reasons for deciding the CMU is unaffordable are up to you and your family. CMU cannot hold a gun to your head and require that you attend. Contact CMU. Let them know that you won’t be attending. Move on with your life.
While you are at it. Toss out a few more RD and rolling admissons applications to places that will fit your budget. Then decide in April after you have all the aid packages.
I’ll tell you what is not reasonable; institutions of higher learning attempting to force a 17 year old (typically) to attend their school even if they have a change of heart. Top college students, like top college athletes, are “recruited” every year by many schools . The difference between the two is that the top college athlete gets to know which schools will be accepting him before he signs on the dotted line. Not so with the top collegiate students who apply ED. No one should be “shamed” into going some place or paying a single dime to attend any school they are ultimately not enamored with (especially minors!) ED is a game invented by top schools who want to maintain their yield; otherwise they would simply offer EA or RD to those students who were qualified.
Univ of Michigan is by far the better choice. Affordability is the key. Any CS degree is employable out of college. Entry level jobs aren’t terribly lucrative at first, and you don’t want the burden of debt sabotaging your new career.
@rjkofnovi I agree with your post with my whole heart.
OP should talk to the counselor at HS first, but this thread is a few weeks old already and may be too late. For my D’s HS policy, they would only process in state public school application or document submission if one declined an ED offer due to financial reason. The high school counselor do not want a bad reputation for future graduates applying ED at that school. If that is the case, OP actually did not have a choice between these 2 schools. ED is not for anyone, particularly for those who want to compare cost. One should check the cost before applying ED.
OP took advantage of the ED process to get int. Dishonest not to follow through
I think of the ED agreement as being akin to an engagement. The mutual promises to marry are serious and should be made in good faith, but if one of the parties really has a change of heart, it is in everybody’s best interest for the wedding to be called off.
An engagement with a defined “out” - the financial aid award being affordable. In this case OP didn’t get what was expected/hoped for/whatever so is taking that “out”. Nothing dishonest about it.
But I’d advise any student who needs to compare FA packages not to do ED.
Yes OP can definitely rescind ED agreement if FA Is not good enough and attending another institution is substantially cheaper. CMU doesn’t want people to mortgage there future to attend their school.
@coolguy40 (and everyone else):
The OP isn’t a MI resident. They are in CA, so UMich OOS would be barely cheaper than CMU full-pay, if at all.
@PurpleTitan you’re making assumptions, who knows what Michigan is giving him. We know CMU is giving next to nothing.
@CU123: Yes, I am making assumptions, but it seems very unlikely that UMich would give an OOS applicant better fin aid than CMU would to an ED applicant. And UMich merit scholarships for OOS are small and extremely hard to get.