Not crazy obviously. Gut reactions matter. I went to Michigan 40 years ago and was very unhappy there. I had been pushed into going. I have spent many decades since trying to convince myself that I liked it given all it’s good qualities. It certainly has those. But it just wasn’t for me. Land was too flat. Sports was too big a theme even though it has high academics. Too many modern buildings even though it does have some older stuff. Town was too small. I’m from New York City and was used to a much bigger, more lively environment. And the skies were too gray. It depressed me. I don’t mind winter weather but need to see some blue in the sky. I know people who liked it there. It has every major. They take better care of undergrads than most big schools (not so much in my day but today). But it wasn’t for me. It was like marrying somebody who is a fine person who is meant for someone else. Looking back, I’d say the most important thing about choosing a college is the fit - not the reputation. Only you really know what you like. Others cannot dictate it to you. You have a lot of work ahead of you and you have to be relatively comfortable with the place and its culture. Maybe visit it again and see how you feel.