<p>Hi, dstark:</p>
<p>Agree with you that the overvaluation is not a good comparison and I tried to make that clear in my post. For clarity: I do not have a real estate crystal ball. I do, however, have a good view of history, economics and human nature. </p>
<p>The comparison I am trying to make is the widespread public interest in real estate “investing” is quite similar to the NASDAQ boom/bust. Or, the famous stock market crash of 1929. Its the madness of crowds. That is the comparison…the same attitude that existed then that “stocks always went up”. No, sometimes they don’t. </p>
<p>It could be that insiders in the nations largest homebuilders are wondering if the boom will continue. It was just reported today that insiders sold 26 times as much stock of their own companies as they bought this year, more than double the 11 to one margin last year. </p>
<p>I might also point out to potential real estate investors/speculators that Japans real estate market peaked two years after its stock market bubble burst and real estate in Japan has declined in price every year since…13 years…until this year. Again, I am not making a comparison of valuations or making predictions. Just pointing out that real estate can go down in perceived valuation, and can do it for a long time.</p>
<p>Please allow me to make additional comments on two statements made in this thread.</p>
<ol>
<li><p>“low interest rates and creative financing have changed the game”. For millions of American families, I am sure low interest rates will turn out to be a great blessing. However, I have my doubts about the so-called “creative financing”. There are people living in homes in my neighborhood who were only able to purchase by using very creative financing…interest only adjustable rate mortgages. Someday, I predict many of these families will not be able to afford their mortgage payments. So, they may have only changed the game temporarily. Mortgage money may not always be as easy to obtain as it is now. Though, I am not predicting that easy money will dry up in the immediate future. It will not. </p></li>
<li><p>“The refinancing craze really helped people”. It also has hurt many people by allowing them to turn their home into an ATM. Let me give you two anectdotal stories. First, you may have heard of the Philadelphia Eagles football fans who flocked to mortgage companies to refi their homes so they could buy $8k SuperBowl packages at Jacksonville. If memory serves me correctly, the Eagles lost that game. I am sure some of those refinancers who were in attendance had “buyers remorse”. Refinancing craze is right. Second, a mortgage broker friend of mine tells me that a large percentage of his business is repeat customers coming to take out their home equity, so they can squander it on vacations, Hummers, boats, etc. i don’t think that it is helpful to turn home equity into entertainment or a depreciating asset. I am not saying all people behaved in this manner, but enough have done so that it makes one question how some of our neighbors are going to fare if the economy were to turn sour, if the job market dry up, if interest rates were to increase substantially and, perhaps worst of all, that precious re-fi money become hard to obtain.</p></li>
</ol>
<p>Don’t get me wrong, I am a big believer in owning real estate. Very few investments can protect you from inflation the way real estate can. However, much of what is happening in real estate today is speculative and over-leverage, not investment. </p>
<p>Best to all.</p>